Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jan 4, 8:16 AM
#1
Offline
Jul 2024
277
Sakacooked days ,its over guys this adaptation will flop. Go watch Solo leveling or Orb on the movements of the earth instead this season

TMS why didn't you put some of the animators from lupin the 3rd,megalo box or detective conan on this show. Why give us mid😭😭😭😭😭
The staff seems pretty good is it only because of the director??
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
Jan 4, 8:23 AM
#2
Offline
Nov 2024
85
I say just wait till the first episode is out then we will just wait and see.
Jan 4, 8:45 AM
#3
Offline
Mar 2021
460
The problem is the director lmao if Moriyama took the helm instead it would have looked as good as SL or atleast on par with it the production committee fumbled real bad on a very good chance to make a lot of profit the Jp fans were already mad now it’ll probably be another Chainsaw man situation
UruichiJan 4, 8:51 AM
Jan 4, 8:55 AM
#4
Offline
Nov 2023
1108
Not relevant, I’ll watch an actual episode rather than trying to be first to shit on something I’ve never seen.
Jan 4, 8:59 AM
#5
Offline
Jul 2022
91
FutoiOtaku said:
Not relevant, I’ll watch an actual episode rather than trying to be first to shit on something I’ve never seen.

Same, I agree with mai senpai
Jan 4, 9:17 AM
#6
Offline
Aug 2021
364
ImTheHourlyDevil said:
FutoiOtaku said:
Not relevant, I’ll watch an actual episode rather than trying to be first to shit on something I’ve never seen.

Same, I agree with mai senpai

I third agree on this one
Jan 4, 9:19 AM
#7
Offline
Jul 2022
4
FutoiOtaku said:
Not relevant, I’ll watch an actual episode rather than trying to be first to shit on something I’ve never seen.

exactly, don't need to judge so quickly
Jan 4, 9:21 AM
#8

Offline
Apr 2015
2552
We'll know soon enough whether it's up to the mark or not.
Jan 4, 9:39 AM
#9
Offline
Jun 2024
2
They got the most hype ass music for all them to just aura farm lmao
Jan 4, 9:39 AM
Offline
Aug 2021
1
Mackyreels said:
Sakacooked days ,its over guys this adaptation will flop. Go watch Solo leveling or Orb on the movements of the earth instead this season

TMS why didn't you put some of the animators from lupin the 3rd,megalo box or detective conan on this show. Why give us mid😭😭😭😭😭
The staff seems pretty good is it only because of the director??

Its ok a casual like yourself feels that way
Jan 4, 9:48 AM
Offline
Oct 2023
1
Mackyreels said:
Sakacooked days ,its over guys this adaptation will flop. Go watch Solo leveling or Orb on the movements of the earth instead this season

TMS why didn't you put some of the animators from lupin the 3rd,megalo box or detective conan on this show. Why give us mid😭😭😭😭😭
The staff seems pretty good is it only because of the director??

really? i don't think it's mid animation. Maybe it's just me. well anyway we can decide that after watching the first episode. I guess
Jan 4, 10:35 AM
Offline
Sep 2019
2
sound like a spoiled brat
Jan 4, 11:00 AM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
People trying to defend the animation of this op are copping hard… The characters are still and when they move it looks so stiff, there’s literally a blue lock moment where the characters stay still and camera moves.

I still have hope that maybe just maybe it will get better than this but leakers recently really shut that down along with the director. Sakamoto Days really deserved so much better than this!!!

On a good note: Gintama like opening and nice song.
Jan 4, 11:03 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
33
Cry more.If the story is good that's all that matters
Jan 4, 11:15 AM
Offline
Jul 2024
147
imagine trashing an anime that's not even out yet, and fr, can you just enjoy something for once instead of telling it's trash for no reason ?
Jan 4, 11:36 AM
Offline
Feb 2021
1511
Knew it was cooked when I saw the studio and director combo, even the OP looking bad is crazy tho lol
Jan 4, 11:50 AM
Offline
Jul 2024
36
I don't know what you meant by mid animation it was preety good
wait till the day first ep airs
we will see that day
Jan 4, 12:19 PM
Offline
Oct 2021
13
I don't get the hate on Sakamoto days, can someone explain?
Jan 4, 12:33 PM
Offline
May 2016
1
I dont get it to. Why not waiting till the first episode?
Jan 4, 1:06 PM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
DragonOussama said:
I dont get it to. Why not waiting till the first episode?

