General Discussion Thread (Spoilers)

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

deg said:

keragamming said:

I don't know I think it may look jarring to be switching from 2d to cg I would rather they go full cg if that is the case, but we will see.

ye it will look jarring but my guess is base on that Armored Titan scene flashback they use old footage from WIT so that Armored Titan was running in 2D animation but the moment the Armored Titan is gonna hit the wall they use 3DCG model on the last cut if you notice that i forgot which episode that was even

it was ep 3 , but the far shots of cg and close ups and close combat can be 2d, like the jaw in ep 3 and that'll make it look good

Jan 7, 2021 4:06 AM

#1853

Offline

Nov 2020

973

keragamming said:
The Eren poster looks just like the one in the trailer where he burst through the building, was that cg?

eren poster is def 2D

Jan 7, 2021 4:07 AM

#1854

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

keragamming said:
The Eren poster looks just like the one in the trailer where he burst through the building, was that cg?

yep to me that is 3DCG and its pretty obvious considering the counterpart poster of that is the 3DCG Armored Titan

Jan 7, 2021 4:09 AM

#1855

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

keragamming said:
The Eren poster looks just like the one in the trailer where he burst through the building, was that cg?

yep to me that is 3DCG and its pretty obvious considering the counterpart poster of that is the 3DCG Armored Titan

no way that's 3dcg.... It's too smooth- I'm betting my money that the poster is 2D

Jan 7, 2021 4:09 AM

#1856

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Krugerman said:

MAQS said:

Collosal titan walking will be CG.

That is the most time consuming titan to draw in 2d while moving.

Nah I think collosal will be 2D- it only appears for 10 sec at most and he never appears later- it's like the female titan case- where it's just faster to draw a 10 sec scene than to make a cg model.

depends if they have time for it or not

Jan 7, 2021 4:10 AM

#1857

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Krugerman said:

deg said:

yep to me that is 3DCG and its pretty obvious considering the counterpart poster of that is the 3DCG Armored Titan

no way that's 3dcg.... It's too smooth- I'm betting my money that the poster is 2D

do you have the posters? if so can you post it? i do not remember much the details on them

Jan 7, 2021 4:11 AM

#1858

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Krugerman said:

deg said:

yep to me that is 3DCG and its pretty obvious considering the counterpart poster of that is the 3DCG Armored Titan

no way that's 3dcg.... It's too smooth- I'm betting my money that the poster is 2D

im damn sure it is 2d i mean even the design looks quite different, it could be that they used the trailer shot to keep the suspense. and thats why im afraid if that image circulated too much a delay could happen

Jan 7, 2021 4:11 AM

#1859

Offline

Nov 2020

973

Harsha1314 said:

Krugerman said:

Nah I think collosal will be 2D- it only appears for 10 sec at most and he never appears later- it's like the female titan case- where it's just faster to draw a 10 sec scene than to make a cg model.

depends if they have time for it or not

bro like I said- it's less than 10 sec in fact - they only used CG for collosal in s2 cause they needed him for the whole ep and the cool sakuga they had with the scouts and s3p2 which eh was in for 2 whole eps

Jan 7, 2021 4:12 AM

#1860

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Krugerman said:

Harsha1314 said:

depends if they have time for it or not

bro like I said- it's less than 10 sec in fact - they only used CG for collosal in s2 cause they needed him for the whole ep and the cool sakuga they had with the scouts and s3p2 which eh was in for 2 whole eps

yeah, guess they can manage it since he doesn't wave around too much, or even a cut like in the trailer would be great

Harsha1314Jan 7, 2021 4:16 AM

Jan 7, 2021 4:13 AM

#1861

Offline

Oct 2015

1221

deg said:

MAQS said:

Wait what??

you mean like the Godzilla anime movie trilogy?

nah Polygon is bad with 3DCG they do not deform their 3D models to make it look like 2D that follows the squash and stretch principle

im talking about 3DCG studios like SANZIGEN (Bubuki Buranki, ID-0, Black Rock Shooter TV), Orange (Land of Lustrous) and Graphinica (Expelled From Paradise, Hello World, SSSS.Gridman)

Oh yeah, but I meant in that everything is made CG not the quality, yes the Godzilla movie trilogy is not good cg.

