Twilight Anime?

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

Theknight117 said:

Kyora said:
Eh, really. I think Vampire Knight still has a better plot than Twilight.

Vampire Knight: Long time ago, a girl was rescued by a vampire from another vampire. Now she's the adopted daughter of the headman of Cross Academy, a school that caters to both humans and vampires. Dramu and romance ensue.

Twilight: A blatant mary-sue moves into a new place. Guys like shy Bella but she doesn't like them. Sad. First say, she sits next to Edward, who seems to hate her, but he warms up to her over time and eventually saves her. Shit happens, she finds out he's a vampire, more shit happens which involves her getting kidnapped and the two being forced to separate, and then ends with her getting bitten and going to prom.

...IDK, hard to say.

Actually the vampire knight story line is totally unrealistic (as a vampire story) and does not make sense at all.

And Twilight sounds like nothing more than a sue-fic.

Really, both aren't that great in terms of plot, but I mean we're talking about anime. It tends to not make sense sometimes.

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 26, 2009 4:26 AM

#153

Offline

Jan 2009

475

Kyora said:

Theknight117 said:

Kyora said:
Eh, really. I think Vampire Knight still has a better plot than Twilight.

Vampire Knight: Long time ago, a girl was rescued by a vampire from another vampire. Now she's the adopted daughter of the headman of Cross Academy, a school that caters to both humans and vampires. Dramu and romance ensue.

Twilight: A blatant mary-sue moves into a new place. Guys like shy Bella but she doesn't like them. Sad. First say, she sits next to Edward, who seems to hate her, but he warms up to her over time and eventually saves her. Shit happens, she finds out he's a vampire, more shit happens which involves her getting kidnapped and the two being forced to separate, and then ends with her getting bitten and going to prom.

...IDK, hard to say.

Actually the vampire knight story line is totally unrealistic (as a vampire story) and does not make sense at all.

And Twilight sounds like nothing more than a sue-fic.

Really, both aren't that great in terms of plot, but I mean we're talking about anime. It tends to not make sense sometimes.

... in that case then a book's storyline which actually won awards should have a better storyline then an ANIME; vampire knight which you just stated "tends to not make sense"

Mar 26, 2009 4:30 AM

#154

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

BlackCat_XIII said:
... in that case then a book's storyline which actually won awards should have a better storyline then an ANIME; vampire knight which you just stated "tends to not make sense"

Not necessarily. Things don't have to have an amazing storyline to sell well.

Honestly, I think that Twilight is pretty crap, btu the author knows what she's doin. The concept of a forbidden romance along with Edward's personality are meant to appeal to most females, and thus it will do well. It doesn't mean that it's necessarily well written or anything. In fact, a few of my friends who write have told me that while they agree that Stephanie Meyer can't string along good sentences for beans, her writing is oddly addicting.

Writing a book that sells doesn't mean that it has to be deep or have a fantastic plot; the author just has to know how to make it appeal to enough people.

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 26, 2009 4:38 AM

#155

Offline

Jan 2009

475

Kyora said:

BlackCat_XIII said:
... in that case then a book's storyline which actually won awards should have a better storyline then an ANIME; vampire knight which you just stated "tends to not make sense"

Not necessarily. Things don't have to have an amazing storyline to sell well.

Honestly, I think that Twilight is pretty crap, btu the author knows what she's doin. The concept of a forbidden romance along with Edward's personality are meant to appeal to most females, and thus it will do well. It doesn't mean that it's necessarily well written or anything. In fact, a few of my friends who write have told me that while they agree that Stephanie Meyer can't string along good sentences for beans, her writing is oddly addicting.

Writing a book that sells doesn't mean that it has to be deep or have a fantastic plot; the author just has to know how to make it appeal to enough people.

yes i know what you mean, some of my friends told me that they reckoned it was crap, but somehow they kept reading.

Obviously its because of the storyline and the plot they want to find out what happens even tho its bad writing.

If things dont have a good storyline then the book is basically screwed, the storyline and plot is what makes the reader want to buy the next book to see what comes up.

