Drawing: Saikyou Mangaka wa Oekaki Skill de Isekai Musou suru!

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

6.7/10


Reading this manga brings forth a nostalgic feeling of when isekai trash was my forte. Though, this is a bit different purely because it’s concept. Besides for that, the plot is the same-old predictable cliches and events every weeb has seen before. To add to that, the conflict or events are entirely forced as nothing feels like a “natural” occurrence. Not only are the conflicts forced, they are incredibly slow-paced as a singular fight may take upward to four or five chapters of mindless scrolling.

Characters in mangas tend to be on the more vulnerable side in personality; but in this, especially in the later ... chapters, characters act different from their set personality and details seem to have been forgotten. There’s also an emphasis on side characters, but there are so many that it causes a side effect of making each of them the very more forgettable.

The manga doesn’t have much redeemable qualities besides for the mc’s summoning ability, which is downplayed to hype up his eventual fight. That being said, it’s still rather enjoyable ni matter how cliche it may be. It didn’t amount to what it could’ve been in the first few chapters, but it’s something.


Reading Rankings (Portnoy inspired + A Huang-Teizan Original)
10 - God’s penmanship
9 - Must-read. Drop everything else.
8 - Instant bookmark
7 - Entertaining
6 - Good to pass time
5 - Why are you reading this?
4 - Bad.
3 - Typical garbage.
2 - My head hurts.
1 - Retirement is a thought.
0 - “Did they even give you a story?!”

I have been keeping up with this title for many months only to feel let down by the direction it's taking. So I have decided it is time to leave a review.

It's...just not good. Sure you got a cool story of Isekai and a bro who can summon stuff, but the execution sucks.

We got a story which doesn't make sense. The Greatest Mangaka has seriously bad pacing issues. It is skipping a ton of imnportant detials and leaving too many questions which interfere with the story.

Actually even I don't understand what's the story at this point? Everything is just happening so fast, so randomly, it's ... preventing me from being invested. There are so many characters and women...I am finding it hard to keep up with the progress.

First and foremost this has a demographic category of seinen but in reality it is shounen or rather I cannot differentiate between other similar fantasy/isekai romance.

Story 5/10 Mediocre

Action Adventure Drama Ecchi Fantasy Mature Romance Seinen according to mangaupdates
Genres: Adventure, Fantasy
Themes: Isekai, Reincarnation According to myanimelist

In that sense MyAnimelist made a more perfect description.
There is an adventure element and fantasy but Mature/Seinen is a lie maybe some resemblance to romance and high potential for harem.
The story is as usual about a reincarnator who was at the time 30y old.......The problem is author probably forgot about that after ... 20-30ch. And even earlier but by chapter 20-30 there is no wisdom of 30y old.
The story touches reincarnation which is a deep philosophical question, it depends on the person of course but you know that your mortal struggles are just YOUR mortal struggles on this planet in this universe. So any concept of of doom is destroyed because the mystery of life has been solved by MC. So in regards of being 30y + of life experience + knowledge of death and reincarnation should have made him if not intelligent but at least full of wisdom.
From the get go we see inconsistency, that only shows that author despite his age doesn't know what he is doing or writing. He tried to make a seinen but made a shounen. Plot armor and friendship. Any negativism will be overshadowed and eventually turned to positivism.
MC wanted a peaceful life but well he didn't get it eventually he is thrown in all kinds of trouble BUT he doesn't hold grudges or displeasure for being thrown like a piece of chess board by everyone even other pawns.
Generally speaking mediocre isekai manga which we saw hundreds of times before. MC without character with a heart of impressionable YOUTH, potential harem members, MC is op but there is an evil organization which is more powerful with their usual idiotic conspiracy.
In seinen content I expect material to be less about EVIL vs GOOD but many layers of grey. Where characters have both their motivations and convictions. Here I see MC's statements being destroyed by others. People apologize for dragging him but he doesn't mind it and even convinces himself that he is doing it for the better future, for family and etc. Maybe things will change but to ch 64 I've only seen the shounen route.
The problem is you can easily predict the future of this manga. It's average.
Bad people are Bad there is no speck of redeeming character in them. Good have to prove they are good despite evil has free hands for no apparent reason. Some powerful characters have plot holes(+story plot holes), conspiracy is brewing they don't see anything their information network is 0. Basically author created artificial fast food manga.

Art 8/10

Characters and background are well drawn (characters are detailed) + fan art with many bit breasted females...... Panel placement and speech bubbles up to a standard

Characters 6/10

Hard to say here, I explained in the story about MC.
MC - 30+ years old reincarnator who has 0 wisdom despite his past life and knowing about death and life. To a degree spineless, his convictions are easily swayed (ego) by hero architype convictions. His actions are seen as heroic while on deep dive you understand during tournament arc at least he made people suffer for no apparent reason while he already understood he could stop it anytime. Despite his age (mental age) he is easily influenced by tears, fluffy words and seducement. If he wasn't a reincarnator I would sweep every statement under the mat but IF AUTHOR decided to make his story like that he should also be accountable for critique that goes with his choices.
Other characters are.....2 dimensional I cannot even say if there are other Main cast for now everyone is supporting cast. Mysterious people, Big boobs of justice, Big Boobs of something else and Evil psychopaths'.

Enjoyment 4/10
Enjoyment is subjective, but I cannot enjoy something that was copy/pasted 100 of times with stupid clichés. In my personal library before chapter 10 i had it at 5/5 now it's is in 3/5. The inception was nice I thought maybe something different will come out but i was disappointed after initial chapters author turned towards vanilla Japanese copy/paste industry. If you put demographic seinen i expect more mature content. If you create a character who is 45 years old mentally I expect this character to be at least with some wisdom due to age but he even was given prequel of being successful author who i would suspect was somewhat intelligent and rich enough to understand the complexity of the upper strata life.

Overall 6/10 (5/10)

I would recommend only if you are new to the anime/manga industry or if you are completely bored and there is no interesting content. Plot armor, power of friendship is strong here. Author stepped on to mature ground but fell through right after taking those few steps. I suspect he understood that his main demographic are impressionable, sexless boys so he decided to revert back to his usual works. Sad to see that despite 10 year difference author didn't mature his content, I liked Freezing series but I was younger back then I've only started transition from Anime to manga and getting to know Japanese nerd industry but with age and library over 1000 mangas behind my back this manga is an epitome of mediocracy, popcorn and fast food. Good for 15y old with small knowledge of manga industry (btw pretty unhealthy) and something that leaves a stomach pain and diarrhea to older veterans.
Seen worse, seen better Im, Dal Young ty for Freezing series when i was younger but you didn't change much If you put seinen in your work because you have a lot of ECCHI content that doesn't mean that it was made for seinen demographic I hold Japanese younger adults in higher regard than you.