And of the ones you mentioned that I know of, those are not good CG, those are GREAT cg, the type I was holding my breath hoping this season would have, but given how Dorehedoro looked I was expecting it was gonna be like that.

Dont get me wrong Dorohedoro and this final season are very good, but for example Bubuki Buranki fights scenes look way better imo.

Jan 7, 2021 4:14 AM

#1862

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Harsha1314 said:

Krugerman said:

no way that's 3dcg.... It's too smooth- I'm betting my money that the poster is 2D

im damn sure it is 2d i mean even the design looks quite different, it could be that they used the trailer shot to keep the suspense. and thats why im afraid if that image circulated too much a delay could happen

we are talking about the promotional posters of the Attack Titan and Armored Titan before the anime aired though

Jan 7, 2021 4:14 AM

#1863

Offline

Oct 2015

1221

Krugerman said:

MAQS said:

Collosal titan walking will be CG.

That is the most time consuming titan to draw in 2d while moving.

Nah I think collosal will be 2D- it only appears for 10 sec at most and he never appears later- it's like the female titan case- where it's just faster to draw a 10 sec scene than to make a cg model.

Good argument, you might be right.

Jan 7, 2021 4:15 AM

#1864

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

deg said:

Harsha1314 said:

im damn sure it is 2d i mean even the design looks quite different, it could be that they used the trailer shot to keep the suspense. and thats why im afraid if that image circulated too much a delay could happen

we are talking about the promotional posters of the Attack Titan and Armored Titan before the anime aired though

yeah and it was literally a trailer shot, and the titans were completely 2d in the trailer as confirmed by ajay

Jan 7, 2021 4:16 AM

#1865

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Harsha1314 said:

deg said:

we are talking about the promotional posters of the Attack Titan and Armored Titan before the anime aired though

yeah and it was literally a trailer shot, and the titans were completely 2d in the trailer as confirmed by ajay

no not the one said by Ajay? the leak image that was confirmed by Ajay is 2D no doubt

Jan 7, 2021 4:18 AM

#1866

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

Krugerman said:

no way that's 3dcg.... It's too smooth- I'm betting my money that the poster is 2D

do you have the posters? if so can you post it? i do not remember much the details on them

I can't find it, I only have a low quality pic here

https://twitter.com/NSTG17/status/1339930220506337285?s=20

Jan 7, 2021 4:18 AM

#1867

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

deg said:

Harsha1314 said:

yeah and it was literally a trailer shot, and the titans were completely 2d in the trailer as confirmed by ajay

no not the one said by Ajay? the leak image that was confirmed by Ajay is 2D no doubt

yeah thats good then. i see the confusion, i meant the new one shouldn't be circulated much because the promotinal one was a trailer shot, and it could be that they wanted to build suspense around the new AT design

Jan 7, 2021 4:20 AM

#1868

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Krugerman said:

deg said:

do you have the posters? if so can you post it? i do not remember much the details on them

I can't find it, I only have a low quality pic here

https://twitter.com/NSTG17/status/1339930220506337285?s=20

that was the pre-animated PV screenshot though i remember thinking they re-created that good in 3DCG with that promotional poster with japanese text and all

Jan 7, 2021 4:22 AM

#1869

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

Krugerman said:

I can't find it, I only have a low quality pic here

https://twitter.com/NSTG17/status/1339930220506337285?s=20

that was the pre-animated PV screenshot though i remember thinking they re-created that good in 3DCG with that promotional poster with japanese text and all

Nope it was exactly that pic with the text evil written on it

Jan 7, 2021 4:24 AM

#1870

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Krugerman said:

deg said:

that was the pre-animated PV screenshot though i remember thinking they re-created that good in 3DCG with that promotional poster with japanese text and all

