New
Nov 27, 2016 9:51 PM
#651
@_Claire_ 1. difference in play is the only reason u created a theory. noted. weak reasoning imo 2. Jack voted Dono with a reasoning, that was enough for everyone to follow that vote. u can see Grave followed it 3. u created a theory on grrr so everyone would vote for him and to save urself. it was omgus in a very 'intelligent' way. extra. I reread the thread while I was bored thanks |
Nov 27, 2016 9:54 PM
#652
DenjaX said: Claiming means you say "I am _____" where the blank is the character name or a specific role, or you claim to have a specific skill, or claim you used a certain skill. It counts even if the claim is false.So, I skimmed a bit on the Sign Ups thread and I think there were changes about the set-up in the middle of the sign up. I'll go check it out tomorrow. Still did not find the answers that I was looking for though xDD |
Nov 27, 2016 9:54 PM
#653
Kit said: While I'm not the mod, this was discussed at length in sign ups so I hope that answers your questions...DenjaX said: Claiming means you say "I am _____" where the blank is the character name or a specific role, or you claim to have a specific skill, or claim you used a certain skill. It counts even if the claim is false.So, I skimmed a bit on the Sign Ups thread and I think there were changes about the set-up in the middle of the sign up. I'll go check it out tomorrow. Still did not find the answers that I was looking for though xDD |
Nov 27, 2016 10:01 PM
#654
roleclaiming in general is not encouraged in this game. doesn't mean it's not allowed, but it'll be counted as a strike. today's number of strikes is 5 for example. which was why Dono preferred to not claim before lynch. |
Nov 27, 2016 10:07 PM
#655
Phraze said: @_Claire_ 1. difference in play is the only reason u created a theory. noted. weak reasoning imo 2. Jack voted Dono with a reasoning, that was enough for everyone to follow that vote. u can see Grave followed it 3. u created a theory on grrr so everyone would vote for him and to save urself. it was omgus in a very 'intelligent' way. extra. I reread the thread while I was bored thanks 1. It was day 1 phase?? Do you expect me to come out with awesome reasoning? As you may have noticed I am a newbie :/ 2. Reasoning? No offense but can you even outline that reasoning yoursef because tbh I cannot understand that. 3. I didnt omgus vote Grrr. Grrr alr voted for Jack at that moment, I have no reason to make this intelligent way youre referring to. |
Nov 27, 2016 10:07 PM
#656
DenjaX said: While I do agree that TPR should be left alone if they are not pushing mislynches, I don't think the rest of your plan sounds.. ideal... The chances of RNG hitting town is higher than hitting scum. I think I'd rather actually play the game than gamble. And scum could simply refuse to claim, leaving town to get killed by both RNG and night kill while scum can only be lynched.Kit said: I must say that TPR should be kept alive and let him do what he wants. TPR is a good vote fodder for our endeavours especially for lynching scum. Also, I can already think of a scenario where we could choke players into claiming as a means of extra lynch. This could be good in late game where lynching would not be enough to finish off scum. Of course it has a huge drawbacks but at the same time, it would be a useful tool to pull off with this game mechanic. Confirmed town will force unknown party to claim or else we lynch and if we do, we put them into Russian roulette with third party ability.Do you think TPR should be lynched? If they guess & push people who are scum then it benefits town. Town will win faster if we focus only on scum. Though I guess it's not a big loss if we accidentally lynch TPR instead of scum. @greenwillow Another question, How many times does the third party ability goes into effect? And what do you consider as a "claim"? Does claiming that X person is scum considered as a claim? Does claiming means only when you claim or fake claim a role? Does claiming that "I am a potato" also considered a claim? |
Nov 27, 2016 10:11 PM
#657
So from what I have understood, regardless whether the TPR dies/already won the game/still alive, people will still be in danger for the Russian roulette when people mass claim. Alright, then TPR shouldn't be lynched then. Let him get hit by mafia instead. Besides, we already have a janitored role so massclaiming is pointless. I believe we can use TPR's ability to get an "extra lynch" during the day. I believe it will be useful when the time comes. |
Nov 27, 2016 10:14 PM
#658
DenjaX said: If TPR is out of the game, the RNG will result in the player's role becoming vanilla instead of resulting in a death.So from what I have understood, regardless whether the TPR dies/already won the game/still alive, people will still be in danger for the Russian roulette when people mass claim. Alright, then TPR shouldn't be lynched then. Let him get hit by mafia instead. Besides, we already have a janitored role so massclaiming is pointless. I believe we can use TPR's ability to get an "extra lynch" during the day. I believe it will be useful when the time comes. |
Nov 27, 2016 10:17 PM
#659
Kit said: What the hell? Where did you get that info?If TPR is out of the game, the RNG will result in the player's role becoming vanilla instead of resulting in a death. Under clarification rule: 10. Even when TPR is out of the game people will still be in danger to die if they claim except that no-one will inherit their abilities. Unless the "danger" there means becoming vanilla... |
