Unlucky-kat said: Good game. Host, what are your final thoughts about having investigation instead of lynching on day 1?
All of you were my test subject, so the question should really be: what did all of you think of the first day investigation.
I liked not having to lynch, I don't think I liked the investigation much though. Tbh, it could have even just been requiring a lynch, but having some structure day one was nice. I don't think the investigation served much purpose though, and made the town suspect investigation roles.
Also, it was almost completely useless to the mafia, so...
Just one of those things we wanted to test I agree with u it was pointless in the end but we like to test new stuff here to see if something works I think in a bigger game and when roles are known it would work better.
Hmmm.... I didn't see through mafia's point of view. Yeah, it does kinda seem useless. Killing someone will reveal their role anyway. Might as well not have it.
I liked the idea with having a day where we get to know each other. I think town benefits more from it than a day1 lynch. But I think the mafia should keep their lynch though. It is a good idea but needs to be further developed
Unlucky-kat said: I liked the idea with having a day where we get to know each other. I think town benefits more from it than a day1 lynch. But I think the mafia should keep their lynch though. It is a good idea but needs to be further developed
Seconded. You'd have trouble getting approval from the town for that one, though, because that means the mafia gets the first kill.
I WAS THE COP YOU FOOL this is the Pyro the Drunk edition who speaks
That tells me nothing other than that you are a drunk cop and should not be relied on. jk,
of course I know who you are. although I forgot the reason why we lynched you... I'll go check.
That's really amusing. :P
Somebody's a bit of a sheeeep. (Jk, sort of)
If I remember, we lynched her because we couldn't get a good read on her, then she unconvincingly claimed cop and we didn't believe her because we already had an investigator. 'S that right, Pyro?
I WAS THE COP YOU FOOL this is the Pyro the Drunk edition who speaks
That tells me nothing other than that you are a drunk cop and should not be relied on. jk,
of course I know who you are. although I forgot the reason why we lynched you... I'll go check.
That's really amusing. :P
Somebody's a bit of a sheeeep. (Jk, sort of)
If I remember, we lynched her because we couldn't get a good read on her, then she unconvincingly claimed cop and we didn't believe her because we already have an investigator. 'S that right, Pyro?
That's right and my lovely friend smurph. Do you still think im Woman? :)
I WAS THE COP YOU FOOL this is the Pyro the Drunk edition who speaks
That tells me nothing other than that you are a drunk cop and should not be relied on. jk,
of course I know who you are. although I forgot the reason why we lynched you... I'll go check.
That's really amusing. :P
Somebody's a bit of a sheeeep. (Jk, sort of)
If I remember, we lynched her because we couldn't get a good read on her, then she unconvincingly claimed cop and we didn't believe her because we already have an investigator. 'S that right, Pyro?
That's right and my lovely friend smurph. Do you still think im Woman? :)
Gah! I'm sorry, I did it again..... The shame is heavy right now.... *bows head*
ごえなさい.
Your username even has "maan" in it...
Unlucky-kat said: I liked the idea with having a day where we get to know each other. I think town benefits more from it than a day1 lynch. But I think the mafia should keep their lynch though. It is a good idea but needs to be further developed
Seconded. You'd have trouble getting approval from the town for that one, though, because that means the mafia gets the first kill.
I think it makes somewhat sense that the town shouldn't try to lynch a killer if the killer(s) havn't killed yet. :P
well it was a good game for me ....since i had never played before and made it to last mafia alive....i think i did pretty well trying to hold my own
by claiming to not know what was going on....although it was true for the most part >.>
oh, so you need to guess who cop will investigate that night.
thats not as op, i misunderstood and thought you could frame cop's target no matter who he chooses.
yeah u have to just guess it does lead to intresting situations when cop finds a real mafia and the mafia says he was framed.
They are also differnt versions of cops that do certain things one sees mafia as townies and townies as mafia another is right only 50% of the time and some more variations
[color=#CC0033]-End of the game, finishing on the beginning of the Fifth Day phase -
Though at times the sleepy town was confused as they meticulously tried to kill of the mafia, they played a wonderful, well executed game. The hints of indecision didn’t matter; they pulled through in the end even though people often doubted themselves at times. I’m sure their thought went something along the lines of: could it really be this easy? And I do apologize, for I tried to make the game a balanced one, but I never accounted for the town to play so amazingly, and the mafia to not. Though the mafia had a couple tricks up their sleeves as well, and those tricks worked sometimes, but not always. I commend both the mafia, and the town, for playing a very stacked game against the mafia. I’ll be honest, I wanted to see what would happen if I chose a very small number, (2), of strong players to be the mafia. I never expected one to make a slip so early in the game, but that’s just the way it worked out. Due to this, I added the new player to the mafia’s ranks to try and balance the game once more, but at that point almost everyone knew who to kill. Everyone played wonderfully, and really pulled together as a team. Congratulations town, you win.
pnut87654321- Killed by vigilante- New GF as well as mafia framer
End results: (survivors are underlined)
1. Haine15 – Town Roleblocker 2. Ranoom Killed by vigilante- Jester 3. Gertrudee Killed by mafia- Town Doctor 4. Smurphinator Lynched by town- Mafia Godfather with one-shot bulletproof 5. Mishukax -Comfirmed Townie 6. Unlucky-kat Killed by Sk- Survivor who must live to Day four 7. Suzune-chan Kicked due to inactiveness- Town Investigator 8. The_Pyromaani Lynched by town- Town cop 9. PTYamin- Died while protecting Haine/ killed by mafia- Bodygaurd 10. MaiTai-Lynched by town- Mafia Roleblocker 11. SluttyxPew- Kicked due to inactiveness- Serial Killer 12. Cloud2313- Town Vigilante 13. pnut8654321 Killed by vigilante- Mafia Framer
I knew the game was going to be a town win from that one mistake, but the town also made one mistake as well. I suppose it cancels out in the end. When playing mafia, one must be extremely careful what one posts. I not blaming who made the mistake, but I do blame myself for not being more clear with the rules Maybe I’ll make a better game in the distant future; a game that won’t be fated from one decision.
Sorry for the rough content of this video, but this was a game based off one/single decisions. I think it has a ton of mafia references in it tough. XD (plus U2 is one of my favorite bands)
Feel free to make comments about the game, your personal strategy, or what you think went well/ went poorly.