[Maybe spoilers] Overrated?

Offline

Mar 2021

1058

It’s one of my favourite seasons of anything so I don’t think it’s overrated.

Nov 2, 2021 7:01 AM

#5

Kaneki__kun__2

Offline

Aug 2021

131

Nahh bro it's not, it's the most important series.

Nov 2, 2021 7:07 AM

#6

RobertEruki

Offline

Oct 2021

8

Honestly peak aot to me

Nov 2, 2021 7:12 AM

#7

CamelBow

Offline

Nov 2020

1513

Just quickly skimming on about S3 P2, I can write much more for S3 P2 but there's no point in going into absolute detail.

S3 P2 is the culmination of the build-up of the past season even tho S3 P1 was such a terrible adaptation, not only is the battle of Shiganshina was absolutely phenomenal but the things after it was a masterpiece. Serumbowl was one of the most-tense episodes.

I loved how Erwin's last moment completely recontextualized his character and made it much deeper and fascinating it was like his whole character was building up to his charge and his death, We are also introduced to Levi and Zeke's dynamics.

Armin's Peak in the anime, showing how far he would go to discover the sea even if he won't be able to experience it. Mikasa starts to learn that she has to let go of her family for the betterment of everyone else. Focusing more on teamwork and other stuff.

Grisha's past making complete sense(I wish they adapted his past panel-by-panel but what we got was amazing too), Introduction of Kruger, and how the backstory of Grisha smoothy shifts the whole narrative of AoT while not being forced, contrived, and out of place and gets concluded by that beautiful Beach sequence where we are foreshadowed the point where Eren and Armin starts walking different path(The shell in the ocean sequence symbolizes this)

I love S4 P1 equally for this reason. S4 enhances the content of S3 P2 while introducing some completely new themes, characters, and narratives.

So yeah my point is S3 P2 is not at all Over-rated.

CamelBowNov 2, 2021 7:19 AM

═════════════════════════════
You're going to be all right. You just stumbled over a stone in the road.
It means nothing. Your goal lies far beyond this. Doesn't it?
I'm sure you'll overcome this.
You'll walk again... soon.
═════════════════════════════

Nov 2, 2021 7:15 AM

#8

Lamyanba1999

Offline

Jun 2020

174

This season has many great moments which mark the series as the one of the best anime and The best anime for some people ( including me ) .But if you think it doesn’t deserve the rating , well that’s your opinion .

Nov 2, 2021 7:17 AM

#9

Seigfried_XO

Offline

Feb 2021

109

TheUltimateB said:
Just finished this season and tbh it's probably my favourite season so far of aot.Now i am not saying that it is my fav but it's not good, no, it was really really amazing, but im not quite sure if it really deserves the nr. 3 spot, i think it should've been in the top 10-15 but i am not mad or anything about its at the moment rank, it's just that i consider other anime to be a bit unappreciated (f.e. Monster, Berserk, SEL etc.). What do you think?

Overrated?
Series - Hell yea
S3 pt 2 - Hell no

Nov 2, 2021 7:23 AM

#10

Offline

May 2021

231

S3 p2 was really good but I don't think its a masterpiece. The series as a whole is kinda overrated imo.
Don't care about mal top anime spots. We all know monster, shinsekai yori, 3gatsu, vinland saga and many more anime are better than aot.

Lone_wolf27Nov 2, 2021 7:52 AM

Nov 2, 2021 7:27 AM

#11

Offline

Jul 2018

564089

Did you just say Berserk , which one 1997 or 2016?

Nov 2, 2021 7:29 AM

#12

Offline

Dec 2020

24

Chota_Itachi said:
Did you just say Berserk , which one 1997 or 2016?

obv 1997, 2016 was just really painful

Nov 2, 2021 7:31 AM

#13

Offline

Jul 2018

564089

TheUltimateB said:

Chota_Itachi said:
Did you just say Berserk , which one 1997 or 2016?

obv 1997, 2016 was just really painful

hmmm even 1997 isn't justice to the Manga , berserk is #1 in manga rankings and that should be enough its not like it should be on peak in every goddamn way

Nov 2, 2021 7:36 AM

#14

e5812

Offline

Feb 2021

1338

didn't really see anything that set this season apart from the others except the absement reveal, but even than it wasn't that impactful so yeah

Nov 2, 2021 7:37 AM

#15

Offline

Dec 2020

24

Chota_Itachi said:

TheUltimateB said:

obv 1997, 2016 was just really painful

hmmm even 1997 isn't justice to the Manga , berserk is #1 in manga rankings and that should be enough its not like it should be on peak in every goddamn way

never said that berserk should be the ultimate nr 1 anime as well, im just saying that from my point of view if aot could get such a high score, animes like berserk could get a bit higher, it doesn't need a better score than this season of aot, i just think it needed a higher spot. And also, if i didn't metion it in the topic description, i thought that this season was really amazing, i rarely give a 10/10, but this season deserved it, i just wanted to see other people's take on this season

