Attack on Titan
(FOR MANGA READERS) Would you like a different end for the anime?
Xacobe01 said: I don't want the point of view of a YouTuber, they tend to be full of shit, since they only want to generate polarizing content that generates discussions so that they can please the algorithm. I can also send you a video of 1hr telling why Eren's character was not assassinated, people just forgot who he was. I want to see your points. Christ, this man might be the saltiest thing on earth, even more salty than umi da. Goddamn asshole acting all high and mighty and that only he truly understands the thematic of AoT with his redditor brain "Now please, if you don't mind, get out and let people who did understand the story talk." If a post answers the topic regardless of opinion there shouldn't be any problems with whether or not someone "understands the theme" in the first place. How about you get off the internet while this show is airing? Nobody wants some salty ending defender who can't see clear flaws in the ending and pretends to understand everything. Even past the flaws in the ending, there are a lot things people would clearly not be happy about which they are trying to express in this discussion along if they wanted to see a different ending or not, so you're in the wrong place kiddo. |
I imagine it's because he's directly relating it to the anime for "anime ending" and not "manga ending". The "for manga readers" could just be a spoiler warning |
| better execution and choice of words, remove the low-key comedy moments since things revolve around genocide, it's uncalled for and out of place, no need to make Eren breaking down like that just to show he still can feel compassion and loves Mikasa as well, the execution could be better, it was juvenile When Eren said he would've continued the Rumbling if Armin and gang didn't stop him then Armin asked "why?" he said "i wanted to do that... i had to...", this is a very selfish and childish motivation from Eren, again we're talking about billions died by his hand. no need to reveal Paradis getting destroyed, yes it may not be the fault of the characters that we know but still one of the main goals of the rumbling was to protect Paradis, maybe revealing that there's a high political tension and struggle between 2 highly influential factions (centuries later) but not war within Paradis also without it getting destroyed would still deliver the same message "the cycle of conflict will always exist, peace is temporary" at least that's how i interpreted the 8 extra pages |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Anyone voting for the third option is capping hard. The ending ain’t good as is. I personally have many problems with chapters that are outside of the infamous 3 (137, 138, 139) but still within the Rumbling arc, yet there’s a few things that they could change or flesh out more towards the end that would make the current manga ending a little better in the anime. - Show what happens to hallu-chan, don’t get rid of it off-screen with no explanation. - Do not even adapt or refer to the moment where Eren revealed to Armin that he controlled Dina to avoid Bertoto and kill Carla. It’s probably the worst thing Isayama wrote in 139 chapters. Especially with how Armin and Eren move past this piece of information like it’s not some nonsensical bombshell that ruins many previous moments. - Flesh out Ymir’s Stockholm syndrome, don’t gloss over it with a few lines of dialogue that includes “only Ymir knows”. - I’m fine with adapting the aftermath, as long as Reiner sniffing Historia’s letter is never shown. - How about showing a kiss or a romantic conclusion between Annie and Armin which is shoved in our face throughout the Rumbling yet they never get a single scene where they show affection towards each other outside of kindergarten blushing. Bonus that I personally wish for but know won’t happen: leave every eldian that transformed into titans in titan form or kill them instead of reverting them back a couple of minutes later. This moment will be absolutely horrible if adapted into a movie. |
 |
| We are getting the 2nd option, anyone hoping for anything else will be disappointed. |
 |
Xacobe01 said: Holo_or_Horo said: Christ, this man might be the saltiest thing on earth, even more salty than umi da. Goddamn asshole acting all high and mighty and that only he truly understands the thematic of AoT with his redditor brain "Now please, if you don't mind, get out and let people who did understand the story talk." If a post answers the topic regardless of opinion there shouldn't be any problems with whether or not someone "understands the theme" in the first place. How about you get off the internet while this show is airing? Nobody wants some salty ending defender who can't see clear flaws in the ending and pretends to understand everything. Even past the flaws in the ending, there are a lot things people would clearly not be happy about which they are trying to express in this discussion along if they wanted to see a different ending or not, so you're in the wrong place kiddo. I've yet to see those flaws. Nobody has presented them. I already mentioned, the problems with the ending rely more on pacing and dialogue options (due to pacing), I'm not saying that it's perfect, nor that I have a bigger brain than theirs, I just want to know the reason why they aren't happy with the ending, why it's shit, why editor Kun is a cuck. I'm not a defender, I am just tired of people spamming the same nonsense over and over again without thinking a bit for themselves. Give me one good reason why it doesn't make sense and I'll shut up. If you don't, theb you're should go to the titanfolk lair, you'll be welcomed there I'm sure you've read plenty of flaws people have countlessly pointed out in forums along with why they hated it, you've just decided discard them. You say you're not defending it as you are actively defending it, what are you on about? I could give you a lot of flaws aside from the ending: That final fight against the past generation titans was pretty horribly written with a ton of deus ex machina moments, eren's friends should've died countless times over realistically in the situations they were put in, it was honestly hard to follow considering how isayama had no issues killing off so many characters throughout the entire series, but that entire fight was written like a generic shounen. The reasoning behind why falco can turn into a bird is a horrible ass pull/flaw, used just so they can get out of any situation easily. Using that same logic, reiner had zeke's spinal fluid in him when historia sterilised his wound with the wine, why can't he turn into a bird? Why did everyone turn into a titan at the end just to turn back to normal magically a panel after? That entire worm scene had no reason to exist where it just turned everyone into a titan until it was mikasa who killed eren. Why could eren turn into a colossal titan at the ending just to have a fist fight with armin? That scene didn't need to exist and there wasn't any explanation for why it happened, at the time he should not have had access to the founder titan powers when he wasn't connected to monke or that worm. This entire series always had some sort of reasoning or explanation for all the crazy reveals that came out, but every point and twist here at the end was just made for a shock or suspense factor, with no other reasoning. I would call all these pretty big flaws, I guess you would call them AoT's theme of "the power of friendship" or "the power of eren's character development". |
Cruicruise said: My understanding of Armin's infamous quote is that he did tell that to make Eren feel better about himself before he died. That's what true friends do. Of course. He even calls it an "error" but people like to cherry pick dialogues to hate. |
 |
| Nah that ending was terrible. I would rather something completely different. |
  Even If We Painstakingly Piece Together Something Lost, It Doesn't Mean Things Will Ever go Back To How They Were - Guts  |
| I am tired out of mind discussing the ending for months. So at this point I'll just go with anything. But still I'll choose the 2nd option here. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Feb 6, 2022 |
474 |
by graciana
»»
Yesterday, 8:08 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Apr 3, 2022 |
574 |
by mateben
»»
Oct 4, 7:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Jan 30, 2022 |
557 |
by Goxist
»»
Sep 21, 4:36 AM |
|
Poll: » Shingeki no Kyojin: The Final Season Part 2 Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )anime-prime - Mar 6, 2022 |
313 |
by Hylianticipated
»»
Sep 3, 10:48 PM |
|
» I think eren did the right thing ( 1 2 )SenseixSenpai - Feb 4, 2022 |
53 |
by MergedZamasu
»»
Aug 28, 12:29 PM |