My Criticism On AoT S4's Animation (So Far)

AnimeLeviathan said:


Your really gatekeeping anime lmao? Unless you prefer the anime over the manga, why not read the manga? Literally makes 0 sense. You just assumed he/she was a tiktok, twitter user, etc. Just because they didn't watch much anime. So what? Who cares how much anime someone watches? Everyone goes at they're own pace. Them not watching much anime doesn't make them any less of a fan than you are, or any less smart than you are. "Low standards"? You can't have low standards about an opinion. Also, you have the nerve to say "Im a bigger AOT fan than you!" when thats not how it works. The person who likes every aspect more than someone else must like the anime more than that person.

I think your late to your circus, you clown.

Awesomeness_1307 said:


Again, you ignored the majority of my reply. WIT indeed did not provide a 10/10 adaptation. And yes, bad shots are everywhere in all the seasons made by WIT, you can definitely find them by pausing. And you can definitely find them in MAPPA's adaptation as well. Maybe even less than WIT. You know what you can't find in WIT's adaptation? 3D ODM sakuga, or a washed out night lighting scheme that makes it hard to tell what's happening, clearly done to blend in the CG. You know what else you can't find in WIT's adaptation? Read below.




P.S. Yes, I'm aware of WIT's god-awful Rod Reiss and Colossal Titan CGI (mixed in with some gorgeous 2D close-ups), but they are the minority in terms of screentime, whereas any Titan which has major screentime is always beautiful 2D.

L0sMichal0s said:

"washed out night lighting scheme that makes it hard to tell what's happening" show me examples of this statement because so far i havent encountered scene like that in final season. Maybe if you watch it RAW on twitch in 360p its hard to tell whats happening yeah but thats problem on your side. Look at uniforms they were wearing in previous episodes and look at their uniforms now. its much more detailed and harder to anime. CGI was necessary for some scenes to save time because its hard to animate it by hand with so many details. Did it ruin anything ? NO. Mikasa entrance was great and ODM gear scenes in ep 7 were amazing too. And shouldnt you be happy they used enviroment to blend in CGI nicely to look it even better ? Jesus i just cant understand you people. If you call this horrible or ruined adaptation you havent seed bad adaptation or mediocre anime.

yaegerist-15 said:
I think you quoted the wrong person here bro

Awesomeness_1307 said:


It is not a horrible adaptation or a ruined adaptation, I'm pretty sure no one has used those terms. It is good/sufficient in terms of quality, with some episodes such as 1, 7, 8, 11, reaching really good quality. Just FYI, I am not a manga reader who watches the NHK stream as soon as possible. I wait for the official Crunchyroll release and watch it with official subs in 1080p on my TV. As for washed out scenes, I'm talking about lack of strong direct lighting. Just go to season 2 episode 4 and watch the entire Utgard castle raid, which takes place entirely in a moonlight night, but still everything is always clearly lit. Heck, even the season 4 trailer is great in this regard. Every character is lit with a strong warm light, because of the citylights at night.


In the end, this is entirely subjective. I could show you screenshots where I think the lighting could be better directed, and you would say something like 'aRe yOU BLiND', so, let's just agree to disagree here.

icarusivys said:



You're*. Oh, and I am not gatekeeping anime, but I'd most definitely want the inevitable misfits such as yourself to get filtered out of the mass.


So now I have to prefer the anime over the manga, to watch the anime? Are you brain-dead? Because you make no sense. This was just as hilarious to as your grammar.


Of course, you wouldn't care. Why would you care if you are in the same boat as the people you are defending, lmao. You are a novice too since you started watching anime 2020, obviously due to the pandemic. It really is okay to have watched less anime and go at your own pace but don't come out here, arguing with a person over quality who has undoubtedly not only seen more than you, but can make legitimate comparisons. It makes you look ignorant and makes your arguments less credible.


But it is evident who the bigger fan is, it doesn't need to be said. I wouldn't mention it myself, but the toxic people here misinterpret my points for things they clearly aren't, only to make me look like a hater which I am not. If I have watched something 10 times (with scrutiny) more than a person who has watched it once (roughly), isn't it clear who knows better? Besides, staying on forums all day instead of actually watching animes doesn't help your case.


Because it is true? Does me criticizing an adaptation of it prove otherwise? I don't know how your head works, but you are definitely either just dumb or tired.


I won't even say anything to this, saying this just proved you to be the certified dumbarse I suspected you to be.

icarusivys said:



You can't call me a clown when none of your points are worth even talking about. I don't think I need to waste my words on explaining why someone like you is a misfit when your reasonings make it pretty self-explanatory. I also countered all of your points with proper arguments, but I don't expect your hateful-self to see anything beyond what you believe in.


Of course, it is now suddenly a typing error because you realized how much of a moronic statement it was, you obnoxious dolt. Blame it on a typo which you know for a fact wasn't a typo.


And I never said otherwise? I literally made this thread and kept a disclaimer which clearly stated that this is my views on the matter. I don't understand why people get so offended about criticisms, most of which is true not only to me, but a lot of other people. Most of the people who disagree from my experience are just not well-experienced in this medium, so there's that.


How the fuck are you going to compare something that is completely unrelated, to a criticism on the animation? How much more of a fool could you be? Honestly, this is entertaining, I have never seen such toxic imbeciles anywhere with such ghastly intellect. AoT is a fictional masterpiece, it is my favorite story in fiction and I have never said otherwise. Not to mention, I don't understand why you made up such a logic on your own and are presenting it to be mine when it clearly isn't. Speak for yourself, you idiotic simpleton.


I know it judging from the arguments they present, they are basically presenting their piece of mind and if I find it half-assed, I'd obviously reach the same conclusion any person with a few brain-cells would, right? Just piss off, I don't hold any interest in arguing with someone as foolish, ignorant and aberrant as you. Just waiting for numskulls like you to leave the community ASAP. You aren't getting any more discussion with me than you already have, you are not worth the effort. Oh, and imagine using a derogatory slur (which is an actual mental disease) in an argument, the heat is getting to you, dullard.

neobluue said:


You woke up and choose to speak fax ,everyone in this thread need to chill out and try to understand each other's side without the excessive attacking. No one here is better than the other because they read the manga or watched the anime 10 times or liking wit/mappa, what makes you different from each other is your ability to be respectful in giving your opinion and not lash out at everything.
At the end of the day aot is still goated for the awesome plot whether the animation is toptier or mid so let's just leave it at that.

Mingyun25 said:


Glad someone’s still sane here

neobluue said:


This whole thread is just sad at this point.