Nov 2, 2021 7:37 AM

#16

Offline

Mar 2021

1058

“Gives it 10/10”
“Calls it overrated”
What

Nov 2, 2021 7:41 AM

#17

Offline

Dec 2020

24

Nitroade24h said:
“Gives it 10/10”
“Calls it overrated”
What

again, i asked if people think it's overrated, i just said that it's really good, but out of all the thousands of anime, i'm not really sure if it really needed the nr 3 spot

Nov 2, 2021 7:49 AM

#18

Offline

Jan 2021

254

Nitroade24h said:
It’s one of my favourite seasons of anything so I don’t think it’s overrated.

Kaneki__kun__2 said:
Nahh bro it's not, it's the most important series.

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

Nov 2, 2021 7:51 AM

#19

Offline

Jul 2018

564089

Of course it is. Attack on titan is pretty good on its hype moments and all, but the story itself is poorly made, and in this part of the anime a lot of things happen because the script needs it. Not gonna get into spoiler tho

Nov 2, 2021 7:51 AM

#20

RedIchigo99

Offline

Mar 2020

111

I would say Season 3 in general is very under appropriated if anything when it comes to AOT. A lot are usually more focused on season 2 and season 1 but tend to either forget season 3 or not really appreciate it. It’s definitely got a lot of great moments and way more focused on characters and backstories than Titian fighting.There are some who pretend it’s the best anime has to offer or it’s the best season when it’s not but generally people usually forget about Season 3 or rarely talk about it and with Season 4 out that trend may continue even though I think Season 3 in general (both pt 1 and 2) are way better than what has been shown so far in season 4 in my opinion.

Nov 2, 2021 7:52 AM

#21

Offline

Jul 2018

564089

VaggPe said:

Nitroade24h said:
It’s one of my favourite seasons of anything so I don’t think it’s overrated.

Kaneki__kun__2 said:
Nahh bro it's not, it's the most important series.

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

i think he meant "most important PART" of the series

Nov 2, 2021 7:53 AM

#22

Offline

Jan 2021

254

Chota_Itachi said:

VaggPe said:

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

i think he meant "most important PART" of the series

If he actually meant that then I agree.

Nov 2, 2021 7:56 AM

#23

Offline

Mar 2021

1058

TheUltimateB said:

Nitroade24h said:
“Gives it 10/10”
“Calls it overrated”
What

again, i asked if people think it's overrated, i just said that it's really good, but out of all the thousands of anime, i'm not really sure if it really needed the nr 3 spot

Well if it’s 10/10 that means it’s pretty much perfect in every way so any perfect show could be in the top 3

Nov 2, 2021 7:56 AM

#24

Kaneki__kun__2

Offline

Aug 2021

131

VaggPe said:

Nitroade24h said:
It’s one of my favourite seasons of anything so I don’t think it’s overrated.

Kaneki__kun__2 said:
Nahh bro it's not, it's the most important series.

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

bro that's were the story takes turn and the history is revealed about everything that what is happening in aot right now. It was in s3 pt2 so it was the most important series and if they didn't opened the basement the truth was never to be found. It that part of the story, were we all know what happened beyond the wall. Till s3 pt1 we saw only inside of the walls and some discoveries were made. But s3 pt 2 was the most important one and so will be the the final season part 2.

Nov 2, 2021 7:56 AM

#25

Offline

Mar 2021

1058

VaggPe said:

Nitroade24h said:
It’s one of my favourite seasons of anything so I don’t think it’s overrated.

Kaneki__kun__2 said:
Nahh bro it's not, it's the most important series.

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

they probably mean most important season

Nov 2, 2021 7:59 AM

#26

Offline

Jan 2021

254

Kaneki__kun__2 said:

VaggPe said:

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

bro that's were the story takes turn the and the history is revealed about everything that what is happening in aot right now. It was in s3 pt2 so it was the most important series and if they didn't opened the basement the truth was never to be found. It that part of the story, were we all know what happened beyond the wall. Till s3 pt1 we saw only inside of the walls and some discoveries were made. But s3 pt 2 was the most important one and so will be the the final season part 2.

So you don't mean "series". You mean part of the series. Then I agree that s3 pt2 is the most important part of aot. I just misunderstood you at first.

Nov 2, 2021 8:00 AM

#27

Offline

Jan 2021

254

Nitroade24h said:

VaggPe said:

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

they probably mean most important season

Yeah, I realized that after he responded.

