| Idk I'd give it a 6 following 1st ep, felt too predictable/convenient at times + some nonsensical stuff which very noticeably clashes with the more serious themes it covers. I also thought it was common knowledge that idol industry and analogous orgs are cut throat and have more regard for money than people (you could say this about any capitalistic industry though lol, how is this news?) so it's strange seeing fans praise that aspect of the writing so much. The art and animation was really nice though, gotta give em that, but the studio did Shikimori-san so was kinda to be expected. |
 |
| It probably won't last as long as I'd like it to be but enjoy it while you can haha. It definitely deserves this recognition. |
 |
| Its popular due to the author creating Kaguya Sama, one of the most popular romcom series out there right now and he wrote this one too, so the success is there. |
 |
| Surprised it's passed the score of Jigokuraku. I thought manga readers would've hyped it up more -_- I guess it's just the times now |
Mukche said: As if positive botting doesn't exist lmao.AdolZeppeli said: Who cares? every time something reaches the top spot will eventually go down, this isn't an exception. Yea bc of FMA bot’s being a nuisance |
| "We could make the world better, but it's easier to just shut our eyes." ~Blackwall |
| It's good and the author is popular because of Kaguya-sama, which is also good. Overall it's overhyped and people are a bit irrational about it, but hey |
  Grant me one hour on love's most sacred shores To clasp the bosom that my soul adores, Lie heart to heart and merge my soul with yours |
| I was aware of its manga popularity and the author's prestige reputation. I knew it was going to be a popular one this season but this type of reception from the fans and the like is a surprise. Due to the wider appeal that this series has, combined with superb production based on the first episode, Oshi no Ko just shot through the roof. It is what it is. |
Confused_100 said: EmpressTrace said: Actually made my account just to contest this. https://imgur.com/a/9BQfBgl You can see this anime in third place on Japanese Twitter trending, literally just below the major Nintendo reveals from today. These are also the exact same stats on Gettytrends. The idea that it's an unpopular anime with manufactured positivity contained to MAL doesn't survive a quick google. Edit: A few more screen grabs.The first proves this trending tag relates to this anime, the second shows that the site he was using as a source shows it trending just under Zelda, with a similar number of tweets. https://imgur.com/a/f6nuPWK Yet the guy said worldwide LOL. You really lost that quick google search huh. Also manufactured votes, I have proven already. Just look at episode 1 thread, alot of new fake accounts giving 10s. Along with bots repeating the same words. So congrats you lost this one too. Now let me see, you said 3rd in Japan right? From data shown enter my site and press on the name, see the graph. The maximum position was number 3, not 1 so congrats. It lost legs after just 4 hours from airing and the episode is 90 minutes long, that’s bad. Then it dies out after 8 hours from airing, only rose in the last 3 hours because of re runs. Now compare this trending to actual other anime which are Super popular. Even Boruto got number 1 in Japan LOL. That says alot. Congrats Oshi no Ko lost to Boruto’s trending in Japan. And wasnot popular worldwide. Now do you want to try again? You can try and fool anyone with Zero background but not me. I will look into everything you say and if it’s not true, I will tear it apart. Like how this fandom is trying to act that there are only bots for 1s and no bots for 10s. It was trending to me all day yesterday and I don't use it on Japanese Twitter, so yeah, I can confirm that it was trending all day long. I don't have a screenshot though, I never thought a conversation like this one would even exist since it is quite obvious that the series is popular. |
Because Oshi no Ko is BETTER than Fullmetal Alchemist. That's why.  |
 |
| Vote manipulation because MAL allows votes to count even when only 1 episode is out. It'll even out eventually. |
   |
Ballin_Editz said: that is if you're implying ever single anime viewer has brain rot and stan this series, which I doubt.AdolZeppeli said: Who cares? every time something reaches the top spot will eventually go down, this isn't an exception. As a manga reader of this series I can assure you it’s gonna be there for a loooooong while. Iykyk. |
| "We could make the world better, but it's easier to just shut our eyes." ~Blackwall |