Nov 27, 2016 10:19 PM
#660
@_Claire_ 1. if u don't know how to scumhunt, don't talk. u played more than the 4 games I and Logic have played, so I'm sure ur smart enough to know that. making a theory simply cuz they're an easy target is scummy 2. reason? it means Jack laid his vote expecting everyone to follow. it didn't need to be the leading train for him to make the wagon happen with the way he talked. 3. u still made a theory on Grrr for nothing. and don't u dare use newbie excuse on me, I'm more new to this than u are. |
Nov 27, 2016 10:21 PM
#661
DenjaX said: It was one of the changes discussed in the sign up thread. There is a contradiction in the "clarifications" section.. points 12 and 13Kit said: What the hell? Where did you get that info?If TPR is out of the game, the RNG will result in the player's role becoming vanilla instead of resulting in a death. Under clarification rule: 10. Even when TPR is out of the game people will still be in danger to die if they claim except that no-one will inherit their abilities. Unless the "danger" there means becoming vanilla... 12. As long as TPR is alive their passive ability regarding claims is in work. And after TPR is out of game if there is ~40% alive players that had claimed they will be RNG'ed and of them will have their left abilities if they have any removed (pretty much they will turn to a vanilla but upon death their original role will be shown). I will also announce it if it happens but not to who though the player himself/herself will be notified, 13. ^If it happens to a mafioso then they will not have abilities anymore but they willl still have a factional kill. |
Nov 27, 2016 10:30 PM
#662
Kit said: Fair enough. Still confusing for me but I shouldn't dwell on this any longer as it distracts anyone from actual scum hunting. Nevertheless, I will still want the TPR to be alive because of his ability. Scum already janitored one player so they can't use what they got for their advantage. I already thought of a lot of things about bending the rules but I'm not sure if the hosts will be happy about that xDDIt was one of the changes discussed in the sign up thread. There is a contradiction in the "clarifications" section.. points 12 and 13 |
Nov 28, 2016 12:29 AM
#663
no. |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
Nov 28, 2016 12:37 AM
#664
DenjaX said: As long as the TPR in play they can make their guess during the night phase.@greenwillow Another question, How many times does the third party ability goes into effect? And what do you consider as a "claim"? Does claiming that X person is scum considered as a claim? Does claiming means only when you claim or fake claim a role? Does claiming that "I am a potato" also considered a claim? 1)no. 2)When you claim this game's role, character or admit your role when someone asks you if their guess is correct. 3)Potato is not the game's role. Don't worry you can say that you are a potato. Potato Master encourages this kind of claims, but might as well leave it outside the thread. |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
Nov 28, 2016 12:46 AM
#665
Phraze said: DenjaX said: I still haven't caught up yet and I checked the current status of the votes and I must say that I don't like the current train at all. got a point. I'm suspicious of Claire and Jack. @coromandel why did u vote for grr? u said he feels town to u. That was my initial impression of him, but I'm thinking people might have jumped on dono's train to save grrr. That's how grave's tunneling looks like to me, an attempt to save grrr. I don't like how he hasn't posted anything yet, so maybe I'll change my vote to Astros after all. Although that could also be a strategy - not to post anything, hoping that people don't want to lynch an inactive. >.> Idk. _Claire_ said: Phraze said: @_Claire_ 1. difference in play is the only reason u created a theory. noted. weak reasoning imo 2. Jack voted Dono with a reasoning, that was enough for everyone to follow that vote. u can see Grave followed it 3. u created a theory on grrr so everyone would vote for him and to save urself. it was omgus in a very 'intelligent' way. extra. I reread the thread while I was bored thanks 1. It was day 1 phase?? Do you expect me to come out with awesome reasoning? As you may have noticed I am a newbie :/ 2. Reasoning? No offense but can you even outline that reasoning yoursef because tbh I cannot understand that. 3. I didnt omgus vote Grrr. Grrr alr voted for Jack at that moment, I have no reason to make this intelligent way youre referring to. *cough* _Claire_ said: @coromandel Why are you expecting her to claim like 10mins before? Also it was going to be really chaotic, also if she lives it will be a burden on the claim's limit. And no I am more referring to Ruu's saying she will proly sort of make my vote indicative of my alignment. (thus the blaming) And it is okay not to trust my reasoning cause I dont trust you either. Because people usually claim to avoid being lynched. Especially when they're town, not so much when they're scum - because someone would counter-claim them eventually. It'd have made more sense to claim, because it was day 1 and she would have been the first player on that list - we were far away from reaching the "magic number" 6, so I thought that was scummy. Kit said: coromandel said: Gruffin was town. We didn't find out his role (= janitor kill) and willow posted that "today's magical number is 5" => tpr is still alive.
