You have to be kidding, right?

Bronos23 said:
I just finished this show and oh man....The sound,the view,the feelings,the atmosphere,the message,emotions,soul searching...this movie has it all. I came here to see the how other people are feeling about it and such...

Let's set the record str8...this show is on par with Kimi no na Wa and maybe depends on the person,even better. The thought that this show can get a negative review really shows how some people are rotten to the core and have a really sad life(inside).

There is that feeling that i get that people are comparing this anime to Your Lie in April, and that because of that it can give a weird feeling watching it...SO WHAT!!! They have similar message and the same kind of female character but damn man, one has nothing to do with the other,thet clearly established the characters as their own and not some ripoff of other show.

I cried while reading Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso, and i cried 4 times while watching Pancreas. Appreciate both and stop with the hate

KreatorX said:
Then fuken go and post a positive review and show how happy and wonderful your life is (inside).

What is even the point of this discussion thread? It is so far, unclear. Understand that people have different tastes. Those tastes are presented in the reviews. You have different tastes, so showcase that in your review.

KreatorX said:
Then fuken go and post a positive review and show how happy and wonderful your life is (inside).

What is even the point of this discussion thread? It is so far, unclear. Understand that people have different tastes. Those tastes are presented in the reviews. You have different tastes, so showcase that in your review.

NovaMagic said:


Well if you have a different taste than OP then you're "rotten to the core and have a really sad life"

NthDegree said:
I kind of wish they would make this kind of movie about men too. Every single time I've seen a movie or series about someone with a terminal illness, it's always a cute girl. Not just animes like this one and Your Lie In April but also live-action dramas like One Liter of Tears. I guess AnoHana kinda counts too although it's not exactly an illness.

Give guys some love too!

Spookzter said:
Damn this has to be one of the dumbest things I've heard lately
"The thought that this show can get a negative review really shows how some people are rotten to the core and have a really sad life(inside)" just how did you come up with this stuff

LordNuxan0R said:


Im a guy and im just gonna say this if anyone even if like the best director that won oscar or something were directing a show about a man is dying, nope man im still not gonna watch it.
I dunno how to explain but i think most people would also say they wont want to watch it XD .

NthDegree said:

If there was more diversity in the charter that was dying, perhaps it could prevent me from rolling my eyes every time I hear this setup. The dying character being always the same gives me the impression that rather than telling the story earnestly, they're just coldly filling a checklist in order to maximize tears via emotional manipulation. At that point I'm having some serious difficulty taking the character and their inevitable death seriously at all.

That's the kind of thing that kills a "heartfelt" story for me.

LordNuxan0R said:


Ya it could feel too generic at times to me as well but i just think how the character's are feeling and thinking and cry. I dont cry because i know she's gonna die i cry because how she feels about her death. But i dunno man, dunno what to say haha. I mean these shows are like these , main FC dies in like 1 year or something. If u can relate to her in the duration of the movie u cry , if not than this not your show. Crying for a man feels weird man.

TBH there is never true gender equality , although it's a bit off topic but people just see different gender differently. A man dying with illness is just less tear teasing than woman dying through illness. I mean i think man are just more suited to die gloriously with regrets in those shounen anime or something. Maybe just me , EH.

NthDegree said:

If you think about it logically, someone dying should be just as sad regardless of what their gender is. And I don't think you mean to say a man dying is not sad either... with your own words crying about it just feels "weird" even though it is sad. Personally I think that "weird" part is just our culture. If crying about it was normal or to be expected that "weird" feeling would probably disappear too. Fortunately culture can be changed by just producing more media, so we should just make lots of works about how sad a man dying is lol.

So I guess it all boils down to what I said in my first post: we need more anime about terminally ill guys.

TrumpMD said:
Male MC in Your Name was 10x better, he wasn't a pansy and antisocial prick.

This movie stinks, good thing I can watch things like this in fast forward.