Why does it have so many sales if it truly has a horrible storyline? Because they get addicted? Why do they want to keep reading? Because they are intriuged as to know what will happen? What happens next is the thing that appeals to the people. And that is basically the plot.

I buy the next book in any series because of one sole reason.. what happens next?

if its a crap book, i would just cut the series and not even buy the next book. It doesnt want to make me go on.

and thats why Twilight has a better storyline then vampire knight.

YOu seriously think that the mangaka for vamprie knight did all his/her research and everything, until it was better then Stephanie Meyer? Admit it.. vampire knight's quality of story is no where near twilight.

Half the people who write manga dont even know what they are talkign about sometimes.

Mar 26, 2009 4:54 AM

#156

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

Uhh okay I think we have different definitions of "good storyline" here.

To me a good storyline doesn't have to be popular; it could be popular, but it could also be completely underrated and cared for. For me, a good storyline should be original and unique, which Twilight is not. I see Twilight as your typical mary-sue fanfic. Mary-sue female MC gets caught in a ~forbidden romance!~ of course involving sexy vampires, and shit happens, he saved her, completely dominates her, and then oh of course, she has to turn into a perfect vampire too.

There's nothing really original about the plot; it's like a fangirl's wet dream. Therefore to me, it has a shitty storyline.

The thing is just that Meyer knows how to market said shitty storyline, which is what makes her successful. It doesn't mean that the book itself is any good. It may not be the plot that's intriguing people. I know a lot of girls who continued reading not for plot, but for Edward Cullen.

I haven't read very far into Vampire Knight, nor have I heard much wank about it so I don't know too much, but no, I do understand that Vampire Knight is also made to appeal to females (especially with the whole Zero and Kaname arguing over the female MC). I can't say much about the plot since I really don't know much about it, but from what I do know, even if it makes less sense, it's more original than Twilight at least. It's just not marketed as well.

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 26, 2009 5:06 AM

#157

Offline

Jan 2009

475

Kyora said:
Uhh okay I think we have different definitions of "good storyline" here.

To me a good storyline doesn't have to be popular; it could be popular, but it could also be completely underrated and cared for. For me, a good storyline should be original and unique, which Twilight is not. I see Twilight as your typical mary-sue fanfic. Mary-sue female MC gets caught in a ~forbidden romance!~ of course involving sexy vampires, and shit happens, he saved her, completely dominates her, and then oh of course, she has to turn into a perfect vampire too.

There's nothing really original about the plot; it's like a fangirl's wet dream. Therefore to me, it has a shitty storyline.

The thing is just that Meyer knows how to market said shitty storyline, which is what makes her successful. It doesn't mean that the book itself is any good. It may not be the plot that's intriguing people. I know a lot of girls who continued reading not for plot, but for Edward Cullen.

I haven't read very far into Vampire Knight, nor have I heard much wank about it so I don't know too much, but no, I do understand that Vampire Knight is also made to appeal to females (especially with the whole Zero and Kaname arguing over the female MC). I can't say much about the plot since I really don't know much about it, but from what I do know, even if it makes less sense, it's more original than Twilight at least. It's just not marketed as well.

Well in

Kyora said:
Uhh okay I think we have different definitions of "good storyline" here.

To me a good storyline doesn't have to be popular; it could be popular, but it could also be completely underrated and cared for. For me, a good storyline should be original and unique, which Twilight is not. I see Twilight as your typical mary-sue fanfic. Mary-sue female MC gets caught in a ~forbidden romance!~ of course involving sexy vampires, and shit happens, he saved her, completely dominates her, and then oh of course, she has to turn into a perfect vampire too.

There's nothing really original about the plot; it's like a fangirl's wet dream. Therefore to me, it has a shitty storyline.

The thing is just that Meyer knows how to market said shitty storyline, which is what makes her successful. It doesn't mean that the book itself is any good. It may not be the plot that's intriguing people. I know a lot of girls who continued reading not for plot, but for Edward Cullen.