Day 1 _Claire_ > grrr aa-dono > Soren > Jackrito > Gruffin Kit > logic340 > grrr logic340 > Phraze > Kit grrr > _Claire_ > Jackrito Jackrito > Rinto-kun > aa-dono Rinto-kun > Luna Soren > aa-dono Ruu > grrr Phraze >_Claire_ > grave_robber (> grrr, voted 5 minutes after phase end) Gruffin > coromandel > unvote > aa-dono Luna > _Claire_ grave_robber > Kit > Rinto-kun > aa-dono (> grrr, voted a few seconds after phase end) coromandel > _Claire_ > Soren > Gruffin Kit votes for logic340 Jackrito votes for Rinto-kun Gruffin votes for coromandel grave_robber votes for Kit aa-dono votes for Soren logic340 votes for Phraze Luna votes for _Claire_ Ruu votes for grrr coromandel votes for _Claire_ VC 1.1 Rinto-kun votes for Luna grrr votes for _Claire_ Soren votes for aa-dono grrr votes for Jackrito _Claire_ votes for grrr Gruffin unvotes Kit votes for grrr VC 1.2 aa-dono votes for Jackrito grave_robber votes for Rinto-kun coromandel votes for Soren Phraze votes for _Claire_ Jackrito votes for aa-dono VC 1.3 grave_robber votes for aa-dono logic340 votes for Kit Gruffin votes for aa-dono Phraze votes for grave_robber aa-dono votes for Gruffin VC 1.4 coromandel votes for Gruffin VC 1.5 (Final vote count) grave_robber votes for grrr (too late - wasn't counted) Phraze votes for grrr (too late) aa-dono (4) // Soren, Jackrito, Gruffin, grave_robber grrr (3) // Ruu, _Claire_, Kit Jackrito (1) // grrr Luna (1) // Rinto-kun Kit (1) // logic340 _Claire_ (1) // Luna grave_robber (1) // Phraze Gruffin (2) // aa-dono, coromandel Not voting: ~ Vote count 1 logic340 (1) // Kit Rinto-kun (1) // Jackrito coromandel (1) // Gruffin Kit (1) //grave_robber Soren (1) // aa-dono Phraze (1) // logic340 _Claire_ (2) // Luna, coromandel grrr (1) // Ruu Not voting: Claire, grrr, Rinto-kun, Soren, Phraze VC 2 grrr (3) // Ruu, _Claire_, Kit _Claire_ (2) // Luna, coromandel Rinto-kun (1) // Jackrito Kit (1) //grave_robber Soren (1) // aa-dono Phraze (1) // logic340 Luna (1) // Rinto-kun aa-dono (1) // Soren Jackrito (1) // grrr Not voting: Phraze, Gruffin Claire and Kit voted for grrr. 2 main trains were now grrr and Claire. VC 3 grrr (3) // Ruu, _Claire_, Kit _Claire_ (2) // Luna, Phraze Jackrito (2) // grrr, aa-dono aa-dono (2) // Soren, Jackrito Rinto-kun (1) // grave_robber Phraze (1) // logic340 Luna (1) // Rinto-kun Soren (1) // coromandel Not voting: Gruffin dono and Jack voted for each other, which created more trains. Jack's vote was OMGUS. VC 4 aa-dono (4) // Soren, Jackrito, Gruffin, grave_robber grrr (3) // Ruu, _Claire_, Kit Jackrito (1) // grrr Luna (1) // Rinto-kun Soren (1) // coromandel Kit (1) // logic340 _Claire_ (1) // Luna grave_robber (1) // Phraze Gruffin (1) // aa-dono Not voting: - It was Gruffin and Grave who made dono lead in votes. Grrr's train didn't change at all, he never had more than 3 votes. VC 5 (Final) aa-dono (4) // Soren, Jackrito, Gruffin, grave_robber grrr (3) // Ruu, _Claire_, Kit Jackrito (1) // grrr Luna (1) // Rinto-kun Kit (1) // logic340 _Claire_ (1) // Luna grave_robber (1) // Phraze Gruffin (2) // aa-dono, coromandel Not voting: -
@Phraze Why did you decide to change your vote to grrr? You voted for him 5 minutes after phase change too, did you not realize the day had already ended by then? hmm.. you're right. Kit said: Ruu said: Maybe Astro is saying.. because Grave has a cold, she may not have the energy to be reading people carefully and being careful about what she says? o_o Sounds like just an excuse thoughAstros said: Hopefully you're considering her physical condition when analyzing her posts. can you explain this? I really want to know what you meant xD +1 Especially since she was very active and her playstyle was aggressive too. Maybe she didn't feel well, but she seemed energetic enough to me. It doesn't explain why she was tunneling on aa-dono, imo. Not being energetic => I'd expect her not to post much and/or be a bit more passive than usual, which wasn't the case. |
Nov 28, 2016 12:50 AM
#666
@grrr @Rinto-kun where are you? |
Nov 28, 2016 2:51 AM
#667
@coromandel Grave prob noticed Grrr gave town vibes, so she was stirring things up for a new target. I remember her gameplay in the last game, stirring things up on D1. she didn't tunnel on Dono at all, only stir things up. Grrr is hard to tell. he does come off as town this game.. but what turns me the wrong way about him was how he 'thanked' Grave after the lynch, in the form of a good night, which Gruffin noticed. I'm pretty sure it should be Grrr over Astros if we gotta lynch. but there's one thing clear, Claire don't appear to be in the same faction as Jack. a lynch on one of them would be more informative. Claire is esp scummy tho, making a theory based off gameplay bs? |