Nov 2, 2021 8:00 AM

#28

Offline

May 2021

231

Kaneki__kun__2 said:

VaggPe said:

Please tell me you are joking when saying that it's the most important series.

bro that's were the story takes turn and the history is revealed about everything that what is happening in aot right now. It was in s3 pt2 so it was the most important series and if they didn't opened the basement the truth was never to be found. It that part of the story, were we all know what happened beyond the wall. Till s3 pt1 we saw only inside of the walls and some discoveries were made. But s3 pt 2 was the most important one and so will be the the final season part 2.

then u should have said that it is the most important "season" not series...

Nov 2, 2021 8:01 AM

#29

Kaneki__kun__2

Offline

Aug 2021

131

VaggPe said:

Kaneki__kun__2 said:

bro that's were the story takes turn the and the history is revealed about everything that what is happening in aot right now. It was in s3 pt2 so it was the most important series and if they didn't opened the basement the truth was never to be found. It that part of the story, were we all know what happened beyond the wall. Till s3 pt1 we saw only inside of the walls and some discoveries were made. But s3 pt 2 was the most important one and so will be the the final season part 2.

So you don't mean "series". You mean part of the series. Then I agree that s3 pt2 is the most important part of aot. I just misunderstood you at first.

ohh bruh am sorry I meant season not series,it was my mistake :)

Nov 2, 2021 8:03 AM

#30

Offline

Jan 2021

254

Kaneki__kun__2 said:

VaggPe said:

So you don't mean "series". You mean part of the series. Then I agree that s3 pt2 is the most important part of aot. I just misunderstood you at first.

ohh bruh am sorry I meant season not series,it was my mistake :)

No probs man :). At least we are on the same page.

Nov 2, 2021 8:22 AM

#31

FlipMonke

Offline

Jan 2017

42

Kinda... Idk. It was good, but my favorite were the earlier seasons. It's just my taste, I didn't like where they were going.

Nov 2, 2021 8:53 AM

#32

M3X1

Offline

Jun 2021

111

Not overrated.But i don't think this is peak AoT.Upcoming season would be better.

I came 💦😣 I saw 👁👄👁 I came 💦😣 I saw 👁👄👁 I praise the Lord ✝🙏💯 then break the law 💲🔫 I take what's mine 🤔<- then take some more ✡💲 it rains it pours 💦☔ it rains it pours 🌧🌈

Nov 2, 2021 9:51 AM

#33

Requiemofthewind

Offline

Oct 2021

422

TheUltimateB said:
Just finished this season and tbh it's probably my favourite season so far of aot.Now i am not saying that it is my fav but it's not good, no, it was really really amazing, but im not quite sure if it really deserves the nr. 3 spot, i think it should've been in the top 10-15 but i am not mad or anything about its at the moment rank, it's just that i consider other anime to be a bit unappreciated (f.e. Monster, Berserk, SEL etc.). What do you think?

you are elitist that's why you call this shit is overrated.

Nov 2, 2021 10:01 AM

#34

Requiemofthewind

Offline

Oct 2021

422

Heartless_x said:

TheUltimateB said:
Just finished this season and tbh it's probably my favourite season so far of aot.Now i am not saying that it is my fav but it's not good, no, it was really really amazing, but im not quite sure if it really deserves the nr. 3 spot, i think it should've been in the top 10-15 but i am not mad or anything about its at the moment rank, it's just that i consider other anime to be a bit unappreciated (f.e. Monster, Berserk, SEL etc.). What do you think?

Overrated?
Series - Hell yea
S3 pt 2 - Hell no

yeah Tokyo Ghoul is overrated both manga and anime

Nov 2, 2021 10:04 AM

#35

Offline

Dec 2020

24

Judgement1 said:

TheUltimateB said:
Just finished this season and tbh it's probably my favourite season so far of aot.Now i am not saying that it is my fav but it's not good, no, it was really really amazing, but im not quite sure if it really deserves the nr. 3 spot, i think it should've been in the top 10-15 but i am not mad or anything about its at the moment rank, it's just that i consider other anime to be a bit unappreciated (f.e. Monster, Berserk, SEL etc.). What do you think?

you are elitist that's why you call this shit is overrated.

the title of the topic doesn't mean "this is overrated" or " i think this is overrated", i asked if "you think it is overrated".
And again, i don't have a problem with attack on titan, i like the show since it's the first anime i've watched and it's a pretty entertaining series

Nov 2, 2021 11:17 AM

#36

WolfSaber

Offline

Feb 2020

1737

While I can see why people would call this overrated I do not not find it overrated it has my favorite arc in anime after all.

Nov 2, 2021 12:14 PM

#37

ghier

Offline

Aug 2019

1374

I mean the rating is what it is like for every other show. One persons feelings doesn’t mean anything compared to the one calculated from everyone’s personal score. If there are people boosting it than yeah, maybe it’s too high. But otherwise, no it is not overrated. Anyone that says otherwise is a bit biased to their own personal feelings.