Director and leakers plus the OP and trailers animation are giving away the biggest “oh no” vibe.

It could be better though, who knows?
Jan 4, 1:09 PM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
SCYTHER07 said:
Cry more.If the story is good that's all that matters

Yeah… unfortunately this series heavily depends on its fights scenes. Plus it’s literally the debut, you know which should attract people into watching it. Story being good isn’t a thing till a specific arc.

So if the animation sucks -> death of this anime. Hence why you should criticise it not be okay with it looking like this…
Jan 4, 1:42 PM
Offline
Sep 2024
2
NormieZzz said:
I don't get the hate on Sakamoto days, can someone explain?

The reason is the choose of the studio, TMS, for the adaptation, Sakamoto days is an action/comedy manga but its action scenes are wonderful, the composition of his autor, Suzuki Yuto, is dinamic, creative and fluent; many manga readers are worried that the studio can't do well the action scenes, trailers are fine, but we hope more for Sakadays.
I hope for the best.
Jan 4, 1:48 PM

Offline
Mar 2013
3497
I wish people would give this adaptation a chance instead of doomsaying to this extent. There's a difference between being worried and writing off this adaptation before it even aired.
Auroraloose's Aurorasimp
Jan 4, 2:46 PM
Offline
Jun 2021
33
Reply to Confused_100
SCYTHER07 said:
Cry more.If the story is good that's all that matters

Yeah… unfortunately this series heavily depends on its fights scenes. Plus it’s literally the debut, you know which should attract people into watching it. Story being good isn’t a thing till a specific arc.

So if the animation sucks -> death of this anime. Hence why you should criticise it not be okay with it looking like this…
@Confused_100 Still not gonna criticise it cause thats childish behavior.Id rather be patient and keep watching the 'bad animation' rather than watch something super popular with god tier animation like demon slayer. If the story gets boring id naturally drop it
Jan 4, 3:00 PM
Offline
Jul 2019
7
Reply to Confused_100
People trying to defend the animation of this op are copping hard… The characters are still and when they move it looks so stiff, there’s literally a blue lock moment where the characters stay still and camera moves.

I still have hope that maybe just maybe it will get better than this but leakers recently really shut that down along with the director. Sakamoto Days really deserved so much better than this!!!

On a good note: Gintama like opening and nice song.
@Confused_100 I'm so tired of this shit. This is nothing new and certainly isn't just a 'Blue Lock' moment. This type of shots has ALWAYS existed. You guys have this debilitating fear of still frames, which is ridiculous. Still frames have always existed, they will continue to exist and SHOULD exist. This OBSESSION with animation has been increasing since Demon Slayer and it's unbearable.
Jan 4, 3:34 PM
Offline
Aug 2021
567
Reply to SCYTHER07
Cry more.If the story is good that's all that matters
@SCYTHER07 Dumb opinion. If story is the only thing which matters, why make an anime adaptation at the first place, just read the manga. or maybe just voice over the manga and present them as episodes like blue lock. Production matters more. A manga like sakamoto days deserves a good anime production and it's fair to criticize what we are being presented
Jan 4, 3:36 PM
Offline
Aug 2021
567
Reply to SuzuXIII
@Confused_100 I'm so tired of this shit. This is nothing new and certainly isn't just a 'Blue Lock' moment. This type of shots has ALWAYS existed. You guys have this debilitating fear of still frames, which is ridiculous. Still frames have always existed, they will continue to exist and SHOULD exist. This OBSESSION with animation has been increasing since Demon Slayer and it's unbearable.
@SuzuXIII Yee how dare people look out for ANIMAtion in ANIMES?
Jan 4, 3:48 PM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
SCYTHER07 said:
@Confused_100 Still not gonna criticise it cause thats childish behavior.Id rather be patient and keep watching the 'bad animation' rather than watch something super popular with god tier animation like demon slayer. If the story gets boring id naturally drop it

And here’s the thing, you think demon slayer’s story is bad, yet it sold better than jjk and csm with lower number of volumes…

I know this is gonna sound weird to you, but the theme of family is huge in eastern culture compared to western, hence the popularity. You thinking the story is weak is your opinion.

