Wistoria's Wand and Sword
| Why can MC attend a magic school and pass without the help of magic, what's the point? MC gets points for dungeons and no one thought to check how he does it even though he can't use the simplest spell? |
| Bro is literally complaining that the most overused shounen trope makes no sense. |
 |
| anime is not always realistic you know its fiction for a reason |
Reply to Piromysl
Bro is literally complaining that the most overused shounen trope makes no sense.
| @Piromysl I guess it's a good thing about me that I don't take shit without thinking xD Honestly, I haven't watched too many anime with the theme "a guy with no magic skills, he studies in a magic school", maybe Black Clover, but there MC actually had magic thanks to the demon, Mashle.. .I haven't watched it, but from what I know, the MC was strong enough to imitate magic..maybe stupid, but there's something, and there's nothing here |
Reply to CrunchyCrobat
Harry potter always goes around breaking rules, why didn't he get expelled and instead be praised for everything he does? If you start asking questions like this, a whole story falls apart, so rather, just enjoy it for what it is
| @CrunchyCrobat I watched Harry Potter a long time ago and I don't remember everything, but the foundations of the entire plot were certainly not that shaken. |
Ba-Cii10 said: @Piromysl I guess it's a good thing about me that I don't take shit without thinking xD Honestly, I haven't watched too many anime with the theme "a guy with no magic skills, he studies in a magic school", maybe Black Clover, but there MC actually had magic thanks to the demon, Mashle.. .I haven't watched it, but from what I know, the MC was strong enough to imitate magic..maybe stupid, but there's something, and there's nothing here bro, shounen is suppose to be like this... stupid dumb lol. if u can't then u have many show other than shounen demographic, don't forget that. |
 |
| This is not a well known fact, but if you're struggling to get enough credits at uni in Australia, you can earn them by going into the university dungeon and slaying a couple monsters. |
Reply to Uruichi
Ba-Cii10 said:
Why can MC attend a magic school and pass without the help of magic, what's the point? MC gets points for dungeons and no one thought to check how he does it even though he can't use the simplest spell?
Why can MC attend a magic school and pass without the help of magic, what's the point? MC gets points for dungeons and no one thought to check how he does it even though he can't use the simplest spell?
You’re complaining about the most basic ass tropes found in every shounen anime lol it’s not supposed to make sense other it won’t be a generic power fantasy.
| @Uruichi so tell me these shounen anime, I don't remember Naruto being able to pass the chunin exam without chakra, I know that not everything always has to make sense, but this most important part of building the plot should be justified imo |
Reply to WSlav
This is not a well known fact, but if you're struggling to get enough credits at uni in Australia, you can earn them by going into the university dungeon and slaying a couple monsters.
| @WSlav Unfortunately, there were no dungeons at my school xD I always had difficulties in mathematics at school, it's a pity that I couldn't get good grades in mathematics using physical education tests. |
Ba-Cii10 said: Why can MC attend a magic school and pass without the help of magic, what's the point? MC gets points for dungeons and no one thought to check how he does it even though he can't use the simplest spell? he excelled at magical theory which is why he got admission |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
Ba-Cii10 said: @WSlav Unfortunately, there were no dungeons at my school xD I always had difficulties in mathematics at school, it's a pity that I couldn't get good grades in mathematics using physical education tests. No need to fear, we have AI now! Straight A’s have never been easier!!! |
 |
Ba-Cii10 said: @Piromysl I guess it's a good thing about me that I don't take shit without thinking xD Honestly, I haven't watched too many anime with the theme "a guy with no magic skills, he studies in a magic school", maybe Black Clover, but there MC actually had magic thanks to the demon, Mashle.. .I haven't watched it, but from what I know, the MC was strong enough to imitate magic..maybe stupid, but there's something, and there's nothing here Yeah, you have clearly not watched many anime, because "trying to be the strongest, despite not having the fundamental skill or talent and others telling me to quit" is very common and beloved trope. It teaches viewers that hard work and effort pays off despite all odds. Your take kinda puts you on the same spot as those bullies. |
|
Reply to Piromysl
Ba-Cii10 said:
@Piromysl I guess it's a good thing about me that I don't take shit without thinking xD Honestly, I haven't watched too many anime with the theme "a guy with no magic skills, he studies in a magic school", maybe Black Clover, but there MC actually had magic thanks to the demon, Mashle.. .I haven't watched it, but from what I know, the MC was strong enough to imitate magic..maybe stupid, but there's something, and there's nothing here
@Piromysl I guess it's a good thing about me that I don't take shit without thinking xD Honestly, I haven't watched too many anime with the theme "a guy with no magic skills, he studies in a magic school", maybe Black Clover, but there MC actually had magic thanks to the demon, Mashle.. .I haven't watched it, but from what I know, the MC was strong enough to imitate magic..maybe stupid, but there's something, and there's nothing here
Yeah, you have clearly not watched many anime, because "trying to be the strongest, despite not having the fundamental skill or talent and others telling me to quit" is very common and beloved trope. It teaches viewers that hard work and effort pays off despite all odds. Your take kinda puts you on the same spot as those bullies.
