DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this chapter. If you want to discuss future events, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to read/download this chapter or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Manga Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| THIS IS A MANGA ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS ANYTHING BEYOND THIS CHAPTER. ---------------------------------------- I'm on the verge of tears T_T Definitely one of Sahara Mizu's best works. |
 |
| Was still hoping for Yuu's release:/ the ending was a bit too sad |
| Cried rivers |
  |
| damn it's been long since I cried while reading something... :'( |
| I just finished it, I never cried while reading manga but I'm crying now :( OMG it's so sad :( I can't believe he died like this :(!! even thought from the beginning I knew he will die but in the end maybe her brother will help a little. :( It's really sad story. :'( |
| Just finished it. I won't lie, I'm crying like a baby right now. This manga is SO emotionally powerful, truly a masterpiece. |
| Superb ending, this last chapter was the best. The previous chapters don't quite match up, but it's still a great manga. |
| Just finished all of it today. I knew I wanna going to cry soon once I reached ch. 8 and I did ;-; yumeka sumomo is amazing! |
| i just finished it as well. it was beautiful, moving, in every way possible. i wish there were more of this kind of manga. those that move you. |
LoreleiNov 5, 2009 7:47 PM
 I am a guy. Don't let my avatar, Yukishiro Tomoe, fool you. |
| A good story, a bit sad at the end though, i guess i'm happy Yuu experienced happiness and that happiness was rediscovered for Her as well. Overall a very good story. |
gastricjuiceNov 8, 2009 10:50 PM
 |
| I was literally crying through most of the chapters. Wow. It was amazing. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
sugarplumfairy said: Same here. I was literally crying through most of the chapters. Wow. It was amazing. Even though the ending should have been obvious I was still hit by it a lot. ;___; |
 ジリティック♡BEGINNER |
| I hate this manga. I mean, I NEVER cry. EVER. Not with movies, or books, maybe rarely with songs. But this fucking manga got me to the verge of tears. It's just so beautiful, so sad. By the way, all of you who were expecting him to live... come on. You knew the ending. You knew what was gonna happen. Suck it up. |
 |
| Unbelievably powerful story. I'm pretty much at a loss of words, I kind of want to criticize something about it too, like some of the drawings.. but screw that. This is among the easiest 10/10 I've given here on MAL. I wish some/any animations were awesome like this masterpiece. About the ending, it sure made me sob too, but I thought it was pretty humane (for the reader!) still. There are enough sadistic mangaka out there who'd have killed half the cast at the end of such a story. That said, up until chapter 6 or so, I didn't really expect the girl to live until the end, heh. |
     |
| It wasn't fair Yuu didn't deserve to die. He was just brought up in the wrong environment. |
lawliet5Jan 16, 2010 5:13 PM
 |
| Even though i knew it was coming, it was still sad :-( Perfect example of why the death penalty sux |
| Thanks Yumeka Sumomo for this beautiful story and yet so sad, I was crying so much >_< when she was playing the piano and crying, and he was standing there crying and i was crying too such a beautiful an sad part, i just loved this manga. |
| The ending was well executed. A bittersweet manga that made me shed a tear, I was listening Loreena McKennitt – Kecharitomene which made the mood perfect. Gotta pay for what you've done. ☺ 9-10/10 |
 |
| Holy fuck. This manga made me cry like a baby ;__; *sniffle* Even though it was ONLY one volume, it felt like I read more than that. The characters were very well-rounded & the emotions were just the right amount. It's rare that a manga leaves such a big impression on me too. And I also noticed that it's always the really really good stories that end up being so damn short (I kinda wish it was longer...) Either way, I enjoyed this manga very much. It's definitely going into my favorites! ♥ |
Bunny-kinsApr 4, 2010 12:27 PM
| tears ... tears What to say , great manga , very emotional , wonderful job from he author the best manga for me ^^ |
 |