Now for the animation criticism is equal to childish remark? Really? LOL

Best answer using your pfp: imagine sasuke vs itachi fight with mid animation, I would love to see you defend it.
Confused_100Jan 4, 4:02 PM
Jan 4, 3:51 PM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
SuzuXIII said:
@Confused_100 I'm so tired of this shit. This is nothing new and certainly isn't just a 'Blue Lock' moment. This type of shots has ALWAYS existed. You guys have this debilitating fear of still frames, which is ridiculous. Still frames have always existed, they will continue to exist and SHOULD exist. This OBSESSION with animation has been increasing since Demon Slayer and it's unbearable.

Still frames in OPs existed? What type of anime did you watch that did that without making it look artistic?

Bruh I literally said I hope it is better than this because I am a fan of the manga and I know this deserves one punch man season 1 kind of treatment but all I am seeing is worse treatment. Something like oshi no ko that isn’t even shounen has a better art and animation than this… So stop acting this looks good and actually criticise to get a better product.

Dandadan got better treatment, wind breaker got better treatment, frieren got better treatment. Almost all of the new gen got better treatment, but when we reach one of the GOATs of the new gen, we get this… Like CMON!!! If you want mid animation for great mangas, then you weren’t a fan because you didn’t care for it. Logic applies.

(Btw frieren is one of the GOATs of new gen and I am happy it got the treatment it deserved)
Confused_100Jan 4, 3:59 PM
Jan 4, 4:26 PM
Offline
Nov 2023
9
It will be like OPM S2 where many people believed that the TV animation would be better than the trailer and ended up being a disappointment✅
Jan 4, 4:57 PM
Offline
Jul 2019
7
Reply to LIVI___
@SuzuXIII Yee how dare people look out for ANIMAtion in ANIMES?
@LIVI___ If it was just people looking out I wouldn't care, it's not though. It's an obsession with animation that goes beyond just anime. You'll see this in Western shows too. It's the people that shit bricks at still frames, or the people that call anything that doesn't have noodle limbs and 56 impact frames bad animation. We're past people just looking out for it at this point.
Jan 4, 5:07 PM
Offline
Jul 2019
7
Reply to Confused_100
SuzuXIII said:
@Confused_100 I'm so tired of this shit. This is nothing new and certainly isn't just a 'Blue Lock' moment. This type of shots has ALWAYS existed. You guys have this debilitating fear of still frames, which is ridiculous. Still frames have always existed, they will continue to exist and SHOULD exist. This OBSESSION with animation has been increasing since Demon Slayer and it's unbearable.

Still frames in OPs existed? What type of anime did you watch that did that without making it look artistic?

Bruh I literally said I hope it is better than this because I am a fan of the manga and I know this deserves one punch man season 1 kind of treatment but all I am seeing is worse treatment. Something like oshi no ko that isn’t even shounen has a better art and animation than this… So stop acting this looks good and actually criticise to get a better product.

Dandadan got better treatment, wind breaker got better treatment, frieren got better treatment. Almost all of the new gen got better treatment, but when we reach one of the GOATs of the new gen, we get this… Like CMON!!! If you want mid animation for great mangas, then you weren’t a fan because you didn’t care for it. Logic applies.

(Btw frieren is one of the GOATs of new gen and I am happy it got the treatment it deserved)
@Confused_100 YES still frames (or camera panning shots without character movement like you said) in OPs exist. Some examples would be Naruto, Chainsawman, DanDaDan, Demon Slayer, JJK etc. all have them because there is nothing bad about them.
Jan 4, 5:29 PM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
SuzuXIII said:
@Confused_100 YES still frames (or camera panning shots without character movement like you said) in OPs exist. Some examples would be Naruto, Chainsawman, DanDaDan, Demon Slayer, JJK etc. all have them because there is nothing bad about them.