Nope it was exactly that pic with the text evil written on it

hmm ok i will agree with you for now

Jan 7, 2021 4:27 AM

#1871

Nyess_

Offline

May 2020

981

deg said:

Krugerman said:

I can't find it, I only have a low quality pic here

https://twitter.com/NSTG17/status/1339930220506337285?s=20

that was the pre-animated PV screenshot though i remember thinking they re-created that good in 3DCG with that promotional poster with japanese text and all

https://twitter.com/aotwiki/status/1333719007594225664
I'm pretty sure they are the same

Something that’s supposed to die and doesn’t… will eventually rot away , whether it’s a man or a nation

Jan 7, 2021 4:30 AM

#1872

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

shingojira-chan said:

deg said:

that was the pre-animated PV screenshot though i remember thinking they re-created that good in 3DCG with that promotional poster with japanese text and all

https://twitter.com/aotwiki/status/1333719007594225664
I'm pretty sure they are the same

ah ok ye there are more simple line arts like on his chest area compared to the much more detailed line art on the 3D Armored Titan

so ye its 2D Attack Titan

Jan 7, 2021 4:33 AM

#1873

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

shingojira-chan said:

https://twitter.com/aotwiki/status/1333719007594225664
I'm pretty sure they are the same

ah ok ye there are more simple line arts like on his chest area compared to the much more detailed line art on the 3D Armored Titan

so ye its 2D Attack Titan

I wonder how Cg attack titan will look, and if Warhammer will be Cg, I honestly dont know how Warhammer will be tbh- mainly cause of the weapons and all- the actual figh with eren is less than half a chapter -more like 1/4 if we are only seeing the action part

Jan 7, 2021 4:34 AM

#1874

Offline

Oct 2013

12257

Harsha1314 said:

keragamming said:

Well he said half a second out of the 10 seconds the attack titan was shown.

It's pretty hard to know tbh, as the preview image for episode 6 that was leaked showed a 2d Eren as well. So it maybe a mixture between 2d and cg? But mostly 2d?

That is still up in the air.

@Harsha1314

Are we sure about that? Because I heard the image we saw of Eren that was leaked is from the preview of episode 6? Or was that episode 5?

its from the preview i feel. and yes the AT will be cg for most part clearly, but the detail on the model is so good, just like armoured and jaw titan i can't ask for more, since i was expecting a full on cg showdown and had my hopes very low for AT design. ngl kinda expected it to look completely like the one from the game

This comment here is why I brought up the fact that the poster shown was 2d Eren from the trailer, so I don't understand where your cg theory is coming from? Or did you thought it was cg?

There is more evidence that the attack titan will mostly be 2d than cg.

Episode 5 leaked details from ajay and also the episode 6 leaked preview image and finally the poster.

keragammingJan 7, 2021 4:37 AM

Jan 7, 2021 4:36 AM

#1875

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Krugerman said:

deg said:

ah ok ye there are more simple line arts like on his chest area compared to the much more detailed line art on the 3D Armored Titan

so ye its 2D Attack Titan

I wonder how Cg attack titan will look, and if Warhammer will be Cg, I honestly dont know how Warhammer will be tbh- mainly cause of the weapons and all- the actual figh with eren is less than half a chapter -more like 1/4 if we are only seeing the action part

ye its weird we have not seen any leaks of the MAPPA showcase of the 3D Attack Titan and Armored Titan but we already saw in the anime the 3D Armored Titan anyway

as for Warhammer Titan lol i got no idea if it will be in 2D or 3D since you said on your thread it will appear for less than 10 minutes of pure action/battles and that is a lot of drawings if its in 2D