| Not just the ending made me cry, it was through the whole manga. No matter how stupid it sounds, how insanely powerful could be the feeling of regret regardless of what you have done? It was just genuine, just fucking beautiful. 10/10. |
Mikiyo said: Not just the ending made me cry, it was through the whole manga. Yeah, I was sobbing here and there, but this ending made me bawl my eyes out. Listening to "Yoru wo Kakeru" while reading made it that much better... That was just... beautiful. |
- If you believe this place holds you, it is a prison. If you do not wish to leave, it will become a fortress. Current icon: Kusuriuri from Mononoke by pana (LJ username) |
| The manga didn't make me shed a tear. It made me cried rivers! LOL. the ending was so sad. :( I thought it would be quite happy. :( |
| Oh, I see that my answer in the questionnaire "4 - like it" was the only one. No, I didn't dislike it, but... I can't give all 5 points. Yuu was the person who had to die. Yes, he's nice. But... we have to see also his victims. Little girl, mommy... but dammit, it's so sad! Six lives absolutely lost . :( |
 Sorry for my English ^^ |
| What a lame manga series. Young spoiled girl, verbally abused by her mother, wants to commit suicide then takes solace in conversing with a criminal who killed a corrupt man and then falls in love with him (only because he's attractive and the only guy she interacts with). The cherry on top was when the mangaka illustrates that the guy actually liked her from a long time ago when he stalked her as she practiced piano. This tragedy is hilariously bad at best. This would only have been a tragedy if this was a real life story rather than a lame set up for a romance manga. 4/10 |
arimakenshinMay 2, 2010 6:00 PM
arimakenshin said: What a lame manga series. Young spoiled girl, verbally abused by her mother, wants to commit suicide then takes solace in conversing with a criminal who killed a corrupt man and then falls in love with him (only because he's attractive and the only guy she interacts with). The cherry on top was when the mangaka illustrates that the guy actually liked her from a long time ago when he stalked her as she practiced piano. This tragedy is hilariously bad at best. This would only have been a tragedy if this was a real life story rather than a lame set up for a romance manga. 4/10 Believe me, if you take like that ALL anime/manga/books even real life then it all sounds like a big soap opera.Now I'm not going to argue anymore with anyone because opinions aren't always the same. ANYWAY, this was..I don't have words.I see that everyone here said that they don't usually cry so it's ok for me since I start bawling even at the things I know that are going to be ok. I expected it to end like that.And I actually like the ending although I would've loved seeing it in another form[such as, Yuu survives and he gets out of prison years later and stuff like that.] 10/10 from me. |
| Emotionally gripping! The story has beautifully portrayed the lessons of forgiveness and happiness even in this kind of situations.. It really made me cry a pool of tears though I'm the sort who cries to this kind of drama... but nevertheless, it is rich with raw emotions and makes you think how you see life as a whole.. It is poignantly captivating... A must read to those who likes stories that grip the heart and wrench the soul.. hehe.. I'm thankful that I stumbled upon this accidentally coz I have read a very beautiful manga.. Live because life is surely beautiful even amidst the hardships! ^o^ |
 |
| Obviously knew that was coming, but I still sobbed. Probably one of the most beautiful mangas I've ever read. |
| A really heart warming story. Truly beautiful. 9/10. |
 |
| A murderer manages to emotionally bed a depressed, insecure girl because he's the only male presence in her life. How are people sobbing over this? /analytical perspective |
| Although I saw the ending coming from a mile away, it still sucked as much as I was expecting. Didn't make me cry. That said, I'm giving this a 10/10 cause I thought it was really damn good. |
 |
| The story was so bitter sweet and I can't believe this made me cry so much. |
 |
| Finished. Good story, good characters, but something doesn't work. I just finished an emotional story, one of those stories that make you think, and I feel that my life will go ahead as I didn't read anything. I can't stand it, a failed masterpiece. Why I don't feel anything about? |
| Wtf I didn't think this manga was sad at all... I guess they call me Chris Brown. |