You are ignoring what I said on purpose LMAO. None of what you said had still frames except for artistic reasons (aka a wallpaper moment), here there is none.

But go on defend like a non fan would do and ignore the main criticisms I gave in last response. Waste of time to respond to at this point.
Jan 4, 8:44 PM
Offline
Aug 2022
340
ill give it the ol 1 ep ordeal im not gonna jump the gun this quick
Jan 4, 8:57 PM

Online
Jul 2024
448
I’m gonna wait for the anime to come out, but my hopes have been abolished, I’m sure the show will be fun, but it’s gonna be rly disappointing for the ppl who wanted an adaptation like that of DanDaDan, Kaiju No 8 (god I hate that anime), Frieren. SakaDays deserves wayy better than TMS. TMS doesn’t even have anything impressive in their works, THEY LITERALLY ANIMATED BAKI AND IT LOOKS LIKE SHIT.
Jan 4, 8:58 PM

Online
Jul 2024
448
FutoiOtaku said:
Not relevant, I’ll watch an actual episode rather than trying to be first to shit on something I’ve never seen.

You haven’t seen the trailers?
Jan 4, 8:59 PM

Online
Jul 2024
448
SCYTHER07 said:
Cry more.If the story is good that's all that matters

My guy, SakaDays is more abt the action than the story. Imagine now, how an action show would work with mediocre animation.
Jan 4, 9:10 PM
Offline
Nov 2023
1108
someguy said:
FutoiOtaku said:
Not relevant, I’ll watch an actual episode rather than trying to be first to shit on something I’ve never seen.

You haven’t seen the trailers?

Yes. Nothing terrible about them. You’re really desperate to pile on the negativity for no reason. At least the makers don’t waste their time looking at MAL forums and reading bs from self appointed experts. It’s anime, above average at that from those clips. If you need photorealistic animation try the Chinese stuff.
Jan 4, 9:11 PM

Offline
Apr 2022
6553
yeah it looks mid sadly but instead of recommending more mid like those, people should read the source material instead.
Jan 4, 9:54 PM
Offline
Jul 2020
112
Reply to LIVI___
@SCYTHER07 Dumb opinion. If story is the only thing which matters, why make an anime adaptation at the first place, just read the manga. or maybe just voice over the manga and present them as episodes like blue lock. Production matters more. A manga like sakamoto days deserves a good anime production and it's fair to criticize what we are being presented
@LIVI___ The greatest of animation doesn't save the crappiest and the most bottom of the barrel stories. Production does NOT matter more than story. That's one of the dumbest takes I've seen in this site, and I've seen a few. That's like saying prettying and swagging up a pile of shit is more important than the fact that it's a pile of shit. Of course it's fair to criticize visual aspects, but that opening didn't look bad at all. It wasn't crazy or anything, but it's crazy that this would be worth the criticism. This sounds more like entitlement and immaturity.

Cartoon adaptations allow for fun and enjoyable direction. Hell, I even liked the Way of The Househusband anime because it hit the comedic bits. You can have subpar animation and still create an enjoyable sequence. Likewise, you can have very talented people drawing, but because the scene is so poorly directed and edited, it ends up being garbage. If the direction and story aren't good, it's probably not going to be good. Doesn't matter if Hayao Miyazaki blessed the show with his artistic talent.
Jan 4, 10:51 PM

Online
Jul 2024
448
FutoiOtaku said:
someguy said:

You haven’t seen the trailers?

Yes. Nothing terrible about them. You’re really desperate to pile on the negativity for no reason. At least the makers don’t waste their time looking at MAL forums and reading bs from self appointed experts. It’s anime, above average at that from those clips. If you need photorealistic animation try the Chinese stuff.

