Why The Hate

ZetaZaku said:
Because people thought this was the third season. (because autism)
Because people think that this ruined the chance of KyoAni ever making a third season. (KyoAni doesn't care about Haruhi, Free is more likely of getting a third season than Haruhi)
Because people think it's taking place in the main Haruhi universe. (despite the title, synopsis and the first episode saying otherwise)
Because people prefer anime girls without any character over moeblobs obsessed with turkey. (sounds like a penis metaphor)
Because people think that KyoAni's Haruhi had actual plot. (top kek)
Because somehow a different design makes the whole show bad. (Oh boy, Kyon doesnt look like that bland guy with a long face anymore, he's now a bland guy with a round face, gasp, the horror)
Because it lacks Haruhi. (which is somehow a bad thing, apparently)

Bottom line is: Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S1 is average. Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi S2 is garbage. Disappearance of Nagato Yuki is already an improvement over Season 2.

HikaruIzumi said:

Agreed.

I think people are mostly just mad that it's not "Haruhi". It's not 3rd season, it's not the same thing, it doesn't have the same art, characters are slightly different etc. What these people were looking for was s3 or something that could be considered s3 but they got a brand new anime and that disappointed them so much that they decided to hate on it as "revenge" (most of them not consciously).

Ulquiorra1923 said:
Haruhi is too damn annoying most of the times in the original series, but I like her a whole lot more now.

nstyn4te said:

As for the argument that the anime is a reflection of the manga, then so much the worse for the manga; it's shit too.

IZUMI64 said:
because many think this SUCK!
srsly, ppl here should've started to respect others opinion

boukendesho said:


Uninformed opinions aren't equal to informed opinions.

IZUMI64 said:


so, you meant all the hate came from ppl who think this different (from original) and then just assuming this anime suck without watch it first?

at first I like this anime idea making spin-off of the "original world", but after watched and finished it. I fucking rather rewatch Haruhi S2 with the whole endless 8.
If I have no respect like you guys, I will say "person who made this story should be executed in front of his family!"

boukendesho said:


... I.e. many of the dislikes come from being uninformed about the source material.

Lastly - nothing you said made uninformed opinions equal to informed opinions.

IZUMI64 said:


another typical "you must read manga first" bullshit crap shitty comment
good adaption doesn't really need the watcher to read the source material first. (like SAO, SNK and GoT for example)
I'm not having problem with the animation, lack of haruhi etc. but the whole spin-off story is just bullshit crap. (same for source material, they suck if the story basically same with this crap)

boukendesho said:

... I can't tell if you are being too defensive or just have reading comprehension challenges, but I will try one last time.

People don't care if you don't like the story. Your enjoyment is your own.

But if you don't like it because it's not Haruhi S3, people are saying you wouldn't have such an expectation if you just spend a couple minutes checking out the source material. And if you can't be bothered, do yourself a favor to listen and learn to save yourself some time and angst.

Nobody said you would have liked the anime if you just read the manga. They are saying you wouldn't have wasted time watching the anime if you didn't like the first couple chapters.

I don't give a shit why you don't like this anime. But stop misreading and misrepresent what's been said.

boukendesho said:

...But if you don't like it because it's not Haruhi S3...

iLatrell_ said:
I guess none of yall dumb fucks have read the manga,

LoneWizard said:
Well said mate...Its too hard to understand for some people apparently...

IZUMI64 said:

saying shit about my reply but still same shit response and shoving opinion in others thought

IZUMI64 said:

like I said above, I like the spin-off idea or completely different story form original world, but the execution just pretty crap and disappointed.
I'm pretty sure if this anime well executed many haruhi fans that hoping for S3 will settle with this anime.
what make them angry, god damn PUYO ruining the characters (keep in mind not because it's different or not haruhi S3) especially Nagato.
we've already seen Nagato with expression and she's loveable in Haruhi movie, he should've did that and expanding the story around that rather than creating disgusting creature called "new" Nagato.

IZUMI64 said:

and you people, just because you love it then you blatantly judging ppl who don't like this anime negatively and urging them to respect your "why it's not shit/it's actually good" opinion.
prime example is OP of this thread, asking "why the hate" then reply with this funny crap answer :

Kintrex said:
Because even if you've never seen The Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi and know nothing about the characters, this show is an utterly bland and unremarkable romantic comedy.