I haven't read very far into Vampire Knight, nor have I heard much wank about it so I don't know too much, but no, I do understand that Vampire Knight is also made to appeal to females (especially with the whole Zero and Kaname arguing over the female MC). I can't say much about the plot since I really don't know much about it, but from what I do know, even if it makes less sense, it's more original than Twilight at least. It's just not marketed as well.

well in any case, vampire knight's storyline is unrealistic and totally does not make sense and that alone has made it worse then twilight.
Thats what i think anyway....

Mar 26, 2009 5:07 AM

#158

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

You've always said that Vampire Knight has a really bad storyline, but could you elaborate on that a bit?

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 26, 2009 5:38 AM

#159

Offline

Jan 2009

475

????

the very actual storyline itself. The plot is bad. The entire concept...of vampries.

but of course... you might view it differently

Mar 26, 2009 5:40 AM

#160

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

Er, what I mean is can you cite examples as to why Vampire Knights' vampires are wrong and whatnot? What parts of the plot make it so bad and how? I mean, I've cited reasons for why I thought Twilight had a crappy plot.

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 26, 2009 6:04 AM

#161

Offline

Jan 2009

475

Kyora said:
Er, what I mean is can you cite examples as to why Vampire Knights' vampires are wrong and whatnot? What parts of the plot make it so bad and how? I mean, I've cited reasons for why I thought Twilight had a crappy plot.

Twilight as your typical mary-sue fanfic. Mary-sue female MC gets caught in a ~forbidden romance!~ of course involving sexy vampires, and shit happens, he saved her, completely dominates her, and then oh of course, she has to turn into a perfect vampire too.

There's nothing really original about the plot; it's like a fangirl's wet dream. Therefore to me, it has a shitty storyline.

Thats not citing anythign at all lol. thats giving like a few exaggerated reasons on like 1% of the story.

Vampire knight story line is horrible because all of all those crappy stuff they have like "anti-vampire guns" and "protection braclets" seriously thats so lame. And at many points the story made no sense, their thoughts weren't logical and like...wth?The very start of the anime was the worse part. vampire saving a random human. It was already a bad plot at the start. A school with day and night students... thats sooo lame.

And a horrible anime like that... written by a inexperienced JAP women, is not as good as twilight's which has way more complex stuff shoved in it.

Mar 26, 2009 10:33 AM

#162

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

BlackCat_XIII said:

Yuruku said:
Well I mean, you have to be stupid to like Twilight to begin with.. So we were already arguing with an idiot.

Oh well, it's always fun~ ;)

I said i didnt like twlight. read properly

But im arguing not for the story but for his "idea" that twilight is a bad book and everyone who reads it is stupid for liking it.

And right up to the start my original idea was still twlight has a better storyline then vampire knight....

Wrong. I said they are stupid for liking an abusive character like Edward.

BlackCat_XIII said:

Kyora said:
Er, what I mean is can you cite examples as to why Vampire Knights' vampires are wrong and whatnot? What parts of the plot make it so bad and how? I mean, I've cited reasons for why I thought Twilight had a crappy plot.

Twilight as your typical mary-sue fanfic. Mary-sue female MC gets caught in a ~forbidden romance!~ of course involving sexy vampires, and shit happens, he saved her, completely dominates her, and then oh of course, she has to turn into a perfect vampire too.

There's nothing really original about the plot; it's like a fangirl's wet dream. Therefore to me, it has a shitty storyline.

Thats not citing anythign at all lol. thats giving like a few exaggerated reasons on like 1% of the story.

Vampire knight story line is horrible because all of all those crappy stuff they have like "anti-vampire guns" and "protection braclets" seriously thats so lame. And at many points the story made no sense, their thoughts weren't logical and like...wth?The very start of the anime was the worse part. vampire saving a random human. It was already a bad plot at the start. A school with day and night students... thats sooo lame.

And a horrible anime like that... written by a inexperienced JAP women, is not as good as twilight's which has way more complex stuff shoved in it.

Yes. Because sparkly vampires are even more realistic. SO PRETTY.