I mean, for an action heavy series the animation is quite limited. You may think that not every anime needs excellent animation, and ye that is true, but you also need to consider the fact that sakamoto days is one of the best selling manga and is also highly praised for its action. I don’t want the show to suck, and wish that I can embarrassingly be proved wrong by TMS, though that’s highly unlikely. I also don’t think the animation is terrible, it’s just average, and unfortunately that’s not enough, you would know if you’ve ever read the manga. I’m gonna enjoy the show anyway, even if it does have bad animation, but I feel like because of that a lot of other ppl will not be able to enjoy Sakamoto Days the same way the fans did.
someguyJan 4, 10:55 PM
Jan 5, 12:09 AM
Offline
Aug 2021
567
Reply to daft_mariner
@LIVI___ The greatest of animation doesn't save the crappiest and the most bottom of the barrel stories. Production does NOT matter more than story. That's one of the dumbest takes I've seen in this site, and I've seen a few. That's like saying prettying and swagging up a pile of shit is more important than the fact that it's a pile of shit. Of course it's fair to criticize visual aspects, but that opening didn't look bad at all. It wasn't crazy or anything, but it's crazy that this would be worth the criticism. This sounds more like entitlement and immaturity.

Cartoon adaptations allow for fun and enjoyable direction. Hell, I even liked the Way of The Househusband anime because it hit the comedic bits. You can have subpar animation and still create an enjoyable sequence. Likewise, you can have very talented people drawing, but because the scene is so poorly directed and edited, it ends up being garbage. If the direction and story aren't good, it's probably not going to be good. Doesn't matter if Hayao Miyazaki blessed the show with his artistic talent.
@daft_mariner A good production always elevates the story while the bad one cripples it. Demon slayer is the best example for it, People call demon slayer overrated and mid but the popularity it achieved is a dream every other producers dream of. So "greatest of animation" does save the crappiest and most bottom of the barrel stories, you can look up sukuna vs mahoraga from JJK, the manga itself doesn't really contain much, it's just 2 chapters of fight and mahoraga was just introduced out of nowhere yet the anime adaptation just elevates it to the extent that they are both different media now and the anime version is just way too superior than the manga too much that sukuna vs maho is considered one of the greatest fights in anime.

Story doesn't mean shit when the production is bad(altough in a very few exceptional cases story is too good for an average production to affect it), a bad production will always handicap the story in some way you have already seen badly produced shows being turned into shit despite it having crazy good writing and story, The most recent example is Blue Lock and uzumaki. You just never notice how important the production is.
Blue Lock and Haiykuu are both animes belonging from the same sports genre, blue have been the best selling manga of all time surpassing even one piece and jjk. But when it comes to the anime, y'know the rest of the case.

Also "direction" comes under the production too,
Even in the most of the genres, the production has carried it's popularity. Let's just ignore action, let's take slice of life. The bests of the slice of life animes have one thing in common, and that's a good production. That's the same for Kyoto Animation projects, they hold a reputable position for how they produce their anime and the quality of their production
altough they may not have the best stories but their production is responsible for making that story feel special to you. Speaking of Hayao Miyazaki, let's their example, studio ghibli films are carried by the production. Sounds like a hot opinion? but it's not, people just don't notice this. If you take away the production from his movies they wouldn't feel special at all, the plot and stories in itself aren't great, all the love which people have for ghibli films are because these movies feels beautiful and immersive to a beautiful fictional world. that is because of the artistic talent and vision of miyazaki and his direction which comes under production.

I would just suggest you to watch this 10 min vid and then share you counter opinion or otherwise we would just be aruging back and forth for hours and reach nowhere

It's a very good video which changed my opinion in how i viewed animes too
LIVI___Jan 5, 12:14 AM
Jan 5, 1:38 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
33
Reply to LIVI___
@SCYTHER07 Dumb opinion. If story is the only thing which matters, why make an anime adaptation at the first place, just read the manga. or maybe just voice over the manga and present them as episodes like blue lock. Production matters more. A manga like sakamoto days deserves a good anime production and it's fair to criticize what we are being presented
@LIVI___ Id rather watch an anime with a good adaptation than read a manga cause you can just sit back and relax while watching the show unlike the manga where you have to keep scrolling every few seconds.I agree a good manga deserves a good anime adaptation but its not complete shit the animation in sakamoto days looks decent but for some crybabies animation is all that matters.Also second thing is that besides animation theres ost voice acting,op,ed and so many more things that happen in an anime which makes it better than a manga
Jan 5, 1:43 AM
Offline
Sep 2023
4
the song is so good but the animation ruined it😞
Jan 5, 1:44 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
33
Reply to Confused_100
SCYTHER07 said:
@Confused_100 Still not gonna criticise it cause thats childish behavior.Id rather be patient and keep watching the 'bad animation' rather than watch something super popular with god tier animation like demon slayer. If the story gets boring id naturally drop it