Jan 7, 2021 4:36 AM

#1876

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Krugerman said:

deg said:

ah ok ye there are more simple line arts like on his chest area compared to the much more detailed line art on the 3D Armored Titan

so ye its 2D Attack Titan

I wonder how Cg attack titan will look, and if Warhammer will be Cg, I honestly dont know how Warhammer will be tbh- mainly cause of the weapons and all- the actual figh with eren is less than half a chapter -more like 1/4 if we are only seeing the action part

im more concerned about how the odm scenes will look. its a given there will be the cg haters even if it looks great, and even at decent (which i highly doubt) we can make it through prolly. but the odm scenes are one of AOT's trade marks as they are seen in the highest quantity is every season

Jan 7, 2021 4:38 AM

#1877

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

Krugerman said:

I wonder how Cg attack titan will look, and if Warhammer will be Cg, I honestly dont know how Warhammer will be tbh- mainly cause of the weapons and all- the actual figh with eren is less than half a chapter -more like 1/4 if we are only seeing the action part

ye its weird we have not seen any leaks of the MAPPA showcase of the 3D Attack Titan and Armored Titan but we already saw in the anime the 3D Armored Titan anyway

Now my biggest question is if Warhammer is 2D- will it look good when Cg eren is fighting 2D Warhammer?

Jan 7, 2021 4:38 AM

#1878

Offline

Nov 2020

973

Harsha1314 said:

Krugerman said:

I wonder how Cg attack titan will look, and if Warhammer will be Cg, I honestly dont know how Warhammer will be tbh- mainly cause of the weapons and all- the actual figh with eren is less than half a chapter -more like 1/4 if we are only seeing the action part

im more concerned about how the odm scenes will look. its a given there will be the cg haters even if it looks great, and even at decent (which i highly doubt) we can make it through prolly. but the odm scenes are one of AOT's trade marks as they are seen in the highest quantity is every season

Imo it'll be 100% 2D

Jan 7, 2021 4:39 AM

#1879

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

keragamming said:

Harsha1314 said:

its from the preview i feel. and yes the AT will be cg for most part clearly, but the detail on the model is so good, just like armoured and jaw titan i can't ask for more, since i was expecting a full on cg showdown and had my hopes very low for AT design. ngl kinda expected it to look completely like the one from the game

This comment here is why I brought up the fact that the poster shown was 2d Eren from the trailer, so I don't understand where your cg theory is coming from? Or did you thought it was cg?

There is more evidence that the attack titan will mostly be 2d than cg.

Episode 5 leaked details from ajay and also the episode 6 leaked preview image.

i feel the fights will be cg, the close mostly cg, i mean the detail on the leaked one made me feel that way i can neither confirm nor deny. i feel the cg because the model was in the mappa showcase, even if it wasn't the complete one probably, or else it'd be circulating around even before ep1 of s4 came out, so chances of mostly 2d and 3d exist equally

Jan 7, 2021 4:40 AM

#1880

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Krugerman said:

deg said:

ye its weird we have not seen any leaks of the MAPPA showcase of the 3D Attack Titan and Armored Titan but we already saw in the anime the 3D Armored Titan anyway

Now my biggest question is if Warhammer is 2D- will it look good when Cg eren is fighting 2D Warhammer?

you missed my edit here

as for Warhammer Titan lol i got no idea if it will be in 2D or 3D since you said on your thread it will appear for less than 10 minutes of pure action/battles and that is a lot of drawings if its in 2D

Jan 7, 2021 4:43 AM

#1881

Offline

Nov 2020

973

Harsha1314 said:

keragamming said:

This comment here is why I brought up the fact that the poster shown was 2d Eren from the trailer, so I don't understand where your cg theory is coming from? Or did you thought it was cg?

There is more evidence that the attack titan will mostly be 2d than cg.