Mar 26, 2009 3:39 PM

#163

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

BlackCat_XIII said:
Vampire knight story line is horrible because all of all those crappy stuff they have like "anti-vampire guns" and "protection braclets" seriously thats so lame.

Aren't they pretty much the same thing as high-tech stakes and garlic or whatever? :\

BlackCat_XIII said:
And at many points the story made no sense, their thoughts weren't logical and like...wth?

Can't comment on this because I don't know enough.

BlackCat_XIII said:
The very start of the anime was the worse part. vampire saving a random human.

Edward saving Bella IN PUBLIC from a BUS/TRUCK/CAR wasn't random at all lol. That aside though, I don't see how that's so bad? Right from the start Vampire Knight establishes that not all vampires are the same, and that was a good way of doing it.

BlackCat_XIII said:
A school with day and night students... thats sooo lame.

Admittedly it is a bit cliche, but it appeals to people as well. The "mysteriousness" of the night students and this awkward barrier between them and the day students only serves to further emphasize their presence and their differences. This shows the big difference and gap in "perfection" between vampires and humans, which is what gives the "zomg vampires!" thrill.

That aside, all you said was that everything was lame. :| Which is just... eh. Also, I didn't have an "exaggerated example." I just summed up the plot at point blank.

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 26, 2009 5:22 PM

#164

Hotstrawberry

Offline

Jul 2008

842

Can't wait, shits gonna be EPIC Hillarious.

Mar 26, 2009 5:43 PM

#165

Aarana

Offline

Aug 2007

1803

I can't wait actually :) I enjoy manga art and story far better than american novels any day ;)

Mar 27, 2009 10:02 AM

#166

naoom

Offline

Feb 2009

46

Hahah. I'm looking forward to it. Love the books and yes i do like the movie. So who knows about a anime...

Mar 27, 2009 10:14 AM

#167

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

naoom said:
Hahah. I'm looking forward to it. Love the books and yes i do like the movie. So who knows about a anime...

Another lost soul :(

Mar 27, 2009 12:33 PM

#168

Bakayaro

Offline

Jul 2008

3704

Drunk_Samurai said:

naoom said:
Hahah. I'm looking forward to it. Love the books and yes i do like the movie. So who knows about a anime...

Another lost soul :(

At least it's not a dude this time.

"I'd suck you~" Berri||Desu Ne?

Mar 27, 2009 12:35 PM

#169

FiiFO

Offline

Oct 2007

2508

OMG please dont turn it into an anime T_T

Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.

Mar 27, 2009 12:35 PM

#170

BurningBang

Offline

Nov 2008

40

If this is true, it needs to go to Mad House Studios. If they can make writing names down in a notebook, and eating a potato chip look badass, I think they can make Twilight look even vaugely interesting.

Mar 27, 2009 12:38 PM

#171

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

Bakayaro said:

Drunk_Samurai said:

naoom said:
Hahah. I'm looking forward to it. Love the books and yes i do like the movie. So who knows about a anime...

Another lost soul :(

At least it's not a dude this time.

So true.

Mar 27, 2009 5:01 PM

#172

panda_general

Offline

Jan 2008

754

Drunk_Samurai said:

Bakayaro said:

Drunk_Samurai said:

naoom said:
Hahah. I'm looking forward to it. Love the books and yes i do like the movie. So who knows about a anime...

Another lost soul :(

At least it's not a dude this time.

So true.

Although, you guys did made my rather craptastic day a little bit better. *Claps* I thank you for that.

Twilight anime will be so like fail. Like omg, there's no yaoi in it. I demand for JasperxEdward, or better yet, JacobxEdward!!! [/sarcasm]
^ Although that would make for a somewhat...more interesting plot.

Edit: Just to report back from page whatever, alcohal will not help you forget things, merely make you high.

Banner made by suikka

Mar 27, 2009 5:07 PM

#173

SequentialNel

Offline

Jul 2008

113

I seriously can't see an american anime being good. The only good anime-style cartoon I've ever seen is Avatar. And, she would have to actually watch anime to know how to make one.

