Between the relationship in the Movie and Tv Series , Which one is Better ??

AngelLily said:
I think both had different approaches to their relationships, so I can't really say which one is better. The TV Series explored their relationship bit by bit, they grew closer in a pace that is believable and that I personally loved.

In the movie, Tomoya fell in love with Nagisa upon noticing that she was the one that completed him. There was a point that he says about Sunohara, "The difference between him and me is that he's got guts". Movie Nagisa is exactly the same. She doesn't give up even when the situation is bad, and even when they said there wasn't a chance of they acting in the drama club, she still found a way. Not only that, but they shared the same dream, the same feelings. It's more "fairy-tale like", "destiny-like".

I, personally, prefer the way KyoAni treated their relationship. We keep getting "and then they magically fell in love". A change to a believable pace is much welcomed.

Mayora-Hime said:
That is a good question and one that i would gladly answer :) I refused to watch the movie until I completed the anime because I was aware of the amount of spoilers it held. And when I did I was extremely dissapointed with how their love grew. It was extremely fast and unrealistic. Cute yes, but that is not the reason why I love Clannad. For me Clannad is one of the few series I've watched that focuses on simple, everyday life things and makes them seem somewhat beautiful. Something that the movie failed to deliver.
In the anime however, their love took quite some time to develop. At some points, us the viewers were skeptical if Tomoya would end up with one of the other girls. Kyou and Tomoyo were not that far behind Nagisa (I always rooted for Nagisa till the end though XD). But it is thanks to this that their love grew in me unlike any other couple. It was as I said, REALISTIC. I believe that that is why it hit me way more than any other anime, the end of their love (the death of Nagisa). It devastated me and I was bawling like a little girl (hope I was not the only one XD). But unlike the anime, the movie hardly brought me a few tears.
So in my opinion Anime>Movie :P
Going totally off topic here, the creators weren't fair making Ushio look so much like Nagisa! The first time I saw her I cried all over again!

Kawashima said:
Indeed, in TV it's better. I hated the movie version... In TV it was beautiful relationship.

Mayora-Hime
Going totally off topic here, the creators weren't fair making Ushio look so much like Nagisa! The first time I saw her I cried all over again![/quote said:


Exactly! It wasn't fair at all.. =[
When I saw Ushio, it was just the saddest thing ;__;