Nov 28, 2016 3:25 AM
#668
Why is this so dead, I'm currently making a readlist/overview of game which is taking a while, but we can't afford to be overall inactive. |
Nov 28, 2016 3:29 AM
#669
Jackrito said: I am with you on this one. I was hoping to see more activity when I woke up. grrr and Soren's lack of activity is upsetting but would both scum really be inactive together? Isn't a that a good way to get oneself lynched??Why is this so dead, I'm currently making a readlist/overview of game which is taking a while, but we can't afford to be overall inactive. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Nov 28, 2016 3:31 AM
#670
I will read today Nanatsu no Taizai chapter then come back to this. @Soren @Rinto-kun @grrr where are you? Please add something of use to the thread. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Nov 28, 2016 3:41 AM
#671
logic340 said: Jackrito said: I am with you on this one. I was hoping to see more activity when I woke up. grrr and Soren's lack of activity is upsetting but would both scum really be inactive together? Isn't a that a good way to get oneself lynched??Why is this so dead, I'm currently making a readlist/overview of game which is taking a while, but we can't afford to be overall inactive. Both are pretty lurk heavy if town or scum so maybe, but I don't like to think that easy, Soren needs to offer more though since I know he can be good and what makes him scum. based off my reread only on Page 5 but Grave is not looking as Great as I though during day one, Rinto is terrible as well. Same as Luna/denja both of rinto and luna did nothing day one, Luna is pretty good as town not sure as scum, so possible this is part of it I know she was busy but it was all fluff. I also dislike some of Kit's early stuff. This will be a while though i have a habit of overdoing my analyzing really should of done this at night. |
Nov 28, 2016 3:53 AM
#672
the momentum of activity died along with the night phase. I'm swingy about Jack/Logic/Kit. Soren/Rinto feel like reserve scum. Coro is starting to look bad to me for wanting to vote Grave/Astros. Grrr makes a fine scummy troll atm. Ruu seems pro town. my summary of things lead to Claire being scum. end of story, nothing much. |
Nov 28, 2016 4:04 AM
#673
hmmm @Jackrito I'm starting to have 2nd thoughts on u now.. Grave clearly wasn't on the same page as u so pointing that out puts me at ease. [edit: Grave/Claire seem to be on the same page so depending on what u come up with, I might go with u as town and Claire as scum.] |
PhrazeNov 28, 2016 4:08 AM
Nov 28, 2016 4:07 AM
#674
I'm still open for questions, but that won't progress the game. Hmm... I'm not sure if anyone is actually scum-hunting... Vote: grrr I want some defense from him, I don't know if he even plays. On the other hand, I'll see what happened in votes today. Oh, and one more thing. If it's possible, I'd like to avoid a lynch by any means and give some time to our town investigative roles to search. |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Nov 28, 2016 4:11 AM
#675
Phraze said: hmmm @Jackrito I'm starting to have 2nd thoughts on u now.. Grave clearly wasn't on the same page as u so pointing that out puts me at ease. Grave is who I'm keeping my vote on today, main reason for this is she voted Dono, off my reasons, but next post she accuses Dono of still voting Soren ,and been in RVS, This shows me she did not read my reasons, since that was a main point in my case on Dono their vote on me. The way she did not know Dono's vote shows she did not care for my reasons only the vote in it. Which is used to setup me up for the mislynch and she cared little about the game and posts. The way she tried to distance from the lynch late on is bad as well |
Nov 28, 2016 4:12 AM
#676
Phraze said: hmmm @Jackrito I'm starting to have 2nd thoughts on u now.. Grave clearly wasn't on the same page as u so pointing that out puts me at ease. [edit: Grave/Claire seem to be on the same page so depending on what u come up with, I might go with u as town and Claire as scum.] i don't think they were on same page grave seemed to take issue with Claire a bit and did not vote grr when asked she easily could of done it. |
Nov 28, 2016 4:22 AM
#677
