| Which member do u think has the saddest story or background, in my opinion I think that chopper, brooke & Robin have the saddest story's, it was a hard choice but I chose Chopper. |
ZatoichiAug 21, 2008 3:45 PM
| "Every man shall reap what he has sown, from the highest lord to the lowest gutter rat. And some will lose more than the tips off their fingers, I promise you. They have made my kingdom bleed, and I do not forget that" |
| I would say brook...He had to bury about half of his first nakama, he lost most of his body and his shadow, and he wondered on the sees all alone for over a decade. |
 |
| Robin and Chopper. I voted for Robin, cuz her story was a little more sad... |
| ONeoRa is always looking for interesting people to join our ranks. Visit our forum to apply: http://www.oneora.net  |
| Whoaaaa..... so hard.... Chopper, Robin, Nami, Brooke.... they all had so sad histories... But hmmmm.... I'm voting Robin, she never had any friends before strawhats and her whole island was massacred and all... |
| Robin's arc was more epic, and we know more there. So Robin! Everyone has had some sort of "Tragic Past", which was sad, at least, though. ;p |
 |
| Robin. She lost her mom, her homeland, became wanted at such a young age, had to survive in the Grand Line all by herself at such a young age, and I can really go on and on. |
| Franky's and Chopper's stories were really sad to me. |
| Well, for dramatic impact I would say Robin, because of the way it was told to us, and for her being so young when everything happened. However, I vote for Brook, simply because I would rather go through everything on Robin's past than Brook's (spending 40+ years alone, not being able to see the sun, burying all your friends, etc). |
| I agree with most people here and say that the saddest story is Robin's as she was so young and her whole island was destroyed but Brook is pretty sad aswell. |
 |
| Chopper or Nami. In the end I choosed Chopper. |
 |
| I have to say that Robin's past is the saddest. 20 years of trying to find out who you really are and your family and friends died because of something so trivial is so tragic. 2nd, Chopper's past is sad too. Being part deer and part human can be something hard to live as. Poor chopper, he wasn't accept by both his kin until he met a doctor. C: |
| Nami has the saddest and Sanji the most horrible |
| Instagram: Luzifurr |
| they all got a hell of a past (dunno about luffy though, just that when shank's saved him) But Robins suffers a lot and longer than the rest of them... |
 Long Leb!!! |
| Luffy: always had a goal, never got depressed. He might have gone through a hard time but never took it the wrong way. Instead thought he was learning from that. Zoro: possible but he was living out his life how he wanted to. He did lose his childhood friend but he lived to do what he promiced so wasn't that bad for him. Nami: Could be hard but she faught for her people. Usopp: pathetic past. Sanji: found a place for him even though he went through a hard time. Chopper: he atleast had someone who took him in. His first firend did die but he found someone else. Robin: The worst past. Never found anyone till the strawhats. Was always betraying and being betrayed.. Franky: found friends who accepted him. Brooke: possible. he had to live by himself for such a long time but didn't seem like he was totally sad. |
 |
Turbe said: Luffy: always had a goal, never got depressed. He might have gone through a hard time but never took it the wrong way. Instead thought he was learning from that. Zoro: possible but he was living out his life how he wanted to. He did lose his childhood friend but he lived to do what he promiced so wasn't that bad for him. Nami: Could be hard but she faught for her people. Usopp: pathetic past. Sanji: found a place for him even though he went through a hard time. Chopper: he atleast had someone who took him in. His first firend did die but he found someone else. Robin: The worst past. Never found anyone till the strawhats. Was always betraying and being betrayed.. Franky: found friends who accepted him. Brooke: possible. he had to live by himself for such a long time but didn't seem like he was totally sad. I totally agree with all your statements, chopper's own familly abandoned him!! that's very sad too, the same with robin (20 years of traveling alone on strangers ships) & about brooke, i think he was more sad about not being able to keep his promise to the whale. |
