| miura planned everything to the final chapter 30 years ago (before golden age) and only told his friend and it's followed that plan near perfectly so should he tell the rest of the story or not. as well as that he did say they will only do what miura said so some parts will not work well if they forgot a reason for soemthing to happen and whatnot they even said it wont be perfect but it will only be what miura said nothing else. Q1: Is It Monthly Now? (Hello this is me after reading the new chapters. If I didn't know Miura passed away I would've assumed he wrote these chapters cause they're masterful. I loved them. They were breathtaking.) |
BellaceAug 6, 2022 10:54 AM
 [/url] |
| Thanks, we can read the official post too. |
 |
KneelBeforeMe said: Thanks, we can read the official post too. I know but I have some questions. Is it Monthly now? And I want to do a poll to see what people think. Thanks for commenting |
| [/url] |
KneelBeforeMe said: Thanks, we can read the official post too. Hey, you've been on this site for a while based off your knowledge of MAL do you think this will drop its score on MAL and ruin it's legacy? |
| [/url] |
Bellace said: Not necessarily monthly, most likely like Vinland Saga which is month to month at times and sometimes has longer span in between chapters.KneelBeforeMe said: Thanks, we can read the official post too. I know but I have some questions. Is it Monthly now? And I want to do a poll to see what people think. Thanks for commenting Bellace said: No idea, can't speak for others. My rating will remain a 10 no matter what.KneelBeforeMe said: Thanks, we can read the official post too. Hey, you've been on this site for a while based off your knowledge of MAL do you think this will drop its score on MAL and ruin it's legacy? |
|
KneelBeforeMe said: Bellace said: Not necessarily monthly, most likely like Vinland Saga which is month to month at times and sometimes has longer span in between chapters.I know but I have some questions. Is it Monthly now? And I want to do a poll to see what people think. Thanks for commenting Bellace said: No idea, can't speak for others. My rating will remain a 10 no matter what.Hey, you've been on this site for a while based off your knowledge of MAL do you think this will drop its score on MAL and ruin it's legacy? Same, thanks for your input. |
| [/url] |
Bellace said: MIURA PLANNED EVERYTHING TO THE FINAL CHAPTER 30 YEARS AGO (before Golden Age) AND ONLY TOLD HIS FRIEND AND IT'S FOLLOWED THAT PLAN NEAR PERFECTLY SO SHOULD HE TELL THE REST OF THE STORY OR NOT. what happened to this said friend , is he still around/involved? |
 |
kushmonatl said: Bellace said: MIURA PLANNED EVERYTHING TO THE FINAL CHAPTER 30 YEARS AGO (before Golden Age) AND ONLY TOLD HIS FRIEND AND IT'S FOLLOWED THAT PLAN NEAR PERFECTLY SO SHOULD HE TELL THE REST OF THE STORY OR NOT. what happened to this said friend , is he still around/involved? Hes the main one writing and supervising using his memory of what Miura said (he admitted he forgot some so it wont be perfect) His name is : Kouji Mori (mangaka himself) His MAL Profile:https://myanimelist.net/people/6748/Kouji_Mori |
BellaceJun 7, 2022 11:30 AM
| [/url] |
Bellace said: Hes the main one writing and supervising using his memory of what Miura said (he admitted he forgot some so it wont be perfect) His name is : Kouji Mori (mangaka himself) His MAL Profile:https://myanimelist.net/people/6748/Kouji_Mori okay .. its in safe hands then |
|
| Fantasia was already extremely underwhelming, it can't be much worse. The quality should continue to be the same as if Miura was working on it himself since he individually prepared his assistants for something like this and has basically told them almost exactly what to do(Except maybe not art wise, but we won't know for sure). |
  |
Stone76 said: Fantasia was already extremely underwhelming, it can't be much worse. The quality should continue to be the same as if Miura was working on it himself since he individually prepared his assistants for something like this and has basically told them almost exactly what to do(Except maybe not art wise, but we won't know for sure). From what I've heard the next arc will be basically Griffith vs. Guts and Gut's Gang of Friends coming to help him tracking him down. We will have a fight tho between Griffith and Guts. |
BellaceJun 7, 2022 2:37 PM
| [/url] |
Stone76 said: Fantasia was already extremely underwhelming, it can't be much worse. The quality should continue to be the same as if Miura was working on it himself since he individually prepared his assistants for something like this and has basically told them almost exactly what to do(Except maybe not art wise, but we won't know for sure). I think Fantasia was picking up steam right at the very end .. - Casca finally got her memory back - Farnese / Witch girl was about to get their power up - We saw the backstory of Skull Knight - Morda was prob about to join clan - Rickert joined forces with the Desert Ninjas - they brought back the prostitutes that were helping Casca .. future allies of Guts and Casca once they evade - showed the dynamics of Falconia .. a new age world with state-of-the-art technology ,, demon cave at the tail end of the city .. Sea God arc of Fantasia was trash ,, but everything after that was some Top-Tier Berserk storytelling |