And here’s the thing, you think demon slayer’s story is bad, yet it sold better than jjk and csm with lower number of volumes…

I know this is gonna sound weird to you, but the theme of family is huge in eastern culture compared to western, hence the popularity. You thinking the story is weak is your opinion.

Now for the animation criticism is equal to childish remark? Really? LOL

Best answer using your pfp: imagine sasuke vs itachi fight with mid animation, I would love to see you defend it.
@Confused_100 Majority of the fanbase of demon slayer consists of kids and teenagers, you know why cause you don't need to think while watching it its just for the sake of entertainment and doesn't need to apply a lot of thought process. Also I wasn't solely relying on Itachi vs Sasuke for enjoying Naruto, theres so much more than just that one fight like Itachis mindset his love for his village and the things he had to sacrifice to make certain things happen.Also id still watch the fight with mid animation and be happy with it
Jan 5, 1:50 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
33
Reply to someguy
SCYTHER07 said:
Cry more.If the story is good that's all that matters

My guy, SakaDays is more abt the action than the story. Imagine now, how an action show would work with mediocre animation.
@someguy Theres always an option to drop it if the story's not good
Jan 5, 2:49 AM
Offline
Feb 2023
1009
SCYTHER07 said:
@Confused_100 Majority of the fanbase of demon slayer consists of kids and teenagers, you know why cause you don't need to think while watching it its just for the sake of entertainment and doesn't need to apply a lot of thought process. Also I wasn't solely relying on Itachi vs Sasuke for enjoying Naruto, theres so much more than just that one fight like Itachis mindset his love for his village and the things he had to sacrifice to make certain things happen.Also id still watch the fight with mid animation and be happy with it

You are ignoring the main point of my argument… smh

The point of the matter: the story is good but if the animation of a fight scene is bad, the emotions you feel for the fight goes flat. So if the story is hyping this fight to come and that fight falls flat, how do you think it will impact your perception of the story? Yeah a lot especially for an action anime. but even if it isn’t then ironically something like uzumaki which has a great story got ruined just because of animation.

Btw demon slayer is mostly watched by kids? Teenagers I get and families but kids? Okay, there’s an easy response to that, first episode lol. The story being simple isn’t equal bad if it achieves it correctly. The opinion of “story more complex equals masterpiece” is flawed.

Anyways at the end of this conversation: I do hope and wish I am wrong and the animation of this skyrockets because I really want this to be anime of the season or year even. Until then, I will keep criticising because I want a better adaptation. Sakadays deserves it.
Jan 5, 3:17 AM

Online
Jul 2024
448
SCYTHER07 said:
@someguy Theres always an option to drop it if the story's not good

ive already caught up to the manga last year and i love it
Jan 5, 4:04 AM
Offline
Jul 2020
112
Reply to LIVI___
@daft_mariner A good production always elevates the story while the bad one cripples it. Demon slayer is the best example for it, People call demon slayer overrated and mid but the popularity it achieved is a dream every other producers dream of. So "greatest of animation" does save the crappiest and most bottom of the barrel stories, you can look up sukuna vs mahoraga from JJK, the manga itself doesn't really contain much, it's just 2 chapters of fight and mahoraga was just introduced out of nowhere yet the anime adaptation just elevates it to the extent that they are both different media now and the anime version is just way too superior than the manga too much that sukuna vs maho is considered one of the greatest fights in anime.