Jackrito said: Phraze said: hmmm @Jackrito I'm starting to have 2nd thoughts on u now.. Grave clearly wasn't on the same page as u so pointing that out puts me at ease. Grave is who I'm keeping my vote on today, main reason for this is she voted Dono, off my reasons, but next post she accuses Dono of still voting Soren ,and been in RVS, This shows me she did not read my reasons, since that was a main point in my case on Dono their vote on me. The way she did not know Dono's vote shows she did not care for my reasons only the vote in it. Which is used to setup me up for the mislynch and she cared little about the game and posts. The way she tried to distance from the lynch late on is bad as well This is the evidence from my readlist to show the posts in question Dono vote This annoys me since, they vote Dono off my reasons not their own, which they had shown before, this makes me feel they are setting me up, Calls out kit again could maybe be scum buddies, same with Rinto This is the a slipup here grave's slipup Here she accuses Dono of not voting and been stuck in RVS the issue here is, she liked my reasons on dono but did not know Dono was voting me not possible, since this was a main point in my case. This shows she did not read my reasons only the vote and wanted to set me up. They is a 9 post gap no way she forgot. Graves's second mistake Here she says she just noticed the vote change, yet more evidence she did not read my post. |
Nov 28, 2016 4:34 AM
#678
Rinto-kun said: This is pretty horrible for your first post in pages... Why wont asking you questions advance anything? Why don't you show us what scum-hunting truly is?I'm still open for questions, but that won't progress the game. Hmm... I'm not sure if anyone is actually scum-hunting... Vote: grrr I want some defense from him, I don't know if he even plays. On the other hand, I'll see what happened in votes today. Oh, and one more thing. If it's possible, I'd like to avoid a lynch by any means and give some time to our town investigative roles to search. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Nov 28, 2016 4:36 AM
#679
logic340 said: Rinto-kun said: This is pretty horrible for your first post in pages... Why wont asking you questions advance anything? Why don't you show us what scum-hunting truly is?I'm still open for questions, but that won't progress the game. Hmm... I'm not sure if anyone is actually scum-hunting... Vote: grrr I want some defense from him, I don't know if he even plays. On the other hand, I'll see what happened in votes today. Oh, and one more thing. If it's possible, I'd like to avoid a lynch by any means and give some time to our town investigative roles to search. No, I'm the most horrible person you'd look for scum-hunting. Also scum-hunting as I've seen it is more like pointing at one another and catching on some weird phrasings, not asking questions. |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Nov 28, 2016 4:37 AM
#680
What I don't like is that Jackrito doesn't even try poking me. Mafia....? :O |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Nov 28, 2016 4:38 AM
#681
logic340 said: Rinto-kun said: This is pretty horrible for your first post in pages... Why wont asking you questions advance anything? Why don't you show us what scum-hunting truly is?I'm still open for questions, but that won't progress the game. Hmm... I'm not sure if anyone is actually scum-hunting... Vote: grrr I want some defense from him, I don't know if he even plays. On the other hand, I'll see what happened in votes today. Oh, and one more thing. If it's possible, I'd like to avoid a lynch by any means and give some time to our town investigative roles to search. He is doing what Shinchi does as scum which is shame others, while adding little themselves, never seen him do it though so this is new to me. He did this at night blaming others for Dono lynch. His wanting to not be lynched is bad as well it is too self aware, |
Nov 28, 2016 4:39 AM
#682
I don't see the point anymore, I would rather work on other stuff then try to make you active, don't worry I know what you are doing though. |
Nov 28, 2016 4:48 AM
#683
I have changed my view on Soren now as well, he for me is not town, in none of his posts is he scum hunting, just defending his prediction and commenting on things, He never once talked about voting and the lynch.The only time he actually suspected someone was Grave ,and that was from the RVS phase only, and was weak as hell. He is showing a lack of deeper thinking and hunting, he does this as scum because he can't make up a case on someone so tries to look busy. My only issue is since his main suspect is Grave, does this make Grave town, based off my read on Grave I doubt it, so this is making me wonder if this is a weak bus to make each other look town if one dies. I'm keeping vote on Grave but neither for me are town. |