| What a profound, human, and tragically beautiful story. Simplistic in character in setting, this work should be required reading for everyone. Besides the immediate applications to the morality of capital punishment and the humanity of those society perceives as bad, this is a such a deep look inside two complex humans that I'd think only the people living it could know. From beginning to end I was dragged along a tale of sorrow that never felt to angsty or tragic. Every string of dialogue or narrative had a sense of significance to it. And even though the end was predictable, it managed to carry so much weight because of what the story did leading up to it. The first 10 I have ever issued to a manga. |
adamantine said: sugarplumfairy said: Same here. I was literally crying through most of the chapters. Wow. It was amazing. Even though the ending should have been obvious I was still hit by it a lot. ;___; Me too T^T I were hoping for him to avoid death to the same end... I knew it was to come but still... Maaan, he was soo good person it hurts T^T Damn psycho !!! It was his fault T^T I must calm myself... Ahh.. Anyway I'm thankfull i was able to read this manga...Really thankfull |
| Sorry for my English ^^' If you notice any mistakes, please tell me about it ^^ Thanks for corrections ^^ |
arimakenshin said: What a lame manga series. Young spoiled girl, verbally abused by her mother, wants to commit suicide then takes solace in conversing with a criminal who killed a corrupt man and then falls in love with him (only because he's attractive and the only guy she interacts with). The cherry on top was when the mangaka illustrates that the guy actually liked her from a long time ago when he stalked her as she practiced piano. This tragedy is hilariously bad at best. This would only have been a tragedy if this was a real life story rather than a lame set up for a romance manga. 4/10 Do you have no soul or compassion?!? Meh, I'll leave it be because, generally, its a waste of effort. This is the first manga I have been glued to since I have looked around. For years, I had read the first chapter of lots of manga titles, but this is the first to keep me at it. Granted, it does require a good sense of a certain emotional grip to understand why it worked, so I guess I can understand why some may not find it to their taste. But having only read two manga's in full, I can't justify giving it a 10 having only one other to go by. If I think it's brilliant, but not a 10. May change that as I read more. |
 |
| I feel like I've read something of great importance. I hope I'll remember the conclusions these two came to and the words that had been spoken. |
 |
| tears at 2AM. What a masterpiece..that was so beautifully written. I could go on but what can I say that hasn't already be said. |
Tarrasji said: This ending wasn't sad at all. I've watched the Korean movie of this film, that's what I call a sad ending. ^True The ending of the movie is more sad, one of the most sad movies I watched. |
| Wow... I mean, just wow. I came across this manga by accident, probably the best accident that ever happened to me =) The end was amazing. True, it was sad but also very realistic... I mean, come on, if Yuu was released in the end it would've been so... Wrong. Anyways, great story, true and honest message, gorgeous art and well developed characters. Loved. |
 |
| Lonely, rebellious, suicidal virgin with mental issues falls in love with the only guy she ever got to know, who happens to be a murderer. Are people conveniently forgetting that the guy used to stalk her as she played the piano and also murdered a person? I guess the distinct feature between creepy and "romantic" is the attractiveness of the guy. |
| Come on, who really didn't see this coming? |
| Even when I was in crowd, I was always alone |
More topics from this board
» Did you cry? ( 1 2 )SleepyBear - May 29, 2014 |
89 |
by justmaya
»»
Yesterday, 2:37 AM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan Chapter 1 Discussion-kassy- - Feb 12, 2011 |
28 |
by perverseangel
»»
Nov 13, 8:59 PM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan Chapter 7 DiscussionKitaTsuki - Apr 16, 2011 |
22 |
by FarCritical
»»
May 11, 5:29 AM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan Chapter 6 Discussion5layer - Jun 25, 2010 |
30 |
by FarCritical
»»
May 11, 5:13 AM |
|
Poll: » Watashitachi no Shiawase na Jikan Chapter 5 Discussionadamantine - Oct 7, 2009 |
29 |
by FarCritical
»»
May 9, 7:05 AM |