| "Every man shall reap what he has sown, from the highest lord to the lowest gutter rat. And some will lose more than the tips off their fingers, I promise you. They have made my kingdom bleed, and I do not forget that" |
| Brooke is the only one I can't think of how he feels. He was left along for a long time and did have that promice but didn't seem like he gave up on life, like robin. He almost seemed like he was always laughing it off so its hard to think of how he really felt, plus its been awhile since I saw/read his arc.. |
| |
| I voted for Nami. Partially because everyone else seems to be voting for Robin... and partially because, dang, she was orphaned twice. And the second time, her "mother" was killed right in front of her, and then she had to work for the guy that did it. I dunno, if someone killed my parents, I... probably wouldn't want to help them further their career as a rutheless tyrant. |
| Hmm, well it would have to be between Nami and Robin for me. It's really hard but I think I'll have to go with Robin on this one. |
    |
| I think Luffy has the saddest story because I just figured out what happened to his mom. She died when Luffy was very young and Luffy was alone after Ace left the island and before Luffy left. Imagine being alone for most of your life. I can cause I was. |
| If I'm crying at your funeral, then I'm laughing too hard. If you're crying at my funeral, then you're dead. 92% of teens have moved on to rap. If you are part of the 8% who still listens to real music, copy and paste this into your signature.... If Abercrombie & Fitch said it wasn't cool to breathe anymore, the majority of the teenage population would die. If you are the other 2% laughing your asses off, copy and paste this into your signature... |
| In persepctive chopper has the saddest story since his own kind didn't even want him, where robin had people yet they all died. |
    |
76ers-kid said: In persepctive chopper has the saddest story since his own kind didn't even want him, where robin had people yet they all died. everyone that robin had only wanted to use her and not actually be with her. She also had to use the people she was around. Chopper on the other hand had that doctor take him in, although everything is how you see it so you can't really convince someone is "worse" off. |
| |
| Nami, Chopper, Robin, and Brook had the saddest stories, but I voted Chopper. It's the only past that actually made me cry ;__; |
 |
| Robin. Because everyone else had at least one person who he/she can trust. But Robin was all alone so many years and she was ready to give up living after losing the hope of finding Rio Poneglyph. |
 |
| Robin! I love her 'Are you my mommy?' line.. ^^ also... the day that she finally met her mother is also the day that she saw her die, what a happy way to celebrate your birthday... T_T (I kinda forgot if that day is her birthday or it happened days after... Hehe) And as the other guys who voted her said, she got no one to trust because of the bounty on her head.. well, before the Straw Hats atleast. |
     |
Henna said: Robin. Because everyone else had at least one person who he/she can trust. But Robin was all alone so many years and she was ready to give up living after losing the hope of finding Rio Poneglyph. I totally agree. But the authors had probably their fun, bringing havoc upon her biography.. |
 |
| Choppers the one that made me cry a little................................................ |
| Chopper. I ain't gonna lie, I cried like a little girl getting ass raped. Brooks was sad too, I cried a little. |
| Nami |
| Robin. ^^ Her story and the CP9 saga was just so great. :D |
| Play Quizzes at Fun Trivia ! ^^ Join me now! --------------------------------------------------------------------  -------------------------------------------------------------------- <a href="http://go.digsby.com"><img src="http://www.digsby.com/affiliate/banners/smallbanner2-468x60.jpg"; /></a> |
| Robin. she has nobody. everyone she came close to died and she was constantly being betrayed as a kid. When they do the hometown reflections no one misses her. I don't see how anyone else comes close. Even brook has Laboon and Chopper has Dr. Kurea. I think Nami would come in second though. She had a tough life having to serve the guy who killed her mother. She never even had any real parents and she doesn't even have a last name. |
 |
| Going Merry should have won this poll if included! LOL. But seriously, |
