Attack on Titan
| We all know that Eren fought with Armin in episode 14 and he beat up Armin pretty badly, but if here instead Armin if Eren would have fought with Mikasa who do you think would have won the fight !? I know Mikasa would probably not fight with Eren and I can't say anything about Eren as he hates Mikasa , but we will not consider that here... |
| It would be a quick af match. Blink and you'll miss it. *Mikasa comes in with a clean looking jab Eren: Slave. |
 |
imbAF said: it was Annie if I am not mistakenEren has the best hand to hand combat score among the 104th trainees |
| Mikasa would break all of Eren's bones. Why is this even a question? It's been established that she is the top soldier and fighter off the division from the first season. Plus, she is an Ackerman. If there is someone who could put up a fight with her in human form, those would probably be Levi and Annie. |
imbAF said: Tanyaradzwa said: Mikasa VS Eren in hand to hand - Mikasa Wins Mikasa VS Titan Eren - Mikasa wins Eren can hardly win a battle without the support of the corpses. If it wasn't for them he would have been eaten and lost the founding titan. They save him countless times. He is not a very good fighter. Lol eren has the highest score in hand to hand combat from all the members of 104th group, how can mikasa win in hand to hand combat vs him?? He could have the best hand to hand combat and still get countered by her kicks and ground fight. |
imbAF said: Yeah i don't know what happens in the hypothetical scenario that is in your mind, but facts are facts, eren has a way better score then mikasa in that department No, man... you are making things up. Mikasa has more physical strength plus general skills, and she has more skills than Eren in other ways of fighting. Sure, Eren could throw a good punch and, in an ideal scenario, hit a precise uppercut on her chin, knocking her out. But unless we're considering their emotions here (in which case a fight wouldn't even happen), do you really believe Mikasa would be defeated like that? Just because he has better punchs, that doesn't make him the best fighter. That's not how martial arts work. |
| @imbAF perhaps you're confusing the wording here and thinking that hand to hand combat means only fist fight. It's unarmed combat in general. Even if Eren somehow scored more on that, he still got his ass kicked by Annie. Mikasa is arguably a better fighter than Annie. |
imbAF said: are you trolling man , he was soo easily been defeated by Annie and he literary copy Annie's fighting style in his fightAmalik0029 said: it was Annie if I am not mistaken Amalik0029 said: it was Annie if I am not mistaken It's eren, i was reading vol 1 the other day, and it was him |
Tanyaradzwa said: Mikasa VS Eren in hand to hand - Mikasa Wins Mikasa VS Titan Eren - Mikasa wins Titan Eren can hardly win a battle without the support of the corpses. If it wasn't for them he would have been eaten and lost the founding titan. They save him countless times. He is not a very good fighter. LMAO did you just say that Eren is not a good fighter ? Are we watching the same anime ? It's not like he beat all the warriors and been doing only hand to hand combat since Season 1. |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel.  |
Discussion_123 said: You all forget the way Mikasa was carrying 3-4 railings so casually ( That's easily over 500kg but I am not sure on this so anyone can correct me here ). Numerous time it has been shown Eren being jealous of Mikasa's strength . In Jean's ova it was shown the Eren was not able to lift a box and Mikasa was carrying 3 such boxes casually . If Eren fights Mikasa in Human form it's a complete curbstomp . It's not even close he would be beaten up more badly than he beat up Armin How is strength relevant in hand to hand combat ? With that analogy Eren should have lost every single fight vs Reiner. It's all about experiences and technique... strength is irelevant |
Just because you are doing something for someone else doesn't make it right. Kindness and beauty can sometimes become cruel. |
imbAF said: Sheklon said: Mikasa would break all of Eren's bones. Why is this even a question? It's been established that she is the top soldier and fighter off the division from the first season. Plus, she is an Ackerman. If there is someone who could put up a fight with her in human form, those would probably be Levi and Annie. She is overll the best. Eren is the best in the entire group in hand to hand combat. Why do people speak so certain of things, for which they don't know and can't prove... I don't remember an instance where it is implied that eren has the best hand to hand combat. What episode are we talking about?(anime only) |
 |
Shizokami said: I don't remember an instance where it is implied that eren has the best hand to hand combat. What episode are we talking about?(anime only) I can bring the manga panel, but in that same panel Reiner says "or was he second to mikasa", because Mikasa humiliated him there, that wasn't in the anime. But that's way early on. Like Annie isn't even mentioned.   ----------------------- On the subject, i wonder if Annie won against Mikasa. It was kind of implied that Annie did win because Eren defeated Reiner, it was the same comparison, one that has better technique vs the one who is physically superior. If Annie did defeat Mikasa, then current Eren probably wins as well. |
