After dedicating 3 months of my life to catching up to this behemoth of a show, I feel obligated to say something about my journey. Was it worth it? To be able to tell people that I've caught up to One Piece, yes. Was it worth it in terms of the story and plot? Eh. One Piece really needs no introduction to the anime scene and I heard about it years before taking the plunge and reading over 1000 chapters. Everyone around me always talked on and on about Whitebeard this, Wano that, and I guess you could say I wanted a taste of that
...
drink. And now here we are, 1014 chapters and 3 months later, I can finally say "I'm caught up to One Piece". Now with the burning question, did it live up to the hype? For the most part, no, but some parts, yes. Overall, I would say I'm satisfied with my experience. Not happy, not overjoyed, not sad, just satisfied.
Story: 7
Some times the story was at a solid 8 and some times it was at an eye gouging 5-6. So I'll just leave it at an average 7. No one really voices this opinion much so I'll take the center stage in saying it. Pre time skip was far better than post time skip. The only arc I actually liked in post time skip was Whole Cake, the rest were a hollow shell of what One Piece was. The best section of One Piece's story was from Water 7-Marineford (Minus Thriller Bark). After that the story had a pretty sudden halt in quality and pacing. However, during that Water 7-Marineford span, I would totally say One Piece was worth the read. I was knocking out 40+ chapters per day during those arcs. Enies Lobby is easily my favorite arc and it is a contender for being on my top arcs list. I'll go ahead and show my ranking of the arcs so you can see my thoughts.
1. Enies Lobby - 8.5
2. Water 7 - 8
3. Whole Cake Island - 8
4. Sabaody Archipelago - 7.5
5. Impel Down - 7.5
6. Marineford - 7
7. Amazon Lily - 7
8. Alabasta - 7
9. Return To Sabaody - 7
10. Wano - 7
11. Post Enies Lobby - 7
12. Dressrosa - 7
13. Zou - 7
14. Levely - 7
15. Skypiea - 6.5
16. Fishman Island - 6.5
17. Thriller Bark - 6.5
18. Post-War - 6.5
19. Punk Hazard - 6
20. East Blue - 5
(I know Enies Lobby is technically a sub arc of Water 7, but since its such a step up in quality and it being actually longer than Water 7, I think it deserves it's own spot).
I want to say One Piece has some of the best plot in anime, but in reality, that credit should go to it's world building. Like 95% of all arcs in One Piece follow the exact same formula over and over again. But thanks to it's fantastic world building, people seem blind to that fact. The Straw Hats show up, main villain introduced and shows how much they screwed up the island. Straw Hats go to attack main villain, main villains henchmen hierarchy shows up and slows them down. Backstories of arc characters and how the island ended up that way ensue, and then the Straw Hats come up with a long shot 1 in a million chance of success plan that always works and then Luffy has a final fight with main villain. Giant feast at the end, Marines come but the Straw Hats escape at the last second, They go to next island, repeat. Every. Single. Arc. Has this exact same formula and it's pretty blatant after the 3rd arc using it. Whole Cake was a entire carbon copy of Water 7. Instead of Robin it was Sanji, instead of CP9 it was the Big Mom pirates, instead of Lucci it was Katakuri. It was just so noticeable, but luckily it was made very well. Overall, I think OP is carried heavily by its masterful world building but I digress, some of the arcs were solid on their own.
Art: 7
Read the manga and the art style was very solid, it takes dedication to produce that kind of quality for over 20 years.
Characters: 8
Along with world building, another thing One Piece does very well is developing their side characters. Though tedious at times, you spend some time in the arcs to build up the backstories of arc characters and why they need the Straw Hats help etc. Sometimes I did feel it was unnecessary while other times I felt that it enhanced the story ten fold. As for the main crew, I think most of them are extremely solid, however I still hate Usopp, don't know why, I just do. Luffy is for the most part fine, but he still plays on several cliche shonen mc tropes. The villains in the arcs are hit or miss, CP9 were fantastic while Caeser The Clown and Gecko Moria were less than interesting. A lot of some times it was good and some times it was bad. But the pro's out weigh the con's in terms of characters. And Mihawk is the best character in One Piece sorry bout it.