Nov 2, 2021 12:31 PM

#38

CandyRagi

Offline

Nov 2020

831

TheUltimateB said:
Just finished this season and tbh it's probably my favourite season so far of aot.Now i am not saying that it is my fav but it's not good, no, it was really really amazing, but im not quite sure if it really deserves the nr. 3 spot, i think it should've been in the top 10-15 but i am not mad or anything about its at the moment rank, it's just that i consider other anime to be a bit unappreciated (f.e. Monster, Berserk, SEL etc.). What do you think?

I think aot should be #3 it is the spot that it deserves......and yeah there r some anime like fmab and hxh that doesn't deserve that spot and are actually overrated....can't do anythin bout that......

"No one can rewrite the stars
How can you say you'll be mine?
Everything keeps us apart
And I'm not the one you were meant to find
It's not up to you you
It's not up to me
When everyone tells us what we can be
How can we rewrite the stars?"

Nov 2, 2021 12:31 PM

#39

SevenStop

Offline

Oct 2019

71

I think AOT in general is a bit overrated but this season is definitely not. It's amazing

The last remaining functional person on this site

Nov 2, 2021 3:50 PM

#40

_spoon_

Offline

Jul 2021

3936

hell yes the most overrated arc in fiction its an 8 out of 10 at max many big plot holes I cant overlook absolutely no character development (except for Erwin and Mabey Levi) and plot armor thicker than concrete along with many bull shit death fake-outs does not deserve even 1% of the praise it gets not even the best aot season that would be s4 after the bellow the Mariana trench ending its probably a 7 out of 10

Nov 2, 2021 6:36 PM

#41

maldonado3008

Offline

Jul 2021

35

_spoon_ said:
hell yes the most overrated arc in fiction its an 8 out of 10 at max many big plot holes I cant overlook absolutely no character development (except for Erwin and Mabey Levi) and plot armor thicker than concrete along with many bull shit death fake-outs does not deserve even 1% of the praise it gets not even the best aot season that would be s4 after the bellow the Mariana trench ending its probably a 7 out of 10

Overrated? Plot holes?bro, I don't know if we saw the same season but nothing happens in this season due to the help of the script, all the events are congruent and everything that is used to get out of this situation are elements that were already available to you before the arc.
I don't know why you think it's wrong

Nov 2, 2021 6:36 PM

#42

Offline

Jul 2018

564089

you could make an argument for it being overrated, for me I'm kind of in the middle.

Nov 2, 2021 6:39 PM

#43

_spoon_

Offline

Jul 2021

3936

maldonado3008 said:

_spoon_ said:
hell yes the most overrated arc in fiction its an 8 out of 10 at max many big plot holes I cant overlook absolutely no character development (except for Erwin and Mabey Levi) and plot armor thicker than concrete along with many bull shit death fake-outs does not deserve even 1% of the praise it gets not even the best aot season that would be s4 after the bellow the Mariana trench ending its probably a 7 out of 10

Overrated? Plot holes?bro, I don't know if we saw the same season but nothing happens in this season due to the help of the script, all the events are congruent and everything that is used to get out of this situation are elements that were already available to you before the arc.
I don't know why you think it's wrong

there are plot holes and plot armor im a lot more critical so you probably didn't notice them

Nov 2, 2021 7:56 PM

#44

Offline

May 2021

231

maldonado3008 said:

_spoon_ said:
hell yes the most overrated arc in fiction its an 8 out of 10 at max many big plot holes I cant overlook absolutely no character development (except for Erwin and Mabey Levi) and plot armor thicker than concrete along with many bull shit death fake-outs does not deserve even 1% of the praise it gets not even the best aot season that would be s4 after the bellow the Mariana trench ending its probably a 7 out of 10

Overrated? Plot holes?bro, I don't know if we saw the same season but nothing happens in this season due to the help of the script, all the events are congruent and everything that is used to get out of this situation are elements that were already available to you before the arc.
I don't know why you think it's wrong

seriously, u think there isn't any plotholes? Aot is known for its plotholes and plot armour and after the ending of the manga the plotholes have only increased.

Nov 2, 2021 8:22 PM

#45

Requiemofthewind

Offline

Oct 2021

422

maldonado3008 said:

_spoon_ said:
hell yes the most overrated arc in fiction its an 8 out of 10 at max many big plot holes I cant overlook absolutely no character development (except for Erwin and Mabey Levi) and plot armor thicker than concrete along with many bull shit death fake-outs does not deserve even 1% of the praise it gets not even the best aot season that would be s4 after the bellow the Mariana trench ending its probably a 7 out of 10

Overrated? Plot holes?bro, I don't know if we saw the same season but nothing happens in this season due to the help of the script, all the events are congruent and everything that is used to get out of this situation are elements that were already available to you before the arc.
I don't know why you think it's wrong

his chimera ant arc fangay that's why lol.

Nov 2, 2021 9:04 PM

#46