Nov 28, 2016 5:06 AM
#684
@Jackrito I did mention in a post that Grrr 'thanked' Grave, which Gruffin noticed. I'm pretty sure there's something to get out of that. not sure if it's a setup on Grave as well, or a scum greeting. for Grave to take a spin at ur reasoning tho, it was weird. does this mean Grrr is scum? I voted Claire followed by ur vote on Dono, but Grave took ur lead. why's that? I'm still suspicious of Claire, but her weird behavior could be normal(?) @Rinto-kun u make me want to vote u. ur practically scumclaiming by appearing just to shade Jack. |
Nov 28, 2016 5:19 AM
#685
They are more examples in the EOD of Grave not reading peoples posts as shown from a bit from reads here. Graves pressure grave is yet again appling pressure on dono, it just feels bad this post she seems certain Dono is bad, but at end mentions inactives and doubts, this does not match up with first half. Reply to dono This is a bad reply dono explained herself fine and makes sense why she did not vote, Clear that Grave did not care at this point. reply to me yet again she is clearly not reading fully, I never mentioned sorens thing on why I suspected her, tried to get dono to claim I think this was because she wanted a role and then flip lynch on grr. |
Nov 28, 2016 5:25 AM
#686
Phraze said: @Jackrito I did mention in a post that Grrr 'thanked' Grave, which Gruffin noticed. I'm pretty sure there's something to get out of that. not sure if it's a setup on Grave as well, or a scum greeting. for Grave to take a spin at ur reasoning tho, it was weird. does this mean Grrr is scum? I voted Claire followed by ur vote on Dono, but Grave took ur lead. why's that? I'm still suspicious of Claire, but her weird behavior could be normal(?) @Rinto-kun u make me want to vote u. ur practically scumclaiming by appearing just to shade Jack. Don't worry, it's just a quality of mine to get the votes. If the status quo hasn't changed by the end of the phase, guess I will try being more active. The thread is kind of dead right now. Jackrito said: I don't see the point anymore, I would rather work on other stuff then try to make you active, don't worry I know what you are doing though. Oi, I may be completely oblivious to some things, but I'm observant. Btw by now we should be 8-3-1. At the start of D3(if we mislynch again) it's going to be 6-3-1 which would be really easy for the mafia to win knowing what roles they have janitored and deceiving. And on D4(the hopeless ending) it's going to be 4-3-1. At this rate it would be kid's play for the mafia to lure the TPR and help him with the win con. So yes, we'd better catch a scum. |
~ ~ Anime List ~ ~ Manga List ~ ~ |
Nov 28, 2016 5:30 AM
#687
Ok I just got to end of day one, based off it all they is no way Grave is town my whole case on them below, the main parts are posted here already. pretty big so will spoiler,I have stuff on others but I want to be uptodate before I post that Starts off by asking about players they don't know, I like this because shows interest in player base , but can be used as a way to find easy targets though. Calls me out I expect this, and like it because wants me to be active. Has a early push on Dono Moves onto color discussion this is a good icebreaker but why not start with this? This carried on too long as well. The way Gruffin townread this still annoys me. Starts to get into game at 103 by giving meta read on Ruu Ruu read , needed to be asked though, the answer is a lot of words just to come to a neutral read this catches my eye. Goes back to fluff, but questions grr on plans, I like this because a lack of grr plan is bad. Puts doubt on Gruffin from old game i understand why though. Inactive callout Calls out Kit and Logic, I find is strange why only them, Logic was not here at all but Kit had done about same as some others. Says loves to suspect me and does suspect ,me but never outright talk to me or call me out. Comes back at Return post Gives some doubts on Grr, but then puts it down to them been Grr i did this as well so can't complain. Reasons on Kit's Question to Dono, I like this because this comes form a Grave town mindset.A lot of paranoia. post to Dono is aggressive but this is Graves play style, their annoyance at been misquoted I get. Pressure on dono Next points on dono been