Enjoyment: 6
Once again, during Enies Lobby it was an 8-8.5 and during East Blue it was around a 4-5. My Enjoyment drastically changed depending on the arcs, but there were more enjoyable arcs than not enjoyable so I'll give it the benefit of a 6. It really just depended on how well the characters flowed in the arc and especially if the main villain was an actual force to be reckoned with. I was actually worried the Straw Hats would lose against Dolflamingo and CP9, but I wasn't the least bit intimidated by Hordy Jones. These factors made it impossible to predict whether I would like an arc or not, but overall it was a fun ride.
Overall: 6.5
To be honest I think I started and finished One Piece just so I could say I've finished it rather than actually being invested in the show. But you can only read so many chapters before starting to take part in the journey this manga takes you on. There were a lot of sometimes I liked it and some times I didn't in that review but that's mainly because of how long this show is. Some arcs could be it's own show so my opinion changes every time they switch gears to a new arc. I think One Piece is objectively a very solid show but it did not personally bring me in on several occasions so unfortunately I can't join the crowd of people saying it's one of the best anime ever made. On the contrary, I won't be on the side calling it an overrated dumpster fire, so rest assured. It's just a nice show that gave me a satisfying experience, nothing more, nothing less.
Alternative TitlesJapanese: ONE PIECE More titlesInformationType: Manga
Volumes: Unknown
Chapters: Unknown
Status: Publishing
Published: Jul 22, 1997 to ?
Demographic:
Shounen
Serialization:
Shounen Jump (Weekly) Authors:
Oda, Eiichiro (Story & Art) Statistics Ranked: #42 2 based on the top manga page. Please note that 'R18+' titles are excluded. Popularity: #4
Members: 643,226
Favorites: 120,037 Available AtResources | Reviews
Filtered Results: 208 / 232
Sort
Your Feelings Categories May 31, 2021
After dedicating 3 months of my life to catching up to this behemoth of a show, I feel obligated to say something about my journey. Was it worth it? To be able to tell people that I've caught up to One Piece, yes. Was it worth it in terms of the story and plot? Eh. One Piece really needs no introduction to the anime scene and I heard about it years before taking the plunge and reading over 1000 chapters. Everyone around me always talked on and on about Whitebeard this, Wano that, and I guess you could say I wanted a taste of that
...
Apr 19, 2021
I'm actually trying to understand why this manga in the top three.
1010 chapters of non-since structure. repeated scenarios and ambiguous power in addition to bad character development like any other normal manga (low-rated manga). From the beginning up to the now, the same scenario where Luffy loses the fight and wakes up to beat his enemy, how many times this scenario has been repeated? 1010 chapters contain disgusting character development, going into each chapter and hoping that this chapter will increase something in rating criteria, but unfortunately, nothing changes. Creating many characters that will make the reader happy, because when one piece fan joins any anime discussion he ... Mar 31, 2024
It is significantly hard to write a review of any manga that is more than 1000 chapters, and especially one as popular as One Piece and make it worthwhile, but I think there's a way.
Simply put I started One Piece expecting to give up around couple hundred chapters in when I got bored, when it was too filler heavy, or when it felt like it wasn't valuing my time. 1000 chapters later, I would honestly say it never even got close to any of those marks. I am honestly quite shocked because I intended to be extra critical. There's a reason this ... Jul 11, 2023
A Racist government that enslave and discriminate certain races. An extremely loyal pirate crew who hate enslavement, discrimination and wasting food. A captain who will fight against the whole world(literally) for his nakama.