Episode 5 leaked details from ajay and also the episode 6 leaked preview image.

i feel the fights will be cg, the close mostly cg, i mean the detail on the leaked one made me feel that way i can neither confirm nor deny. i feel the cg because the model was in the mappa showcase, even if it wasn't the complete one probably, or else it'd be circulating around even before ep1 of s4 came out, so chances of mostly 2d and 3d exist equally

I think the first few minutes of the fight starting from when attack titan punches wht while transforming to warhammer fully healing will be 2D. Then I'm not sure how they will do it in CG but eren getting impaled and laying midair might be in 2D too- Fuck IDk anymore if that's the case the whole wht vs attack titan will be 2D but I highly doubt it.

Jan 7, 2021 4:43 AM

#1882

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

Krugerman said:

Harsha1314 said:

im more concerned about how the odm scenes will look. its a given there will be the cg haters even if it looks great, and even at decent (which i highly doubt) we can make it through prolly. but the odm scenes are one of AOT's trade marks as they are seen in the highest quantity is every season

Imo it'll be 100% 2D

i know, but the 3d backgrounds of mad box......... they are something else even the movements were top tier in nearly all seasons except maybe a few shots here and there which are at such a minimum amount its unbelievably well made. i will be looking forward to how its going to look now

Jan 7, 2021 4:44 AM

#1883

Offline

Oct 2013

12257

deg said:

Krugerman said:

I wonder how Cg attack titan will look, and if Warhammer will be Cg, I honestly dont know how Warhammer will be tbh- mainly cause of the weapons and all- the actual figh with eren is less than half a chapter -more like 1/4 if we are only seeing the action part

ye its weird we have not seen any leaks of the MAPPA showcase of the 3D Attack Titan and Armored Titan but we already saw in the anime the 3D Armored Titan anyway

as for Warhammer Titan lol i got no idea if it will be in 2D or 3D since you said on your thread it will appear for less than 10 minutes of pure action/battles and that is a lot of drawings if its in 2D

But the poster we saw of the armored titan is from episode 1, so we should also believe the poster image of Eren is from a direct episode of the anime.

Meaning what we saw in the preanimated trailer of Eren attack titan could be what we will see in the episode as well.

Or the poster was simple a placeholder since the episode was still in production at the time and if that is the case I will lean more towards it being 2d than cg, based off what ajay that it was mostly 2d but only half a second of cg and again the preview for the next episode have a shot of 2d Eren.

So my conclusion is that if there is cg its minimum cg for the attack titan, that is the likely scenario and I also think the war hammer titan will be 2d as well.

Also it would be weird if the warhammer is cg and Eren titan is 2d, that is why I conclude the warhammer will be 2d, plus his abilities would be hard to produce in cg.

I could be wrong, but just basing off evidence it more leans to the attack on titan being 2d than cg.

Jan 7, 2021 4:44 AM

#1884

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

Krugerman said:

Now my biggest question is if Warhammer is 2D- will it look good when Cg eren is fighting 2D Warhammer?

you missed my edit here

as for Warhammer Titan lol i got no idea if it will be in 2D or 3D since you said on your thread it will appear for less than 10 minutes of pure action/battles and that is a lot of drawings if its in 2D

I meant it's total screentime lol- if it's pure action it should be 4-5 mins If they had a highly skilled animator for that ep they could manage it but fuck I'm rly curious now- Let's wait and see- The only way I see it is that they change up alot of the action to make it easier in CG

Jan 7, 2021 4:45 AM

#1885

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

Krugerman said:

Harsha1314 said:

im more concerned about how the odm scenes will look. its a given there will be the cg haters even if it looks great, and even at decent (which i highly doubt) we can make it through prolly. but the odm scenes are one of AOT's trade marks as they are seen in the highest quantity is every season

Imo it'll be 100% 2D

youre forgetting there are tweets of animators saying its so hard to draw the new black uniforms so it will be more harder to draw and animate decently in ODM gear scenes

but maybe those animators are just the in-betweeners complaining lol

Jan 7, 2021 4:46 AM

#1886

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:

Krugerman said:

Imo it'll be 100% 2D

youre forgetting there are tweets of animators saying its so hard to draw the new black uniforms so it will be more harder to draw and animate decently in ODM gear scenes

but maybe those animators are just the in-betweeners complaining lol

vercreek also said smtgh abt working on a scene in aot where it took a long ass time to draw 16-17 frames in 32 days or smtgh- Idk if its ove-exaggeration or if that's how fucking had it is to draw

Oh yea btw I saw an animator from WIT- I think he/she is working with MAPPA now said abt how they copy and paste the wongs of freedom logo instead of drawing it over and over again

Jan 7, 2021 4:50 AM

#1887

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

@Krugerman

oh ye i remember vercreek saying that too

@keragamming

ye could be too all is possible at the moment lol but one thing is for sure episode 5 is how Ajay saw it so it will only have a split second 3D Attack Titan

Jan 7, 2021 4:50 AM

#1888

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

deg said:

Krugerman said:

Imo it'll be 100% 2D

youre forgetting there are tweets of animators saying its so hard to draw the new black uniforms so it will be more harder to draw and animate decently in ODM gear scenes

but maybe those animators are just the in-betweeners complaining lol

but as is prev stated making those dynamic scenes in cg is near imposiible, unless they want it to look like in the videogame, which i highly doubt

Jan 7, 2021 4:52 AM

#1889

Offline

Dec 2020

1588

deg said:

Krugerman said:

Imo it'll be 100% 2D

youre forgetting there are tweets of animators saying its so hard to draw the new black uniforms so it will be more harder to draw and animate decently in ODM gear scenes

but maybe those animators are just the in-betweeners complaining lol

in other words, i don't think it'll look very bad, but definitely chances for not looking as good as prev seasons. but another thing, since its the same 3dcg director, chances are the background movements could look just as good, even though araki was the one who primarily worked on those shots and the way they look

Jan 7, 2021 4:56 AM

#1890

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

but anyway as @Krugerman pointed out earlier it will be weird to see 2D Warhammer Titan fighting a 3D Attack Titan though lol

like if they do not use the detailed 3D Attack Titan on that fight then when will they use it anyway? and what a waste of time to make a detailed 3D Attack Titan model if its not gonna be use a lot

Jan 7, 2021 4:57 AM

#1891

Offline

Nov 2020

973

deg said:
but anyway as @Krugerman pointed out earlier it will be weird to see 2D Warhammer Titan fighting a 3D Attack Titan though lol

like if they do not use the detailed 3D Attack Titan on that fight then when will they use it anyway? and what a waste of time to make a detailed 3D Attack Titan model if its not gonna be use a lot

There is the War for Paradis fight- I think they may make that fight 90% CG as that's when their schedules will be even more tighter and those scenes doesn't require much 2d shots from what i rmbr

Jan 7, 2021 5:00 AM

#1892

Offline

Oct 2015

1221

keragamming said:

Harsha1314 said:

its from the preview i feel. and yes the AT will be cg for most part clearly, but the detail on the model is so good, just like armoured and jaw titan i can't ask for more, since i was expecting a full on cg showdown and had my hopes very low for AT design. ngl kinda expected it to look completely like the one from the game

This comment here is why I brought up the fact that the poster shown was 2d Eren from the trailer, so I don't understand where your cg theory is coming from? Or did you thought it was cg?

There is more evidence that the attack titan will mostly be 2d than cg.

Episode 5 leaked details from ajay and also the episode 6 leaked preview image and finally the poster.

Simple, MAPPA made a 3d model of Eren, they would not have done so if they were not going to use it a lot. otherwise its a waste of resources.

Jan 7, 2021 5:06 AM

#1893

Offline

Oct 2013

12257

The reason I think the warhammer titan will be 2d is because his abilities are too dynamic for cg technology to work, he changes his attacks very often and quickly and these types of attacks are way too complex for cg.

Unless they make his body cg but his abilities drawn in 2d, but I think if you are going that far you might as well draw him in 2d as well.