lacking I agree with, also their view on Dono voting me for bad reasons I agree with it is a big push on Dono but I did same to disagree with this makes me a hypocrite. I'm not sure how I became in her top 3 though, with Grr, since we are both neutral to her. next big post This messes me up a lot, since in this post she says happy with vote on Kit, but last post said want to vote was Dono, me and Grr. I like their points on Grr though. Theot want to vote Soren,Dono, and Rinto is a vast change from last post me and Grr are gone and Rinto and Soren are in. This looks like a list of easy mislynches hate this post. A lot of VCA then votes Rinto I can get behind reasons Next post First point is very strange, and it annoys me, just seems to be annoyance at Grr more then anything, 2 point I don't really get at all, 3 is not relevant, 4 Not sure why she saw this as positive, 5 is valid. Dono vote This annoys me since they vote Dono off my reasons, not their own, which they had shown, this makes me feel they are setting me up, Calls out Kit again could maybe be scum buddies, same with Rinto This is the a slipup here grave's slipup Here she accuses Dono of not voting and been stuck in RVS the issue here is, she liked my reasons on dono but did not know Dono was voting me not possible, since this was a main point. This shows she did not read my reasons only the vote and wanted to set me up. They is a 9 post gap no way she forgot. Graves's second mistake Here she says she just noticed the vote change, yet more evidence she did not read my post. Graves next big post posts on Ruu appear forced, logic post is ok I guess, The Soren interaction is intresting they both did the same thing and both have reasons they won't say yeah I bet. The Rage at Soren looks fake to me she would be more mad at this then is shown. grave is yet again appling pressure on dono, it just feels bad this post she seems certain Dono is bad, but at end mentions inactives and doubts, this does not match up with first half. Reply to dono This is a bad reply dono explained herself fine and makes sense why she did not vote, Clear that Grave did not care at this point. reply to me yet again she is clearly not reading fully, I never mentioned soren's thing on why I suspected her, tried to get dono to claim I think this was because she wanted a role, and then flip lynch on grr. Finally she vote changes to grr in last min, I think she mistimed this and it would of made a tie, Grave would not make a tie willingly as town, the change to grr also makes no sense. I see this as a way to frame me and Claire at same time if either flipped town. Also puts blame on lurkers. |
Nov 28, 2016 5:32 AM
#688
catching up ~ |
Nov 28, 2016 5:33 AM
#689
Also after that read I really should not of voted dono, and wish i could of been there EOD because they came across a lot more town and Grave did not. |
Nov 28, 2016 5:40 AM
#690
Rinto-kun said: Phraze said: @Jackrito I did mention in a post that Grrr 'thanked' Grave, which Gruffin noticed. I'm pretty sure there's something to get out of that. not sure if it's a setup on Grave as well, or a scum greeting. for Grave to take a spin at ur reasoning tho, it was weird. does this mean Grrr is scum? I voted Claire followed by ur vote on Dono, but Grave took ur lead. why's that? I'm still suspicious of Claire, but her weird behavior could be normal(?) @Rinto-kun u make me want to vote u. ur practically scumclaiming by appearing just to shade Jack. Don't worry, it's just a quality of mine to get the votes. If the status quo hasn't changed by the end of the phase, guess I will try being more active. The thread is kind of dead right now. Jackrito said: I don't see the point anymore, I would rather work on other stuff then try to make you active, don't worry I know what you are doing though. Oi, I may be completely oblivious to some things, but I'm observant. Btw by now we should be 8-3-1. At the start of D3(if we mislynch again) it's going to be 6-3-1 which would be really easy for the mafia to win knowing what roles they have janitored and deceiving. And on D4(the hopeless ending) it's going to be 4-3-1. At this rate it would be kid's play for the mafia to lure the TPR and help him with the win con. So yes, we'd better catch a scum. Ok thanks for this, how about you give me a way to catch scum, instead of a running narrative if I was not so sure Grave was bad I would be voting you here. |
Nov 28, 2016 5:53 AM
#691