A legendary treasure capable of turning the world upside down. A mysterious clan waiting for 800 years for a certain person. A story in which antagonist and protagonist have the same ideology- "People's dream never end". People who won't sell out their friends even if it means their country is destroyed. Is 78 years too old ? One arm not enough to rule the seas? An outsider shouldn't save a country? ... Feb 17, 2019
One Piece is without a doubt something that is worthy to be called "King of Shounen," and for many great reasons. It is tough to miss since its popularity is mind blowing and growing at a rapid rate and it's everywhere. It has almost overtaken "Batman" comics, and it is not so far off anymore actually. Now, It has already set its sight on "Superman" comics, and I would say it has a perfect shot at the 1st spot too if it keeps selling like bread and butter as it has done for so many years already.
However, the popularity is justified, and it shows in ... Apr 19, 2015
How do I love thee? Let me count the ways
This series is where it all began for me. The "Romance Dawn" if you will. I remember starting the fifth grade back in 2007, I hit it off real quickly with this one boy in my class. We had loads of things in common and were constantly sharing new interests. One thing we didn't share was his love anime and manga. This wasn't because I didn't like it, rather I just hadn't experienced it yet. One day he shoved One Piece volumes 1-3 in my backpack and told that I would love it. And love it ... Apr 24, 2011
Leader of the big three in Japan. Categorized as consistently getting better with every story arc that passes. Praised for its unique art style which is called both grotesque and absurdly appropriate.
Know this, its a fantastic manga. 80-90% of the people who don't read it are people who were influenced badly by the art or the horrible 4kids dub which destroyed its image or just had trouble getting past the slow beginning. But people who truly don't like the series aren't that common. Don't judge this one quickly whatever you do. Read 100 or even 200 chapters ... Mar 31, 2019
One Piece is the most charming, heartwarming, heartbreaking, unique, well-thought out fiction I have ever read. It was life-changing for me to be honest. It manages to be hilarious while teaching amazing lessons, heartbreaking while still instilling feelings of hope, have a unique art style while still being visually stunning, etc.
It's often been said that the characters don't develop at all, and while I understand that claim, I don't agree. Characters like Robin manage to do a 180 throughout the course of the series while still retaining the core traits that made you like them in the first place. Every moment of One Piece for me ... Aug 16, 2015
Now the best selling manga of all time, One Piece is the tale of a man named Luffy who is gonna become king of the pirates. In face of this long-running manga, that summary does many injustices; in essence, One Piece is a story of the Strawhat Pirates setting out to follow their dreams. This overview is going to be a bit long, but hang tight with me and I'll give you as much of an comprehensive overview as I can on this monster of a series.
My criticisms of the manga are as follows: as the manga goes on, the skinnier women get less and ... Oct 29, 2024
Let me tell you about my experience with One Piece. Seven years ago, a friend pressured me into reading it. How did he sell it to me? “The fights are amazing,” he said, and in his words, “It gets good with Doflamingo.” Ah, the innocence and ignorance of my friend. I read it, got as far as Dressrosa, somewhere around chapter 732, and then I dropped it.
The problem with One Piece and some of its fans is that they try to sell the manga as if it were like Dragon Ball, Naruto, Bleach, MHA, JJK, or KnY. The truth is, it’s not. This isn’t to ... Sep 13, 2023
I'm late to the party but yes, there's a reason One Piece is one of the most beloved mangas ever published: it's amazing. While I'm only a quarter into the manga, I have read enough to know I have more greatness to enjoy.
The art is great and keeps on getting better as you go along and perfectly complements the wacky universe Oda created. You really have it all: a charismatic cast of larger-than-life villains and heroes, a gargantuan world that sketches itself out at a timely pace, ridiculously fun and creative fights, and epic arcs. There is true passion and love infused into this carefully ... Nov 3, 2021
The most overrated manga of all time.