|
kushmonatl said: Stone76 said: Fantasia was already extremely underwhelming, it can't be much worse. The quality should continue to be the same as if Miura was working on it himself since he individually prepared his assistants for something like this and has basically told them almost exactly what to do(Except maybe not art wise, but we won't know for sure). I think Fantasia was picking up steam right at the very end .. - Casca finally got her memory back - Farnese / Witch girl was about to get their power up - We saw the backstory of Skull Knight - Morda was prob about to join clan - Rickert joined forces with the Desert Ninjas - they brought back the prostitutes that were helping Casca .. future allies of Guts and Casca once they evade - showed the dynamics of Falconia .. a new age world with state-of-the-art technology ,, demon cave at the tail end of the city .. Sea God arc of Fantasia was trash ,, but everything after that was some Top-Tier Berserk storytelling Sea god arc art was peak art in berserk imo, hope the next 2 chapters arent more cliffhangers. |
| [/url] |
Bellace said: kushmonatl said: I think Fantasia was picking up steam right at the very end .. - Casca finally got her memory back - Farnese / Witch girl was about to get their power up - We saw the backstory of Skull Knight - Morda was prob about to join clan - Rickert joined forces with the Desert Ninjas - they brought back the prostitutes that were helping Casca .. future allies of Guts and Casca once they evade - showed the dynamics of Falconia .. a new age world with state-of-the-art technology ,, demon cave at the tail end of the city .. Sea God arc of Fantasia was trash ,, but everything after that was some Top-Tier Berserk storytelling Sea god arc art was peak art in berserk imo, hope the next 2 chapters arent more cliffhangers. lol the art may have been good but the story .... not so much |
|
kushmonatl said: Bellace said: Sea god arc art was peak art in berserk imo, hope the next 2 chapters arent more cliffhangers. lol the art may have been good but the story .... not so much Yeah, it took me 2 months to read that part versus 2 days to get through the arc before. it's the arc where i think even sao surpasses its quality in that area. |
| [/url] |
| I wouldn't go as far as to say it would ruin it seeing as Studio Gaga is still behind it, but Mori isn't really the best writer around. Most of his works have used their storytelling as a vehicle for whatever the manga itself seems to be about conceptually (street fighting in the case of Holyland for example). Most of his manga also tend to devolve into an escapist power fantasy type deal. I also think his characters and the ways in which they tend to develop is very hit-or-miss, but having Miura's notes may alleviate that to an extent. All in all, this feels unnecessary as Berserk was always about the journey more than anything, but I may be in the minority here. |
 |
| No, it won't. The one picking it back up is going to reproduce whatever he remembers of what Miura has told him of Berserk. So while things may not be fleshed out, the major over-arching plot is going to be nearly the same as if Miura was writing it. |
 |
| No Berserk finally has a chance to once again take the throne back from AOT as the peak fiction after the latter stole it with chapter 131. I am glad Berserk gets a chance to resume its greatness. |
| End Zionazism |
Patricku16 said: Idoreview said: it's the best Case scenario for what happened. Ask yourself the question how could berserk resume without miura. Would you have liked them to Hire an author or mangaka who doesnt understand the story and just go along with what they think would happen? Or the Bestfriend of the author who knew how the story would conclude joined the team miura trained for berserk's artstyle?That sounds like complete trash. What a terrible fate for the best manga ever. What a horrid thing for an alleged friend to do to a dead friend's life's work! It makes me a bit nauseous, honestly. i would like if berserk ended with miura since it felt like guts and his universe and art and how it all was connected to miura and without him it wouldnt hit as hard. |
| [/url] |
24846 said: Mikasa said: No Berserk finally has a chance to once again take the throne back from AOT as the peak fiction after the latter stole it with chapter 131. I am glad Berserk gets a chance to resume its greatness. Lol. Attack on titan peak? Bro has to read more stuff. S1-3 is generic shonan. 1 dimensional characters (mikasa, potatoe girl), tonal inconsistency (though that’s a problem with most shonan), the themes it explores has been done better in other series (race and war is done better in legend of the galactic hero’s, freedom is done better in Vinland saga). The themes it explores are done very shonany and simiplistic imo Incorrect but you gets points for trying. |
