Aug 26, 2015
Gender issues are always a touchy subject and they are usually approached in a “gentle”, serious manner, but this is not the case with F. Compo. Not as much because the method is crude, but as its main focus is not the journey of self-discovery. F. Compo is all about comedy with traces of drama along the way. By all means, this is no recipe for disaster, although in this case a lot of things did not mix well together.
There is no profound story, or any actual story at all for that matter; it is about the everyday life of various characters and their daily
...
adventures from simple things such as helping a friend to fighting with one’s self over accepting and being who one truly is. It is simple and nice and it could have worked great, if only the humor was up to par most of the time. Almost every problem, misunderstanding, joke, etc. revolves around a gender issue theme, be it either having the main character cross-dress against his will and thus, creating more trouble or having people turning gay at the drop of a hat, just because. There is no wide variety when it comes to comedy so it can only get stale after the usage of the same jokes, which most of the time are shallow and become very annoying in a long running manga.
The drama aspect of it has higher value as some stories portray better certain situations and circumstances and can make the reader empathize with the characters. Unfortunately, it is not enough to save the entire work, since the comedy is the strongest genre of it and sometimes affects it and also, there is unnecessary or badly executed drama at times. For instance, the romance is at a pretty low point, because it appears only to showcase a new (or repeated) problem with a dramatic finish and otherwise, it is forgotten. As a result, the pacing is pretty poor even for a seemingly relaxing slice of life manga.
The characters are also abused by the comedy, unfortunately. Especially the main character, whose main trait is naivety, so it is just so easy for various predicaments to happen to him alllllll the time. The development is small, since as mentioned, this is not a manga about any serious issue, so everything that happens is essentially for the comedy and often lacks a more thorough thought or explanation for the readers. That being said, at least it is not nonexistent and there is progress when genuine problems come up and we see the main cast, but also the secondary one to think more seriously. All of them are likable, though some can be really tiring with their repetitive jokes (again) and almost everyone has a story to tell, something that is always positive as the readers can see parts of everyone’s lives or pasts. However, most of the characters do not have any great impact.
F. Compo has a realistic art with a richness of facial expressions. It also manages to handle well the cross-dressing, yet there are times that I feel some characters have the same trait as Superman; just take off your glasses and no one could recognize you anymore. Sometimes it is just too obvious when who is dressed what and it makes no sense for other people not to realize this. The backgrounds are not notable and while most characters seem unique, some look more generic. All in all, the art is simple but sufficient and it delivers.
Personally, I assumed this would be more serious and although I was not discouraged when I figured out that it is not as I had imagined, it disappointed me greatly with its overuse of shallow gender jokes and then the lack of any deep thought at its majority or the misuse of such thoughts and the random events that happened that made me think the creator had run out of inspiration. This could have been so much more heart-warming, but it always ran around in circles.
Reviewer’s Rating: 4
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