Mar 27, 2009 5:14 PM

#174

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

neeonX said:
I seriously can't see an american anime being good. The only good anime-style cartoon I've ever seen is Avatar. And, she would have to actually watch anime to know how to make one.

Well since anime only comes from Japan that doesn't really matter.

Mar 27, 2009 5:20 PM

#175

cyan_04

Offline

Dec 2008

1002

twilight anime? Like they can draw better than the japanese lol. I dont think itll work.... i mean itll actually show good fighting and speed but... er... sounds gay tho... i mean the best american cartoon show ive seen is probably family guy lol.

::: (\(\
*: (=' :') :*
•.. (,('')('')¤°﹒‧°‧° ☆.(¯`•.•´¯)
.°☆ ‧°‧°☆∴° ☆ ¤º… `•.¸.•´ ☆™

Mar 28, 2009 12:03 PM

#176

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

Why don't people understand that if it's not from Japan then it's not anime?

Mar 28, 2009 3:17 PM

#177

Bakayaro

Offline

Jul 2008

3704

Drunk_Samurai said:
Why don't people understand that if it's not from Japan then it's not anime?

You know, I can't even think of something witty to say to this. All I can do is agree :(

"I'd suck you~" Berri||Desu Ne?

Mar 28, 2009 4:13 PM

#178

Offline

Dec 2008

1346

Drunk_Samurai said:
Why don't people understand that if it's not from Japan then it's not anime?

This.

Now I'm just not even going to try arguing. ): I assumed that the series was going to be... anime, not a cartoon.

There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection

Mar 28, 2009 4:31 PM

#179

eLiT3_

Offline

Mar 2007

669

F**K OFF! Words really can't express how... ridiculous that it... we honestly don't need thousands of fking fangirls joining this site about how much they love what they think is "anime"... when it reality (if it does pull through), a prostituted version of Japanese-styled cartoons which have been tweaked for mindless, screaming fanatics of a book...

*sigh*... my rant is over, people may agree or disagree with me... I don't care.... bottom line... fking ridiculous... lol

Join the Kyonko Fanclub Today! | Join the MAL Tenjou Tenge Fanclub Today!

Mar 28, 2009 6:34 PM

#180

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

eLiT3_ said:
F**K OFF! Words really can't express how... ridiculous that it... we honestly don't need thousands of fking fangirls joining this site about how much they love what they think is "anime"... when it reality (if it does pull through), a prostituted version of Japanese-styled cartoons which have been tweaked for mindless, screaming fanatics of a book...

*sigh*... my rant is over, people may agree or disagree with me... I don't care.... bottom line... fking ridiculous... lol

Let them join. They'll wind up leaving because everybody else has a brain.

Mar 28, 2009 9:50 PM

#181

Gin-iro

Offline

Jul 2008

858

I'm not sure most would join anyway. They'd most likely flock to livejournal groups and fan sites rather than a whole database site of anime and manga.

Omae wa mou shindeiru.

Mar 28, 2009 10:10 PM

#182

Yeona

Offline

Aug 2008

101

ewww!~ no!!
dont contaminate my anime/manga with all these stuffs please?
a book and movie is alr as good as it it. (but not to me. i hate it.)

its irritating to see non-anime lovers watching anime just because of twilight. ONLY.
its like since you like twilight, go watch VK alr.

-sorry, no offence but i really hate twilight.-

Mar 28, 2009 10:13 PM

#183

Vahriel

Offline

Nov 2008

148

to bring back the vampire argument, could you imagine twilight going up against some of the vampire series that anime already has... i mean the demented and defragmented plot of Twilight is enough to satisfy the imagination of a teenage fangirl, but for 99% of us, we'll sit there watching it thinking "wow, this is nowhere near as good as (insert vampire anime here)"

I mean anime has vampire series/OVA/Movies for all different genres!
Blood+ for the Drama/Plotline/(Best Vampire Anime of all time kthx)
Hellsing for the Violence/Action
Karin for the comedy

How is Twilight supposed to compete with that...