| End Zionazism |
24846 said: lol. Ok, 1 dimensional characters= when the potatoe girl is dying her last words are what’s for dinner or some shit like that. Emphasising her 1 persanality trait ti try and get some cheap emotional feelings out the audience S1-3 eran doesn’t develop (other then towards the end of s3). He just stays the same like a typical shonan protagonist. You would think maybe after seeing consequences for his actions he would change or something but no, he just has the same goal of killing titans no matter what. This problem doesn’t get fixed until late s3 and s4 Tonal inconsistency: one scene u have the show trying to explore deep themes of war and race and the next there’s a girl character saying “ohhhh I’m so hungry hahahaha I’m so quirky guys, look how hungry I am. U get the idea. The themes it explores (race and war for example) have been explored in other shows in a much more naunced way and years ago in shows like legend of the galactic hero’s, band of brothers, ect. The theme of freedom is also done so in your face, and lacks any subtly. The show treats it’s adulnce like kids (it is so shonan I guess) and doesn’t try and let the aufdience find the themes through characters actions, instead it just tells and explains it to you, with the amount of times “freedom” is said. Plus again, the theme of freedom has been explored better in other stuff like Vinland saga, the climber, ext which has actual subtly and nuance to it Mikasa only has 1 personality trait Levi is the generic cool edgy character, who may not seem like he doesn’t care, but actually cares for his comrades and feels guilty when they die. That trope has been done to death S1 is so predictable. It’s just action scene after action scene with no room for quiet character pulsing moments. If we don’t care about the charraters then the action scenes lack consequence Nope still incorrect. Try again. |
| End Zionazism |
Mikasa said: You are coping hard my guy just take the L and move on bro.24846 said: lol. Ok, 1 dimensional characters= when the potatoe girl is dying her last words are what’s for dinner or some shit like that. Emphasising her 1 persanality trait ti try and get some cheap emotional feelings out the audience S1-3 eran doesn’t develop (other then towards the end of s3). He just stays the same like a typical shonan protagonist. You would think maybe after seeing consequences for his actions he would change or something but no, he just has the same goal of killing titans no matter what. This problem doesn’t get fixed until late s3 and s4 Tonal inconsistency: one scene u have the show trying to explore deep themes of war and race and the next there’s a girl character saying “ohhhh I’m so hungry hahahaha I’m so quirky guys, look how hungry I am. U get the idea. The themes it explores (race and war for example) have been explored in other shows in a much more naunced way and years ago in shows like legend of the galactic hero’s, band of brothers, ect. The theme of freedom is also done so in your face, and lacks any subtly. The show treats it’s adulnce like kids (it is so shonan I guess) and doesn’t try and let the aufdience find the themes through characters actions, instead it just tells and explains it to you, with the amount of times “freedom” is said. Plus again, the theme of freedom has been explored better in other stuff like Vinland saga, the climber, ext which has actual subtly and nuance to it Mikasa only has 1 personality trait Levi is the generic cool edgy character, who may not seem like he doesn’t care, but actually cares for his comrades and feels guilty when they die. That trope has been done to death S1 is so predictable. It’s just action scene after action scene with no room for quiet character pulsing moments. If we don’t care about the charraters then the action scenes lack consequence Nope still incorrect. Try again. |
struggler_sensei said: You are coping hard my guy just take the L and move on bro. Any man who tries to announce the winner of an internet argument, in order to win the argument, has already lost. |
| End Zionazism |
Mikasa said: They've given you multiple points to back up their argument all you've done is go "nope try again" like a child. plus they are right.struggler_sensei said: You are coping hard my guy just take the L and move on bro. Any man who tries to announce the winner of an internet argument, in order to win the argument, has already lost. |
struggler_sensei said: Mikasa said: They've given you multiple points to back up their argument all you've done is go "nope try again" like a child. plus they are right.Any man who tries to announce the winner of an internet argument, in order to win the argument, has already lost. Ramblings are not points. No one asked him what he doesn't like. He essentially just said "Nuh uh" with too many words. |
| End Zionazism |