reevaluation(thanks to some input from Coro/Jack/Rinto) town Logic: good impression as usual Ruu: reacted well to my meta pressure Coro: I'm curious about the choice of voting Grave over Grrr? tho it's positive so far neutral Luna Denja: the way he wants TPR alive or as a buffer sound good(?) Jack: I'm at ease that he pointed Grave out for framing him. but too early to tell Claire: weird~ Kit: inactive since the start of this game. hasn't generated opinions unless asked Soren: not very active Grave Astros: running through Jack's reasoning was bad. but again, her playstyle is usually stirring things up. scum Grrr: the thanks to Grave post-lynch was weird Rinto: appeared only to fluffpost vote and shade going with the confirmed targets Vote: grrr |
Nov 28, 2016 5:59 AM
#692
wow 7 posts when I refresh... if Grave and Grr are scum, then it doesn't matter which train we vote for? Grr looks like the lesser of two greater evils tho |
Nov 28, 2016 6:01 AM
#693
Rinto-kun said: I don't see you asking questions or catching people up on their phrasing or word choice either though. You've offered little in the way of "constructive posts" I was honestly wondering if you erupted Gerry changed out or modkilled today. I'd like for you to be a helpful town (if you are town) otherwise I find your actions very hard to reason with.logic340 said: Rinto-kun said: I'm still open for questions, but that won't progress the game. Hmm... I'm not sure if anyone is actually scum-hunting... Vote: grrr I want some defense from him, I don't know if he even plays. On the other hand, I'll see what happened in votes today. Oh, and one more thing. If it's possible, I'd like to avoid a lynch by any means and give some time to our town investigative roles to search. No, I'm the most horrible person you'd look for scum-hunting. Also scum-hunting as I've seen it is more like pointing at one another and catching on some weird phrasings, not asking questions. |
Proud Administrator of the D Gray Man FC and OnePunch-Man FC |
Nov 28, 2016 6:04 AM
#694
@Rinto-kun I'm far from convinced u are town. starting off with a scummy fluffpost and now talking statistics.. it doesn't help u there |
Nov 28, 2016 6:32 AM
#695
Will do a VC in some time xd |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
Nov 28, 2016 6:36 AM
#696
borrón y cuenta nueva @Astros I decided to read everything again with out using meta or taking into account my last analysis. I want to blame my analysis on lack of sleep but that's not fair. So I'll just say my analysis was weak and I was too stubborn to admit it. This doesn't mean I think you are 100% town, it means that for now I'm not getting a strong scum read from Grave/you so I don't think you should get lynch today. You are neutral for now. That been said, I'm looking forward to read more from you to get a better reading. We shouldn't lynch you just because grave looked scummy. unvote Any new reads since we last spoke? Confused @Phraze has finally appeared! :D The whole post about Claire and Jack being in different factions but both scummy oh god. I think you need to organise your thoughts first and post them later so we can better understand your reasoning. @Rinto-kun seriously? That's it? no scum hunting? no q's , no nothing? @DenjaX I like your posts so far but your vote hurt my feelings T^T |
Nov 28, 2016 6:49 AM
#697
~Vote Count 2.3~ grrr(6) // coromandel, _Claire_, Soren, Kit, Rinto-kun, Phraze Astros(2) // logic340, Jackrito Ruu(1) // DenjaX Not voting : grrr, Astros, Ruu TIMER |
supercalifragilisticexpialidocious |
Nov 28, 2016 6:52 AM
#698
Nov 28, 2016 6:54 AM
#699
You just said I am so not scummy and now you vote me :(. It doesn't make any sense. By the way coro is town. and Claire is mafia. |
More topics from this board
» [GAME] (* ̄・ ̄)ノ Count to 30 Before a Slightly Inebriated Staff Member Posts! v4 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Togs - Jul 2, 2017 |
2866 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:07 AM |
|
» [GAME] Last Letter Game ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )grave_robber - Sep 9, 2014 |
8750 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» Count To 7777 V3 ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Lambtron - May 15, 2018 |
1159 |
by fausifahrial
»»
Nov 7, 2023 9:06 AM |
|
» [GAME] Say something about the person above you ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Haine - Jul 19, 2014 |
3810 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 19, 2023 2:43 PM |
|
» [GAME] Truth or dare (ToD) 2.0 [Round 5] ( 1 2 )Lambtron - Mar 12, 2019 |
92 |
by Zymf
»»
Jun 18, 2023 12:09 PM |