Twilight failed as a book
Twilight failed more as a movie (lol@shiny vampires)
Twilight won't even make it as an anime.

Mar 29, 2009 12:35 AM

#184

Kappaka

Offline

Feb 2008

5396

Rufusruferson said:

Twilight failed as a book
Twilight failed more as a movie (lol@shiny vampires)

That's why the author and the directors are rolling around in shit loads of money isn't it?

Mar 29, 2009 3:25 AM

#185

Vahriel

Offline

Nov 2008

148

LolitaDecay said:

Rufusruferson said:

Twilight failed as a book
Twilight failed more as a movie (lol@shiny vampires)

That's why the author and the directors are rolling around in shit loads of money isn't it?

the whole reason for that is because fangirls with rich parents outweigh the people with brains by at least 2:1 :/

I mean, when i say failed, i mean that they sucked, not that they didn't do well... i mean, they did well, i give them creds for that, but, the storyline and the entire plot was ridiclously cliche and retarded to say the least.

Mar 29, 2009 5:52 AM

#186

Kappaka

Offline

Feb 2008

5396

I just find it so hilarious that the internet just has to rip the crap out of anything that's vaguely popular.

Yeah Twilight wasn't that good, it wasn't half as bad as what everyone here's making it out to be. I'd say 70% of you have never so much as read a word of it therefore have no right to comment on whether it was good or not.

Bloody hell. I'm not a rabid fangirl either before you take that stance on me.

Mar 29, 2009 7:01 AM

#187

EuphoricField

Offline

Feb 2009

641

Rufusruferson said:

LolitaDecay said:

Rufusruferson said:

Twilight failed as a book
Twilight failed more as a movie (lol@shiny vampires)

That's why the author and the directors are rolling around in shit loads of money isn't it?

the whole reason for that is because fangirls with rich parents outweigh the people with brains by at least 2:1 :/

I mean, when i say failed, i mean that they sucked, not that they didn't do well... i mean, they did well, i give them creds for that, but, the storyline and the entire plot was ridiclously cliche and retarded to say the least.

well obviously it didn't suck as bad as you people think since its this popular, and just because someone likes something you don't like doesn't mean we don't have brains.

Mar 29, 2009 9:10 AM

#188

zzzfdfdsfsdfafs

Offline

Nov 2007

2010

Lol.
I doubt there's gonna be one, but if there is I'm watching just enough so my rating counts and giving it a 1.

Mar 29, 2009 10:20 AM

#189

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

EuphoricField said:

Rufusruferson said:

LolitaDecay said:

Rufusruferson said:

Twilight failed as a book
Twilight failed more as a movie (lol@shiny vampires)

That's why the author and the directors are rolling around in shit loads of money isn't it?

the whole reason for that is because fangirls with rich parents outweigh the people with brains by at least 2:1 :/

I mean, when i say failed, i mean that they sucked, not that they didn't do well... i mean, they did well, i give them creds for that, but, the storyline and the entire plot was ridiclously cliche and retarded to say the least.

well obviously it didn't suck as bad as you people think since its this popular, and just because someone likes something you don't like doesn't mean we don't have brains.

Liking abuse shows people don't have brains. (Excluding masochists)

Mar 29, 2009 10:51 AM

#190

Cadarn

Offline

Feb 2009

163

I'm surprised by the amount of negativity the very idea of a Twilight anime generates. Granted I've never, and will never, read the books, watch the movies, or watch the theoretical anime.

But considering the high scores and praise that shit like Elfen Lied, ef~, the KnK movies, any Key anime, et cetera, receive among the anime community, I'm surprised that Twilight would be singled out as being terrible.

My guess is that a lot of you haven't read it, and would probably enjoy it if you did.

Mar 29, 2009 11:07 AM

#191

Offline

Aug 2007

7550

Cadarn said:
I'm surprised by the amount of negativity the very idea of a Twilight anime generates. Granted I've never, and will never, read the books, watch the movies, or watch the theoretical anime.

