| Why would you guys give a show with superb visuals and incredible music such a low score after only seeing 4-5 episodes of it? If you drop it I think that you don't really have the right to give it a bad rating because honestly, on what are you basing that score? This show has like 6 episodes out but already has a 5,92 score. Which parts did you dislike so much? There was no typical cliché or fanservice to be hated on so far, the characters are fun too, and the story is yet to be unveiled. ? ? ? |
 |
oryouohagi said: Why would you guys give a show with superb visuals and incredible music such a low score after only seeing 4-5 episodes of it? If you drop it I think that you don't really have the right to give it a bad rating because honestly, on what are you basing that score? This show has like 6 episodes out but already has a 5,92 score. Which parts did you dislike so much? There was no typical cliché or fanservice to be hated on so far, the characters are fun too, and the story is yet to be unveiled. ? ? ? I guess theyre basing their scores on the first 6 episodes obviously. Id also suggest not taking MAL ratings too seriously since all members use it differently, like you for example: oryouohagi said: also take the rank of the anime into consideration, if it has a low score, I'd might give it a 8, although were it in the top 100 I'd give it a 5. It works in the opposite direction too, that's why I have some anime rated the same score, when in fact one is way worse than the other. |
SpaghettiSpikeNov 13, 2016 8:17 AM
 Oshii is probably the only director that loves dogs. He thinks he's a dog himself. That's right, its slime! It will dissolve your clothing slowly before my eyes! |
Dishonest said: oryouohagi said: Why would you guys give a show with superb visuals and incredible music such a low score after only seeing 4-5 episodes of it? If you drop it I think that you don't really have the right to give it a bad rating because honestly, on what are you basing that score? This show has like 6 episodes out but already has a 5,92 score. Which parts did you dislike so much? There was no typical cliché or fanservice to be hated on so far, the characters are fun too, and the story is yet to be unveiled. ? ? ? I guess theyre basing their scores on the first 6 episodes obviously. Id also suggest not taking MAL ratings too seriously since all members use it differently, like you for example: you said: also take the rank of the anime into consideration, if it has a low score, I'd might give it a 8, although were it in the top 100 I'd give it a 5. It works in the opposite direction too, that's why I have some anime rated the same score, when in fact one is way worse than the other. What? I never giving a stuff low score just to make the total rating down from top 100 or so. I give a score just the way I feel about it. |
 |
You said: Dishonest said: I guess theyre basing their scores on the first 6 episodes obviously. Id also suggest not taking MAL ratings too seriously since all members use it differently, like you for example: What? I never giving a stuff low score just to make the total rating down from top 100 or so. I give a score just the way I feel about it. Did the link work? lol I was too lazy to put his name in there :D |
| Oshii is probably the only director that loves dogs. He thinks he's a dog himself. That's right, its slime! It will dissolve your clothing slowly before my eyes! |
| absolutely bad episode 1 |
Cross  AngeHey guys check my profile for current airing season anime recommendation (guaranteed best taste) |
Dishonest said: You said: What? I never giving a stuff low score just to make the total rating down from top 100 or so. I give a score just the way I feel about it. Did the link work? lol I was too lazy to put his name in there :D it doesn't and it sends on my notifs instead. |
|
Dishonest said: oryouohagi said: Why would you guys give a show with superb visuals and incredible music such a low score after only seeing 4-5 episodes of it? If you drop it I think that you don't really have the right to give it a bad rating because honestly, on what are you basing that score? This show has like 6 episodes out but already has a 5,92 score. Which parts did you dislike so much? There was no typical cliché or fanservice to be hated on so far, the characters are fun too, and the story is yet to be unveiled. ? ? ? I guess theyre basing their scores on the first 6 episodes obviously. Id also suggest not taking MAL ratings too seriously since all members use it differently, like you for example: oryouohagi said: also take the rank of the anime into consideration, if it has a low score, I'd might give it a 8, although were it in the top 100 I'd give it a 5. It works in the opposite direction too, that's why I have some anime rated the same score, when in fact one is way worse than the other. Yes, and I'd be satisfied with that honestly, if the score wasn't 5,92. That explanation works for 7 or a bit above but at this score it's just unreasonable. I just can't put my finger on why they would rate a show they could not even form a proper opinion about a score that low. |
|
GangsterCat said: absolutely bad episode 1 I digged it though. Although I have an affinity to like shows with musical theme of some sorts. |
|
You said: Dishonest said: I guess theyre basing their scores on the first 6 episodes obviously. Id also suggest not taking MAL ratings too seriously since all members use it differently, like you for example: What? I never giving a stuff low score just to make the total rating down from top 100 or so. I give a score just the way I feel about it. On this site I rate this way yes, as for irl I might have a bit different opinion on the shows than I have here. So see: I'd might have given a score of 8 or 7 to the natsume series, I still never would be able to watch that horrible trainwreck again. It's just not to my taste. |