Confused_100 said: Ionliosite2 said: It was trending to me all day yesterday and I don't use it on Japanese Twitter, so yeah, I can confirm that it was trending all day long. I don't have a screenshot though, I never thought a conversation like this one would even exist since it is quite obvious that the series is popular. Where are you from? The trending data is uploaded almost hourly (almost here means either hourly or less not more) so I don’t know when it trended. Or just tell me when and I will try to find it. But it never trended like that at all. In Japan, it was topping at 3 but not for long even. 3 hours max. And you need to put runtime as a parameter when you look at how it trended. Worldwide, didnot find any trace of it. USA, saw it was 30 something, maybe 31 but that’s also nothing as even alot of newly aired animes trend when they air. Maybe because you were following the topic? Because that’s the only way it trends to anyone outside Japan really but then again I didn’t look at every country. I haven't even liked a single post related to Oshi no Ko, in fact, not even something related to it popped in my feed before it became something trending, so I definitely wasn't following the topic. |
Xefly said: Confused_100 said: Same mindset. FMAB living rent free in this fandom’s mind. And fandom acts like it doesn’t have 10s bots and fake accounts. Ah yeah they do in episode 1 thread… You're a dumbass who didnt watch the episode. You litteraly have no right to sh*t on an anime you never watched, you're trying your hardest to say it's not a trending anime https://twitter.com/HusbandofEmilia/status/1644218179042910209?t=wTGEYPAO9-7Du8AU65QT4A&s=19 it litteraly surpassed Zelda on Twitter keep watching FMAB which ended in 2010 and keep bragging about it in 2023 Absolute Dumbass. this anime doesn't even have a fandom yet and you're like "FMAB fans live rent free in your heads" NO SHIT cause they're the most Toxic fandom ever, imagine rating every good anime a 1 to get FMAB an anime that aired in 2009 to number 1 in 2023 the sad part, they dont even watch anime. >This anime doesnt even have a fandom yet >Gets number #1 spot in MAL Yeah, sure. And the most toxic fandom definitely isn't FMA's, it is more likely to be Shingeki no Kyojin's fandom or even Boku no Hero Academia's fandom. |
Confused_100 said: Ballin_Editz said: As a manga reader of this series I can assure you it’s gonna be there for a loooooong while. Iykyk. Actually I know. And this drops off hard after a certain point… Iykyk bro how long are you gonna go around every thread telling people it drops off later lmao. like thanks, we get it. |
 "86 part one is far better than part two and one of the most masterfully told stories i have ever seen" -bocchi 'the rock' johnson real quote. she said it not me |
Xefly said: Ionliosite2 said: >This anime doesnt even have a fandom yet >Gets number #1 spot in MAL Yeah, sure. And the most toxic fandom definitely isn't FMA's, it is more likely to be Shingeki no Kyojin's fandom or even Boku no Hero Academia's fandom. Absolutely nobody expected it to get number 1. Multiple people from many fandoms enjoyed this anime lol why do you think it's still number 1? AOT fans clearly enjoyed it too I expected it, I even told my brother about it before it premiered, but I didn't mention it on MAL forums. I mean, if someone who likes AoT also likes Oshi no Ko that can mean they became or can become a part of Oshi no Ko's fandom, there is no a single exclusive fandom a person can partake in, you can be member of multiple fandoms at the same time. |
daiotaku said: hich4n_ said: Oh yeah bro a gynecologists being murdered and reborn as the child of a pregnant teen idol. Totally predictable, such a cliché. Idk I'd give it a 6 following 1st ep, felt too predictable/convenient at times + some nonsensical stuff which very noticeably clashes with the more serious themes it covers. I also thought it was common knowledge that idol industry and analogous orgs are cut throat and have more regard for money than people (you could say this about any capitalistic industry though lol, how is this news?) so it's strange seeing fans praise that aspect of the writing so much. The art and animation was really nice though, gotta give em that, but the studio did Shikimori-san so was kinda to be expected. I didn't mean the Nvm, I just saw the reborn as her child part is in the synopsis so that was already known. |
hich4n_Apr 13, 2023 4:00 PM
|
More topics from this board
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Usopp8000 - Mar 27, 2023 |
2681 |
by WSP__2
»»
Yesterday, 3:54 PM |
|
Poll: » Would you like to marry Ai given the opportunity? (first ep spoilers)Shizuna - May 6 |
40 |
by A_Yaze
»»
May 11, 8:38 AM |
|
» OverhypedMooogle - May 9 |
41 |
by KayKimii
»»
May 10, 11:44 AM |
|
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Yuyuichi - Jun 28, 2023 |
680 |
by Darkiiii
»»
May 6, 10:23 PM |
|
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Ricky16 - May 17, 2023 |
869 |
by Tsukimariko
»»
May 5, 7:13 PM |