But considering the high scores and praise that shit like Elfen Lied, ef~, the KnK movies, any Key anime, et cetera, receive among the anime community, I'm surprised that Twilight would be singled out as being terrible.

My guess is that a lot of you haven't read it, and would probably enjoy it if you did.

1) Abuse.

2) Sparkly vampires.

3) Enough said.

Mar 29, 2009 1:01 PM

#192

PepsiBusinessman

Offline

May 2008

249

I demand Anno be the director!

Just kidding. *shivers*

PepsiBusinessmanMar 29, 2009 2:35 PM

I enjoy watching people's favorites. Recommend your favorite show to me, even if I have it dropped/on hold.

Mar 29, 2009 2:32 PM

#193

rweqoiu

Offline

Feb 2009

1637

oh i hope not
might just ruin anime >.<

leave twilight as it is

Cadarn said:
I'm surprised by the amount of negativity the very idea of a Twilight anime generates. Granted I've never, and will never, read the books, watch the movies, or watch the theoretical anime.

But considering the high scores and praise that shit like Elfen Lied, ef~, the KnK movies, any Key anime, et cetera, receive among the anime community, I'm surprised that Twilight would be singled out as being terrible.

My guess is that a lot of you haven't read it, and would probably enjoy it if you did.

I have read the books, yes. At first, I thought it was ok. But after a while, I came to realize how it's not well written and how it's way too overrated. And the "love" story in it is just lust. nothing more.
If you put it all together, Twilight will not make a good anime.
And take it from me, someone who's read the book.

rweqoiuMar 29, 2009 2:36 PM

Mar 30, 2009 7:33 AM

#194

Theknight330

Offline

Oct 2008

45

LOl@ drunk dwarf

U keep saying the word abuse as if abuse Is twilight which is totally wrong. U r simply looking at the story in a wrong way or just trying to make non- existant facts to criticize something u have a bias view upon, and ur doing it poorly, by summing up 4 books with 1 word abuse. It's as stupid as saying ur Jesus .

Just becuz some1 has done a few acts doesn't mean they are abusive. R u gonna call every1 in the world a liar then? Edward is not abusive by nature

And of course it's gonna fail as an anime, it's just some people like u that goes too far and keep saying excessive trash. The general consensus like the story, but they never said the anime was going to be good?

Drunk dwarf u r truly idiotic for making exaggerated statements that have a narrow view.

Theknight330Mar 30, 2009 7:39 AM

Mar 30, 2009 7:57 AM

#195

Offline

Jan 2009

475

Just give up on him Lol,
let him continue to think that whatever he thinks is right, is right and that everyone who likes twlight is dumb LOL. It is not that I like twilight, I just don't like how you condemn/ discriminate everyone...that's the worse kind of people out there

Theknight117 said:
LOl@ drunk dwarf

U keep saying the word abuse as if abuse Is twilight which is totally wrong. U r simply looking at the story in a wrong way or just trying to make non- existant facts to criticize something u have a bias view upon, and ur doing it poorly, by summing up 4 books with 1 word abuse. It's as stupid as saying ur Jesus .

Just becuz some1 has done a few acts doesn't mean they are abusive. R u gonna call every1 in the world a liar then? Edward is not abusive by nature

And of course it's gonna fail as an anime, it's just some people like u that goes too far and keep saying excessive trash. The general consensus like the story, but they never said the anime was going to be good?

Drunk dwarf u r truly idiotic for making exaggerated statements that have a narrow view.

Mar 30, 2009 8:01 AM

#196

Offline

Jan 2009

475

LolitaDecay said:
I just find it so hilarious that the internet just has to rip the crap out of anything that's vaguely popular.

Yeah Twilight wasn't that good, it wasn't half as bad as what everyone here's making it out to be. I'd say 70% of you have never so much as read a word of it therefore have no right to comment on whether it was good or not.

Bloody hell. I'm not a rabid fangirl either before you take that stance on me.

Well said. People comment and condemn things they don't even know about.

Mar 30, 2009 8:03 AM

#197