|
alcamoth said: I'm not sure honestly. Some thought it was boring and a waste of time but even still this show is definitely not 5.92 worthy. It's why I gave it a 10 for now to up the rating a little. I see you are a good guy, I was like that too. I gave 10 for shows I felt sorry for. Now it changed a bit though. As for this show I really like it so far and hope that the rating will bend in the firection of reality. |
|
| Well rating something low based on the scale of 10 feels good, try it... |
_Ako_ said: Well rating something low based on the scale of 10 feels good, try it... That's a guilty pleasure and I try to steer clear of it. It's like scratching one's balls. |
|
oryouohagi said: _Ako_ said: Well rating something low based on the scale of 10 feels good, try it... That's a guilty pleasure and I try to steer clear of it. It's like scratching one's balls. Scratching someone's balls is fine if you get to be paid. |
_Ako_ said: oryouohagi said: That's a guilty pleasure and I try to steer clear of it. It's like scratching one's balls. Scratching someone's balls is fine if you get to be paid. But do you get payed giving low scores? I doubt that you are an official critic. In that respect scratching your balls is more profiting. |
|
oryouohagi said: But do you get payed giving low scores? I doubt that you are an official critic. In that respect scratching your balls is more profiting. Lol... Is there a merit of being a critic to begin with? Nah, I'm dead tired of scratching my balls, been doing that since the day I know I have a balls... |
_Ako_ said: oryouohagi said: But do you get payed giving low scores? I doubt that you are an official critic. In that respect scratching your balls is more profiting. Lol... Is there a merit of being a critic to begin with? Nah, I'm dead tired of scratching my balls, been doing that since the day I know I have a balls... Well who knows. I'll continue scratching my balls and give high scores for shitty shows. |
|
oryouohagi said: _Ako_ said: Lol... Is there a merit of being a critic to begin with? Nah, I'm dead tired of scratching my balls, been doing that since the day I know I have a balls... Well who knows. I'll continue scratching my balls and give high scores for shitty shows. Well, if you do that, why bother asking? |
_Ako_ said: oryouohagi said: Well who knows. I'll continue scratching my balls and give high scores for shitty shows. Well, if you do that, why bother asking? True that fam, true that |
|
| This is proof that you shouldnt care about the scores (and MAL has shit taste too) |
DatRandomDudeNov 19, 2016 9:47 AM
STOP SLEEPING ON ODD TAXI |
| All depends on peoples opinions. Of the top 20 high-rated anime on mal, two of those I have rated at a 1/10. Personally, I'm enjoying how unpredictable ClassicaLoid is. It hasn't been the greatest anime yet, but I'm expecting my score of a 6 to raise to a 7 or 8 eventually. I have high hopes. |
 |
| I've only watched one episode but I don't think it deserves such a bad score |D I mean, Taboo Tattoo, one of the most horrendous anime I've ever watched in my entire life, has a higher score than this. And that show is just absolutely god awful 8V This one has good humor, and although it's pretty cheesy with its idea, I appreciate its originality and wackiness. hopefully it goes up to at least a 7 by the time it finishes. |
 |
| I was expecting this anime to be somewhere around 7 far from a masterpiece but 5.9 is a bit unfair and im not a real fan of mixing academix music with electronic but the new versions/remixes are unsane in a good sense, like the show |
MichaelJacksonJan 7, 2017 12:23 PM
| :v |
| I wouldn't worry about the score of the show at present. Shows with low scores in the initial airing tend to end up with a higher score later on. An example: Aku no Hana had an abysmal rating, either in the low 5.xx or even dipped below 5.00, when it aired in April 2013 and caused quite the controversy. It is now comfortably above a 7.00. ClassicaLoid has every chance of the rating increasing over time. "The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice." |
| I still haven't rated it yet, but for the first 11 episodes I leaned more towards a 6, because there was no actual plot progression (or just bits of it), just daily routines and goofing around, what probably should made us laugh, but I don't think I ever laughed out loud, just some little smiles or sometimes even just sighs. Ep 12 made it a bit better, some plot progression, but still nothing that would make watch the anime as soon as it comes out. While I do like some of the arrangements (Chopins Lullaby and Liszt arrangement from ep 4), most of them are just meh. The art is wacky, what fits this show, but somehow it tires me out. The characters are the worst. I still have to come across one that I might actually like. The classicaloids are in their own world (well most musicians are, if I compare them with my roommates, that study music to become musicians). Overall I'd rate it, for now, somewhere between 6 and 7.. |
 |
| I think Classicaloid is rating so low because it can get really weird and silly most of the time, seriously, Beethoven turned into a fish? |
More topics from this board
Poll: » ClassicaLoid Episode 3 DiscussionStark700 - Oct 22, 2016 |
26 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 24, 12:57 AM |
|
Poll: » ClassicaLoid Episode 2 DiscussionStark700 - Oct 15, 2016 |
33 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 24, 12:43 AM |
|
Poll: » ClassicaLoid Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Oct 8, 2016 |
63 |
by RGreatDanton
»»
May 23, 10:24 PM |
|
Poll: » ClassicaLoid Episode 25 DiscussionStark700 - Apr 1, 2017 |
20 |
by Yuyiiscool
»»
Mar 25, 2023 11:06 PM |
|
Poll: » ClassicaLoid Episode 24 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 25, 2017 |
9 |
by Yuyiiscool
»»
Mar 24, 2023 8:15 PM |