|
| Well i think both Nami and Robin had sad childhoods. Nami's [foster] mother was killed right in front of her eyes..How terrorizing can that be.. But my vote still went to Robin..She had to see her hometown [with her family,mom,loved ones] die in the terrible flames at a very young age..After which she had to put up with living alone and not being able to trust anyone. She's an amazingly strong character. |
 |
MugiwaraSilver said: I voted for Nami. Partially because everyone else seems to be voting for Robin... and partially because, dang, she was orphaned twice. And the second time, her "mother" was killed right in front of her, and then she had to work for the guy that did it. I dunno, if someone killed my parents, I... probably wouldn't want to help them further their career as a rutheless tyrant. so damn quote. Nami has the saddest past... She sacrificated herself for her village.. She is strong for livin' and workin' with the same person that killed her 'adoptive' mother.. all this for her town.. So, nami. Gettin' hits and run away it's 'easy', but its less easy 'living with the problems and trying to fight them'.. so~ Robin had a sad past too, but Nami most. She fighted.. >_< for this reason i like nami so much. she's great! |
    |
EtnaEraclea said: Gettin' hits and run away it's 'easy', but its less easy 'living with the problems and trying to fight them'.. so~ Robin had a sad past too, but Nami most. She fighted.. >_< for this reason i like nami so much. she's great! What the f*ck are you talking about? o_O Facing her problems? Robin was a little girl, for God's sake! Ok, so was Nami, but wait... what exactly happened to her? Hmm.. let me think: Her mother was killed because she didn't have enough money to pay Arlong for not killing her.... Right before Nami's eyes... Sad, indeed. But what then? She had entire village somehow looking out for her and her sister. She "chose" to work for Arlong hoping that she can buy off her village... Yeah, she was strong - she lost one person after all. And then what happened to Robin? I can't really recall... or wait! I can: World Government decided that people, who can read Poneglyphs are to be killed... So they send Marines' battleships to annihilate her island... Robin's mother was killed right before her eyes too. The difference? Her mother wasn't the only one who died then - the library, the only place she thought "home" of was burned, all her friends had to stay on the island, waiting for their deaths... What about the rest of islanders? They were allowed to evacuate. But guess what? No a single one of them was Robin's friend whatsoever - all the kids called her a monster. And the only person who wanted to help her escape, her new friend, Saul, was killed by Aokiji, who let her go after that, because if he didn't he would hurt his pride... So let me summarize: Nami: 1. Mother's death. 2. Working for her mother's killer, so she is able to buy her village off of him, while villagers pretended to hate her (because she was working for him). And then Robin: 1. Mother's death, as well as all the people's she ever loved and respected. 2. Her island disappearing from the surface of the planet. 3. being forced to leave, having no place to go, no money, no prospects, etc. Yeah, I suppose you're right - Nami's story is so much worse than Robin's. And yes, Robin certainly could have had stay and fight an Marine Admiral with a fleet in tow. (no sarcasm at all...) ~~ Personally, I don't give a damn about who's past was the saddest in your opinion. But if you say that Robin didn't fight, then it's totally different case. |
Gradonil_RalApr 12, 2009 10:05 AM
| ONeoRa is always looking for interesting people to join our ranks. Visit our forum to apply: http://www.oneora.net |
| Well maybe i express myself wrong.. sorry if i did.. i get what u mean and u are right, robin had a really sad past too.. the stupid kids that called her monster, the few ppl that really she loved all get killed and the whole island deleted from the world's face.. [personally i criyed (like a lot of one piece's fan i believe~) when at enies lobby she said something like 'if i really can, then i want to live'..] Anyway i was meaning the sacrifice part..ok u say that was a nami's choice..but well it's also true that the other alternatives [like doing nothing] she had weren't so good at all.. and in the sacrifice part of her story she had to go into a pirate's ship to another one, just to