| @Piromysl 🤣am I a bully? ..ok, I guess you didn't understand what this topic was about |
Ba-Cii10 said: @Piromysl 🤣am I a bully? ..ok, I guess you didn't understand what this topic was about No, I'm saying that those bullies would totally aggre with you. |
|
| Makes perfect sense because they explain it, if you can't read then that's your own problem I guess. |
Reply to epyon4light
Makes perfect sense because they explain it, if you can't read then that's your own problem I guess.
| @epyon4light how explained? so that in a prestigious MC school he is able to pass the 6th grade using only theory and going to the dungeons? it's like knowing all the formulas in mathematics and not being able to solve any problem and still passing the subject or getting grades in mathematics in physical education xD |
Reply to kamane12
@Ba-Cii10 the grey hair professor, wakner says there are three ways to earn credits Dungeon, theory and then magic, these credits determine whether you graduate the school and even get a chance to be selected to go up the tower, MC does average in theory and very well in dungeon, so he survives expulsion from a hair's breadth, magic is important, but other two is equally important, and MC does other 2 to the point he barely hangs on, the professor said it when he said he need 4 more credits the week to not get expelled since he didnt get enough points from theory that week
| @kamane12 ok, theory is important, but it is needed to be better at magic because, after all, it is a SCHOOL OF MAGIC, you can understand that it has some points for theory, but it should not determine anything because the ultimate goal is to use it in practice. Dungeons are there to test magic in battle and any way to complete the dungeon other than magic should not be counted if it is a magic school that is supposed to teach you magic, the MC after 6 years is not able to perform the simplest spell and still completes the dungeon, doesn't it occur to anyone that he doesn't do it with magic? If in a magic school that is supposed to teach you magic, the final condition for passing is not the use of at least basic magic, then it makes no sense, it would be better if the MC went to a warrior school and his goal was to surpass magicians, or it could be that magic is the most important thing, but it is not a school of magicians and you can graduate as a warrior, not "I have no magic and I want to be the best magician" it is as if "I have no legs and I will be the best football player, they will put me on the pitch and I will just sit there despite that it makes no sense and I will pass the tests using theory, plus I will throw the ball into the goal with my hand when no one was watching, and no one will think how I did it without using my legs even though I literally have NO LEGS" XDD |
Reply to THiRDEYEKAii
he studies magic theory.....were you not paying attention
| @THiRDEYEKAii read literally one comment above and you will know xD |
Reply to Ba-Cii10
@THiRDEYEKAii read literally one comment above and you will know xD
| @Ba-Cii10 You're not really saying much of anything. Becoming a mage is the only way to advance toward his goal. He excels in areas other than practical magic. Normally, he would simply fail because of his lack of magical ability, but he supplements that by earning extra credit from the dungeon, something that is supposedly in the rules, but that would never ordinarily be possible to accomplish by a poor ranking student. Given how paramount magic is in that world, it makes sense we would be ridiculed and looked down upon for lacking in ability, many want to see him forced out, and others are probably wondering how he hasn't flunked out yet. There's nothing illogical about these circumstances, given everything that we know. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| same point could be said for mashle |
 |
Reply to Yeetyus
I mean it’s kinda funny that you are upset about the plot that much, but I kinda get your point. I think it’s not that deep bro. If the anime had no other thinks to offer I would agree with you but the animations are kinda fire. We don’t get that many good animated simulcast shows.
| @Yeetyus What simulcast? I only see sub. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
Reply to Yeetyus
Seasonal anime. Winter / Fall etc…
| @Yeetyus A simulcast is when the English dub airs on the same day as the sub. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| Bro doesn't watch anime |
  |
| The whole point is that the school teaches magic to students who don’t know how to use it yet. How is the school supposed to know someone will never learn it? People who go to law school aren’t lawyers yet, so why would you expect a kid going to magic school to be a mage/wizard already? |
| Gachiakuta is the greatest manga of all time |
| The dungeon is one way to earn credits, the how of it doesn't matter. It was probably done this way because everyone assumed it would be done with magic. Imagine in our world that to pass a sniper's course you needed 95/100 points to pass by hitting the mark from 600m+... but someone did so by blasting actual magic at it. It would be unheard of, the rules aren't meant for that, we can't imagine hitting the mark that precisely without a high-powered rifle. That's why there isn't a specific rule against using physical force. If anyone tried they assumed those people would fail. |
Ba-Cii10 said: The first few mins of episode 2 explains that. Maybe be a bit patient.Why can MC attend a magic school and pass without the help of magic, what's the point? |
 |
| True, that's one of the reasons why Reign of the Seven Spellblades did the "magic school+swords+dungeons" much better. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Tsue to Tsurugi no Wistoria Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Sep 8 |
82 |
by Alkimia
»»
4 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Tsue to Tsurugi no Wistoria Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Sep 1 |
129 |
by Alkimia
»»
1 hour ago |
|
Poll: » Tsue to Tsurugi no Wistoria Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Aug 25 |
134 |
by Alkimia
»»
6 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Tsue to Tsurugi no Wistoria Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Aug 18 |
122 |
by Alkimia
»»
6 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Tsue to Tsurugi no Wistoria Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Aug 11 |
110 |
by Alkimia
»»
6 hours ago |