First of all, I’m actually one that enjoys the series, however I can’t be denied that (unlike most of their fandom believes) the series is far from perfect. (although that also doesn’t mean that is terrible) I’d try to be as impartial as I can, so I’ll start by mentioning some of the good and great stuff of the manga, and by that, we can’t review this without mentioning how awesome is the world building by Oda, truly is masterful, probably the best aspect of the series, since it’s adventure based, he does it in such a magnificent ... Sep 9, 2024
One Piece is a series that has much of what you want but also leaves a lot to be desired. There are many things the series does quite well, and there are many things it just does not do or fails to do at an adequate/consistent level. I’ll give two examples. One is one pieces world building and how grand and ambitious it is, alongside its narrative. This is does well but it also is a double-edged sword because my next example is…Character Writing in One Piece I believe is awful. Especially considering how long it is. There are too many characters, too many places,
...
May 25, 2024
One Piece is not like any manga out there. If you can get past its length, and find the characters likeable, it's dang near perfect. One Piece is one of the only mangas that have had me pulling all-nighters just because an arc is THAT good. One Piece seems like a goofy pirate adventure, but it turns into this emotional master piece 400 or 500 chapters in. From the start, you're immediately teased with what is to come. Just from the East Blue, you can tell that the Straw Hats will definitely be on a grander journey than the one in the first 100 chapters.
...
Feb 8, 2024
It's a pretty good manga. It's just not for me. And that's fine, if some people enjoy it, they enjoy it.
However, I will say my piece. The beginning starts off great, with the East Blue saga being a pretty good introduction to One Piece. We saw our first group of characters, Nami got her arc, and it was well done. The entire series is done fairly well. So why don't I like it. It is just far too long, with little to no stakes. I get that the journey is the point, you're supposed to derive enjoyment from just watching the gang have fun ... Jun 16, 2023
So, here we are. After such a long time I finally got around to diving into the oceans of One Piece and a few years later, I have almost caught up with this insane manga. And finally, I feel qualified to share my thoughts. So is One Piece really one of the best manga series of all time? Yes! Should you read it, even today? Absolutely! And no, you don't need to get to chapter (whatever) for it to "get good", I was pretty much hooked by chapter 10 or so.
I'd like to preface this by saying, its kind of surprising that a series as ... Jun 9, 2015
The world is full of mysteries and miracles! As corny as it sounds, that's what we tried to show in his work Oda-sama. Will he? Of course! This story shows us not only the life of the dreamer, striving to find something legendary, but also that the dreamer is willing to take a chance for many of his friends, even the dream. It becomes stronger, seeking recognition of his love for his hope, and he sees it. But the world is not so simple, it teaches one, sometimes painful, sometimes happy, that all the difficulties of life and its sweet moments experiencing Monkey D. Luffy
...
Sep 5, 2015
I first started reading One Piece about 5 years ago and no matter how hard I tried I just couldn't get into the series. I will admit I fell for the classic problem at the beginning of a series with "the artwork." It drove me insane. So I dropped the series and came back to it about 2 years ago and boy am I happy I did. Once I managed to push through those first few chapters, this series dragged into depths of fandom I'd never experienced before.
Story: 10 This comedic adventure is set in a place where pirates roamed the earth. Our protagonist Luffy sets ... Jun 4, 2015
This may be the one of the best shonen battle manga ever read, the story about a pirate that is trying to fine the One piece to become the pirate king. The main character traveling around the world meeting new friends and making the coolest crew mates of the sea. Every adventures is a unique story were the main character and his friends fight with many enemies that including the navy and the marines. I give this manga 10 because it took me a lot of time to appreciate this work of art, the first time i saw One piece i thought it was a
...
Mar 26, 2012
To simply state, every theme that is desired from a Shounen Manga is included in One Piece. I would say the overall perspective of One Piece can be mirrored to that of The Lion King. It's impossible to dislike the Lion King, because it addressed so many themes that relate to ourselves and society. The same goes for One Piece. One Piece addresses the importance of Friends, Family, Trust, Goal Orientation, Belief, Happiness, Sadness, and all the common themes that make us go through the day and want to read page from page. Each journey and island that is included in the making of the
...
|