stealing from them.. and this, as a little kid and then young woman, was kinda dangerous.. and yeah, always speaking about sacrifice, all her village was there to hate her (at least in front of her eyes) and despise her.. instead with the fight part, yea..its also true that the little robin as a kid of course cannot face a big enemy like world government, but with a kid's eyes (i mean, when u are a kid u have no strenght so) even a 'stupid fish' like arlong could appear a 'big enemy.. anyway as i said in my previous post, yeah i think robin's past is really sad but i think nami's is most sad.. b'cuz of the sacrifice and fight part.. >< anyway, happy easter (in late)~ |
|
EtnaEraclea said: instead with the fight part, yea..its also true that the little robin as a kid of course cannot face a big enemy like world government, but with a kid's eyes (i mean, when u are a kid u have no strenght so) even a 'stupid fish' like arlong could appear a 'big enemy.. Well, if I recall correctly Nami didn't "fight" Arlong - she was really scared of him. She chose to work for him so she could pay him to leave her village... Yes, we can call it "facing" Arlong. And I do give her a credit for that, but the difference is that she had a opportunity to fight him (her way, of course). Robin didn't - it's not like if she got enough money then her island would appear again. (and even if it would, there wouldn't be anyone there who cares for Robin) So my point is: Nami did "fight" Arlong, that's true, but she had a chance to. Robin didn't have one and she had no one she could sacrifice herself for. Anyways, I get your point (I don't agree, but I get it) and I hope you get mine. Let's end it this way, either way we could argue and argue, for all the eternity ;p (well, probably not that long, but it sounds better this way xd) //Happy easter to you too :P |
| ONeoRa is always looking for interesting people to join our ranks. Visit our forum to apply: http://www.oneora.net |
Monkey_D_Keroro said: Choppers the one that made me cry a little................................................ I agree cried my little face off at choppers and also Robins |
| Brooks past was very sad *_* made me cry a little) although everybody has a sad past. |
| The only ones that can compete about having the sadest pasts is Robin an Brooke. Luffys past we don't really know much about, other than that he gets traumatized thinking about it and that his grandpa was though on him. Still he probabilly can't compete with Robin and brookes past. |
In Oda we trust. |
| Brook is the saddest by far in my opinion, spending all that time alone on the ship where your crew died is just sad, robin is the runner up though |
| Definetly Robin.. her story could make even a golem cry. That is also one of the main reasons the enies lobby arc rocked. Brook and Nami went through a lot to. The others have nasty stories to, but they still menaged somehow better then those 3. |
| Robin definetly Brook and Nami did have pretty bad pasts as well but Robins was definetly the worst |
Gradonil_Ral said: Robin and Chopper. I voted for Robin, cuz her story was a little more sad... I agree |
| Its really hard to choose between Robin and Brooke.... But i think Robin have the saddest story |
eliyav said: Brook is the saddest by far in my opinion, spending all that time alone on the ship where your crew died is just sad, robin is the runner up though +1 on this Robin saw everyone die before her eyes and had to constantly run away for her life since the marines kept on chasing her. |
 |
![http://myanimelist.net/signature/RaijinKiba.png"](http://myanimelist.net/signature/RaijinKiba.png"){kind=link}
| Brooke for me, as he loved his nakama a lot and he actually had to bury the one's he loved and be alone on that ship, also often dreaming about them shows he really missed them a lot. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Your Favourite Strawhat Pirate ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Azuriel - Dec 3, 2007 |
269 |
by D_1_0
»»
Aug 28, 7:55 AM |
|
» Arc with the best Outfits? :)cannibalsushii - Jun 14, 2023 |
1 |
by softpillow
»»
Jun 17, 2023 11:35 AM |
|
» changing Monkey D. Luffy's picturesoftpillow - Nov 15, 2022 |
3 |
by softpillow
»»
Jun 17, 2023 11:30 AM |
|
» Princess Vivihal02god - Apr 9, 2010 |
12 |
by Vexez5102
»»
Aug 15, 2021 11:31 AM |
|
» Your favorite OP villain/opponent? ( 1 2 )Silberkralle - Aug 21, 2008 |
65 |
by someone-aru
»»
Jul 18, 2021 4:10 PM |