Xilver said: Shizokami said: I don't remember an instance where it is implied that eren has the best hand to hand combat. What episode are we talking about?(anime only) I can bring the manga panel, but in that same panel Reiner says "or was he second to mikasa", because Mikasa humiliated him there, that wasn't in the anime. But that's way early on. Like Annie isn't even mentioned. ----------------------- On the subject, i wonder if Annie won against Mikasa. It was kind of implied that Annie did win because Eren defeated Reiner, it was the same comparison, one that has better technique vs the one who is physically superior. If Annie did defeat Mikasa, then current Eren probably wins as well. I still can't see him winning against Mikasa, seeing how easily he was defeated by Annie (both in human and titan form), and even commander Sadis mentioned that Mikasa showed unprecedented evaluation in every aspect, which makes me think that she's stronger than Annie. |
|
Shizokami said: I still can't see him winning against Mikasa, seeing how easily he was defeated by Annie (both in human and titan form), and even commander Sadis mentioned that Mikasa showed unprecedented evaluation in every aspect, which makes me think that she's stronger than Annie. Eren that lost to Annie had no chance against Mikasa. But we're not talking about the same Eren here. If Mikasa defeated Annie, then it doesn't match Eren beating Reiner, but it's possible. I mean there's no solid proof both ways. So it's kind of a pointless conversation. |
Xilver said: Shizokami said: I still can't see him winning against Mikasa, seeing how easily he was defeated by Annie (both in human and titan form), and even commander Sadis mentioned that Mikasa showed unprecedented evaluation in every aspect, which makes me think that she's stronger than Annie. Eren that lost to Annie had no chance against Mikasa. But we're not talking about the same Eren here. If Mikasa defeated Annie, then it doesn't match Eren beating Reiner, but it's possible. I mean there's no solid proof both ways. So it's kind of a pointless conversation. We're not talking about the "same" Mikasa too you know, or do you mean he somehow got OP at hand to hand combat by learning the truth of the world, in which case yeah, the conversation is pointless. |
|
Shizokami said: We're not talking about the "same" Mikasa too you know, or do you mean he somehow got OP at hand to hand combat by learning the truth of the world, in which case yeah, the conversation is pointless. We're talking about more or less the same Mikasa unless you suggest that she actually started paying attention to martial arts, even though she used to only rely on her superior physical capabilities. Eren had a drive for it, him actually working and improving on stuff like that is not a stretch. Mikasa is just a powerhouse. I don't know who wins, and i don't really care. Just expressed my thoughts on the matter. |
Xilver said: bruh but difference between situation is massive . Eren and Reiner had atleast comparable speed and agility and not very huge power difference . So techniques could work whereas this Mikasa was carrying 3-4 railway tracks like a piece of cake . This is easily more than 500 kg ( not sure how much ) . It is easily more than any normal Human . Not to mention she is more fast and agile than both annie and her . It is not even close . They would be beaten up more worse than Eren beat Armin .Shizokami said: I don't remember an instance where it is implied that eren has the best hand to hand combat. What episode are we talking about?(anime only) I can bring the manga panel, but in that same panel Reiner says "or was he second to mikasa", because Mikasa humiliated him there, that wasn't in the anime. But that's way early on. Like Annie isn't even mentioned. ----------------------- On the subject, i wonder if Annie won against Mikasa. It was kind of implied that Annie did win because Eren defeated Reiner, it was the same comparison, one that has better technique vs the one who is physically superior. If Annie did defeat Mikasa, then current Eren probably wins as well. |
imbAF said: check this bro . Eren lifting a boxDiscussion_123 said: It might be because Mikasa and Annie didn't take it seriously . It is in no way shape or form Eren could take on Mikasa that time . She would one shot him . He might take Annie now but Mikasa is now even a bigger beast than earlier . According to....??? What you want to believe i guess. Facts are that he is the best in hand to hand combat. That's canon. Everything else is a if,buts,maybes  Mikasa lifting box   If you still don't believe see Eren's reaction  If you still don't believe check How Mikasa was carrying 3-4 railway tracks casually as if it's a joke |
Discussion_123Mar 23, 2021 7:44 AM
More topics from this board
» Dont make those flame wars threads distract you from thisrach1m4n - Mar 14, 2021 |
16 |
by PeterOliver1
»»
7 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 17, 2021 |
1056 |
by Spootzel
»»
Sep 18, 11:10 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Dec 6, 2020 |
961 |
by Misakoooo
»»
Sep 18, 5:32 PM |
|
» Attack on TitanThienBao1703 - Sep 10 |
30 |
by Kunii
»»
Sep 16, 7:07 PM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Episode 16 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Koito91 - Mar 28, 2021 |
716 |
by ClaudiusGD
»»
Sep 13, 1:52 AM |