I think it would cost them way more to make all those ability in cg, but I could be wrong.

deg said:
but anyway as @Krugerman pointed out earlier it will be weird to see 2D Warhammer Titan fighting a 3D Attack Titan though lol

like if they do not use the detailed 3D Attack Titan on that fight then when will they use it anyway? and what a waste of time to make a detailed 3D Attack Titan model if its not gonna be use a lot

What detail 3d attack titan? Post link please.

@MAQS
Are you talking about the poster from the trailer?

keragammingJan 7, 2021 5:09 AM

Jan 7, 2021 5:09 AM

#1894

lagom

Online

Jan 2009

107727

keragamming said:

deg said:
but anyway as @Krugerman pointed out earlier it will be weird to see 2D Warhammer Titan fighting a 3D Attack Titan though lol

like if they do not use the detailed 3D Attack Titan on that fight then when will they use it anyway? and what a waste of time to make a detailed 3D Attack Titan model if its not gonna be use a lot

What detail 3d attack titan? Post link please.

the MAPPA showcase dude although we do not have any visual leaks of it

Jan 7, 2021 5:09 AM

#1895

Offline

Nov 2020

973

keragamming said:
The reason I think the warhammer titan will be 2d is because his abilities are too dynamic for cg technology to work, he changes his attacks very often and quickly and these types of attacks are way too complex for cg.

Unless they make his body cg but his abilities drawn in 2d, but I think if you are going that far you might as well draw him in 2d as well.

I think it would cost them way more to make all those ability in cg, but I could be wrong.

EXACTLY!!! AND The scenes before this must be 100% 2D too
I made a detailed analysis in this thread

https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1885683

Jan 7, 2021 5:12 AM

#1896

Offline

Oct 2015

1221

keragamming said:
The reason I think the warhammer titan will be 2d is because his abilities are too dynamic for cg technology to work, he changes his attacks very often and quickly and these types of attacks are way too complex for cg.

Unless they make his body cg but his abilities drawn in 2d, but I think if you are going that far you might as well draw him in 2d as well.

I think it would cost them way more to make all those ability in cg, but I could be wrong.

deg said:
but anyway as @Krugerman pointed out earlier it will be weird to see 2D Warhammer Titan fighting a 3D Attack Titan though lol

like if they do not use the detailed 3D Attack Titan on that fight then when will they use it anyway? and what a waste of time to make a detailed 3D Attack Titan model if its not gonna be use a lot

What detail 3d attack titan? Post link please.

@MAQS
Are you talking about the poster from the trailer?

No, the MAPPA showcase had the 3D Eren titan, no pcitures allowed that is why we have not seen it.

Even Foxen anime confirmed it, I hate the guy but he is no liar on those things.

Jan 7, 2021 5:13 AM

#1897

Offline

Oct 2013

12257

deg said:

keragamming said:

What detail 3d attack titan? Post link please.

the MAPPA showcase dude although we do not have any visual leaks of it

Wasn't it the poster that was posted along with the armored titan? But if the poster did say 3d attack titan I guess there is no debate here.

So I guess 2d and cg attack titan then.

Jan 7, 2021 5:14 AM

#1898

Offline

Nov 2020

973

keragamming said:

deg said:

the MAPPA showcase dude although we do not have any visual leaks of it

Wasn't it the poster that was posted along with the armored titan? But if the poster did say 3d attack titan I guess there is no debate here.

So I guess 2d and cg attack titan then.

lmaooo im so confused and hyped- I'm 100% the poster we saw of eren alongside Cg armoured titan was 2D tho- minaly cause I doubt ep 6/7 was completed 1 month ago

Jan 7, 2021 5:18 AM

#1899

Offline

Oct 2015

1221

Just to clarify things for all.

There IS a 3D detailed model of Eren, we know that from the Showcase by people who went there.

whether the poster or previews or whatever are the 2d or 3d model that is irrelevant, the fact is MAPPA would not have done a 3D model if they were not going to use it a lot.

Jan 7, 2021 5:19 AM

#1900