Story doesn't mean shit when the production is bad(altough in a very few exceptional cases story is too good for an average production to affect it), a bad production will always handicap the story in some way you have already seen badly produced shows being turned into shit despite it having crazy good writing and story, The most recent example is Blue Lock and uzumaki. You just never notice how important the production is.
Blue Lock and Haiykuu are both animes belonging from the same sports genre, blue have been the best selling manga of all time surpassing even one piece and jjk. But when it comes to the anime, y'know the rest of the case.

Also "direction" comes under the production too,
Even in the most of the genres, the production has carried it's popularity. Let's just ignore action, let's take slice of life. The bests of the slice of life animes have one thing in common, and that's a good production. That's the same for Kyoto Animation projects, they hold a reputable position for how they produce their anime and the quality of their production
altough they may not have the best stories but their production is responsible for making that story feel special to you. Speaking of Hayao Miyazaki, let's their example, studio ghibli films are carried by the production. Sounds like a hot opinion? but it's not, people just don't notice this. If you take away the production from his movies they wouldn't feel special at all, the plot and stories in itself aren't great, all the love which people have for ghibli films are because these movies feels beautiful and immersive to a beautiful fictional world. that is because of the artistic talent and vision of miyazaki and his direction which comes under production.

I would just suggest you to watch this 10 min vid and then share you counter opinion or otherwise we would just be aruging back and forth for hours and reach nowhere

It's a very good video which changed my opinion in how i viewed animes too
@LIVI___ Popularity doesn't equal quality. Is it every producer's dream? Idk. I'm a member of the audience. I consume what they produce. Popularity doesn't mean anything to me, at least in a meaningful way. Yes, something like Demon Slayer became extremely popular mainly due to its visuals, but the thing that really 'elevated' it was direction. The way they portrayed and directed it elevated the source material in a way that it made the story seem more interesting as well.

Yet, you're missing the point. You say story doesn't mean shit if the production is bad: you're almost right, were it not for the fact that the story remains what it is no matter how you portray it. That's integral to any piece of visual entertainment that contains any semblance of narrative. A story doesn't have to be that interesting on paper in order to still be enjoyable, but the story is still central to what makes it good or bad anyway. I.E. Revenant (starring Leonardo DiCaprio) isn't complex. It's kind of bland on paper, actually; but the way it's directed and played by the actors makes it visceral and compelling. Still, the driving force of the film is contained in the plot. Not the filmmaking. A film is telling and showing you the story. It still has to be written in a way that it also works the way its portrayed in an adaptation, and vice versa.

Point is, production doesn't matter more than story, because its purpose is to envisage it. Not supercede it. It doesn't need to be Demon Slayer in order to do that and be interesting, no matter how hard you try to suggest otherwise. It's only my opinion ofc, but no, I don't think pretty visuals and esoteric designs saved Darling in the Franxx from being a wad of horseshit, or Demon Slayer's flashy episodes from being mid. As controversial as Record of Ragnarok's anime is, I liked it a lot more than something like God of Highschool.

Don't get me wrong, I don't fully agree with SCYTHER07, but at least their viewpoint is fair. If the story is good, that's all that matters in their eyes. On the other hand, since you're arguing for what's been presented (the opening), I find it weird that you think it's fair to criticize it the way you're implying. We haven't even seen the first episode yet.
Jan 5, 5:07 AM
Offline
Feb 2024
89
That opening looked about as expressive as the main character's face.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

» Final Trailer

GoCrayzee - Yesterday

26 by someguy »»
2 minutes ago

» Honestly, who let the Japanese promotion team cook? There's no way Netflix made a way better trailer than the JP team.

RealNath - Yesterday

13 by AakBan_Pochi29 »»
8 hours ago

» Final Trailer

Ki11grave - Yesterday

8 by Buckshot_ »»
8 hours ago

» Stop ( 1 2 )

someguy - Jan 4

66 by Confused_100 »»
Yesterday, 7:07 AM

» Japanese fans are not happy with the upcoming Sakamoto Days Anime adaptation to the point the studio started deleting negative Japanese comments from YouTube trailers

deg - Dec 28, 2024

43 by AmirKazeXD »»
Jan 8, 11:45 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login