Mikasa said: Not actual ramblings though. they were valid criticisms.struggler_sensei said: They've given you multiple points to back up their argument all you've done is go "nope try again" like a child. plus they are right. Ramblings are not points. No one asked him what he doesn't like. He essentially just said "Nuh uh" with too many words. |
struggler_sensei said: Mikasa said: Not actual ramblings though. they were valid criticisms.Ramblings are not points. No one asked him what he doesn't like. He essentially just said "Nuh uh" with too many words. "1 dimensional characters= when the potatoe girl is dying her last words are what’s for dinner or some shit like that. " Bruh ππ #tooValid |
| End Zionazism |
Mikasa said: I mean he's not wrong.struggler_sensei said: Not actual ramblings though. they were valid criticisms. "1 dimensional characters= when the potatoe girl is dying her last words are what’s for dinner or some shit like that. " Bruh ππ #tooValid |
struggler_sensei said: Mikasa said: I mean he's not wrong."1 dimensional characters= when the potatoe girl is dying her last words are what’s for dinner or some shit like that. " Bruh ππ #tooValid You really cry a lot when you're alone, don't you? |
| End Zionazism |
Mikasa said: your point? one is a character whose main character trait is liking food at an obscene level, asking about food when they die. The other is a character with multiple character traits (i.e. loyalty, camaraderie, intuitiveness, insightfulness) struggling to tell the woman he loves how he feels as he is dying but failing to do so and dying dissatisfied with his own last words. These are very different levels of writing. struggler_sensei said: I mean he's not wrong. You really cry a lot when you're alone, don't you? |
struggler_sensei said: your point? one is a character whose main character trait is liking food at an obscene level, asking about food when they die. The other is a character with multiple character traits (i.e. loyalty, camaraderie, intuitiveness, insightfulness) struggling to tell the woman he loves how he feels as he is dying but failing to do so and dying dissatisfied with his own last words. These are very different levels of writing. One character whose main trait is being a simp "nice guy" to the death. The other is a character with multiple character traits (i.e. loyalty, camaraderie, intuitiveness, insightfulness) struggling to save the people she cares about and fighting for her homeland. These are very different levels of writing. I can also be selectively reductionist. That's why people who argue like this are retarded and I don't engage them. |
| End Zionazism |
Mikasa said: c'mon dude you are making such a stretch saying Judeau's main trait was being a simp and you know it. Sasha on the other hand served as comic relief for the majority of the story as "girl who eats food aggressively and at inappropriate times". Look the point is AoT is alright but it's hardly "peak fiction" the reason people think that it is, is cause it was an entire generations intro into anime and got mainstream success in the west but when you place it in relation to the totality of manga and anime it is far from the peak, it's just many people's first foray into decent anime, therefore, they hold it higher then it actually is.struggler_sensei said: your point? one is a character whose main character trait is liking food at an obscene level, asking about food when they die. The other is a character with multiple character traits (i.e. loyalty, camaraderie, intuitiveness, insightfulness) struggling to tell the woman he loves how he feels as he is dying but failing to do so and dying dissatisfied with his own last words. These are very different levels of writing. One character whose main trait is being a simp "nice guy" to the death. The other is a character with multiple character traits (i.e. loyalty, camaraderie, intuitiveness, insightfulness) struggling to save the people she cares about and fighting for her homeland. These are very different levels of writing. I can also be selectively reductionist. That's why people who argue like this are retarded and I don't engage them. |
| No. Have full faith in Kouji Mori and his assistants. They're gonna kick ass. Mori has been Miura's friend for many years. He will pave out a desired path to a conclusive ending that will satisfy not only fans but Miura himself (no cap). Miura and Mori would discuss with each other frequently about their manga series. So Mori most likely has a clear idea on the direction that Berserk has to take. It may not be 100% Miura's work but it will be pretty close. Of course not perfect though. Can't wait to see what happens after Fantasia arc. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Berserk Chapter 383 DiscussionMegamiRem - Sep 11 |
21 |
by Izxo
»»
Sep 21, 12:01 AM |
|
Poll: » Berserk Chapter 91 DiscussionKitaTsuki - Nov 4, 2011 |
31 |
by otakuweek
»»
Sep 12, 1:23 AM |
|
Poll: » Berserk Chapter 88 DiscussionKitaTsuki - Nov 4, 2011 |
31 |
by otakuweek
»»
Sep 11, 9:00 PM |
|
» Volume 43 end notes from Koji mori.jacobPOL - Sep 9 |
6 |
by DayRivia
»»
Sep 11, 2:41 AM |
|
Poll: » Berserk Chapter 382 DiscussionTheMangaManiac - Jun 26 |
32 |
by BlackYagami97
»»
Sep 9, 9:29 PM |