M_A said: Rise rise rise KnK 5. Fall fall fall TTGL. corrected... |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Ketuekigami said: M_A said: Rise rise rise LOGH. Fall fall fall TTGL. corrected... :D |
| here is the list of douches that gave this movie a 1: 1502 twd452 1 Plan to Watch -/1 1503 ArrancarNelTu 1 Dropped -/1 1504 Iudicium 1 Completed 1/1 1505 AtticusSP 1 Dropped 1/1 1506 Fareplay 1 Completed 1/1 1507 VanMartin 1 Plan to Watch 1/1 1508 ceapy 1 Plan to Watch -/1 1509 dustbunny2230 1 Completed 1/1 1510 goral 1 Dropped 1/1 1511 rosarioisvamp 1 Completed 1/1 1512 nyannyanroll 1 Completed 1/1 1513 Sausage_Mahoney 1 Completed 1/1 1514 countfenring18 1 Completed 1/1 1515 keviceaia 1 Completed 1/1 1516 Jagger 1 Completed 1/1 |
M_A said: Rise rise rise LOGH. Fall fall fall KNK5. I can't believe that none of the KnK fans used the "You fall!" quote from the first movie on this. For that, KnK5 deserves to fall. |
| Its only a matter of time till Gurren Lagann is up at the top again. This is already down .2 since when it first got up there. |
  |
Viperslayer said: Its only a matter of time till Gurren Lagann is up at the top again. This is already down .2 since when it first got up there. and the only reason for that will be for the increasing trolls giving KnK 5 a 1. each time it goes up to .04 a new 1 pops up and it gets pushed back down. but be sure that if it suddenly drops it can only be by a large amount at once and then we got a problem (Berserk all over again?) -_-' and im dumbfounded on this? can you please explain how someone who hasn't even seen KnK 5 (you for instance) will assume that it will drop below below TTGL? can you honestly say it deserves to be lower if you haven't seen it??? i cant seem to understand, but maybe that's because i can use common sense. naikou said: M_A said: Rise rise rise LOGH. Fall fall fall KNK5. I can't believe that none of the KnK fans used the "You fall!" quote from the first movie on this. For that, KnK5 deserves to fall. well i dont wanna dis LOGH... but fine fine, you fail... naikou =3 jk jk |
KetuekigamiFeb 19, 2009 3:41 PM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I think this thread needs to be deleted now and remade. It's broken. |
| yay! no more TTGL 1st place, cant belive they made TTGL be 1st place >_> gonna give this a 10/10 just to keep TTGL down, that stupid overrated trash |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| Yeah, this thread is definitely broken. |
 |
| ...eh, I gave both TTGL and KnK5 10's. |
    There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection |
| Thread fixed |
 |
Peralisc said: yay! no more TTGL 1st place, cant belive they made TTGL be 1st place >_> gonna give this a 10/10 just to keep TTGL down, that stupid overrated trash no one "made" it #1. it happened because TTGL is just an overall likable series and will naturally get high scores... now whether or not its overrated is another story. I personally believe a few of the top list is overrated but i wont say they dont deserve any credit (exception being R2 >__>). But dont mark KnK unless you see it. If you do your just as bad as the trolls who marked it 1. But after all why not watch KnK? i mean isnt the nature of the top list to show what is good and what you would probably enjoy? if so then isnt it natural to watch something that shoots up to #1? Kyora said: ...eh, I gave both TTGL and KnK5 10's. lol aero said: Thread fixed YAY!~ i missed this thread~ |
KetuekigamiMar 9, 2009 1:10 AM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Peralisc said: yay! no more TTGL 1st place, cant belive they made TTGL be 1st place >_> gonna give this a 10/10 just to keep TTGL down, that stupid overrated trash Quit trolling. If you're serious then you are a dumbass for rating something after only seeing 2 episodes. |
Peralisc said: yay! no more TTGL 1st place, cant belive they made TTGL be 1st place >_> gonna give this a 10/10 just to keep TTGL down, that stupid overrated trash I agree that ttgl is overrated, and that knk5 deserves the top spot more but take the drunk ttgl fanboy's advice and don't troll. It'll make the knk fans look as bad as the ttgl fans. |
      |
Ketuekigami said: Kyora said: ...eh, I gave both TTGL and KnK5 10's. lol W-what? D: I feel like part of the minority who enjoyed both. >_>; TBH, I don't really care which of the two are first on MAL since I loved both for different reasons. |
There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection |
dxthegreat said: Peralisc said: yay! no more TTGL 1st place, cant belive they made TTGL be 1st place >_> gonna give this a 10/10 just to keep TTGL down, that stupid overrated trash I agree that ttgl is overrated, and that knk5 deserves the top spot more but take the drunk ttgl fanboy's advice and don't troll. It'll make the knk fans look as bad as the ttgl fans. Aren't they already? I would say TTGL does what it tries to do better than KNK does. KNK seems like it tries to be more intellectual and complex, but really it isn't. TTGL was always just semi-mindless ridiculous action, and it does that perfectly. I kind of shock myself by the fact that i actually bothered comparing KNK and TTGL. I feel silly, but i guess that's what boredom does to you. |
Kyora said: Ketuekigami said: Kyora said: ...eh, I gave both TTGL and KnK5 10's. lol W-what? D: I feel like part of the minority who enjoyed both. >_>; TBH, I don't really care which of the two are first on MAL since I loved both for different reasons. dont get me wrong, i loved TTGL as well... but to a far lesser extent... and considering the extent i loved KnK 5 i could say that TTGL is an outstanding series =3 M_A said: Aren't they already? once the fans start creating dup accounts to push up KnK5s rating then they are... but until then thier not. M_A said: I would say TTGL does what it tries to do better than KNK does. KNK seems like it tries to be more intellectual and complex, but really it isn't. TTGL was always just semi-mindless ridiculous action, and it does that perfectly. I kind of shock myself by the fact that i actually bothered comparing KNK and TTGL. I feel silly, but i guess that's what boredom does to you. I respect your opinion but i highly disagree. i believe they both do what they intend to do very well. on that note. KnK only tries to be intellectual in the context of its own world, it may not seem like it does it well if you try to stay in the boundaries of reality but if you put yourself in its fictional world then it seems very complex and intelligent. |
KetuekigamiMar 9, 2009 1:36 AM
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| First of all calm down drunk_samurai, nobody is trying to hurt your shows. I must correct your point of view kido, that show was just unberable to continue watching it, thats why i dropped it. No need to waste more time on something i cant stand. I was honest when i rated TTGL. Hope now you can sleep at night and watch your language, those words are a bit too big for a 12 year old. ;) But dont mark KnK unless you see it. If you do your just as bad as the trolls who marked it 1. But after all why not watch KnK? i mean isnt the nature of the top list to show what is good and what you would probably enjoy? if so then isnt it natural to watch something that shoots up to #1? Its on my watching list for days now, but didnt have time watch it, in case thats your only concern. The top mostly lists some of the excessively overrated animes. I would probably try to dodge KnK 5 aswell and only watch it when i have no idea what else to watch, but i seen already and liked (more or less) the first 4 movies. You could check the list next time, before telling someone what to do. :/ |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Peralisc said: First of all calm down drunk_samurai, nobody is trying to hurt your shows. I must correct your point of view kido, that show was just unberable to continue watching it, thats why i dropped it. No need to waste more time on something i cant stand. I was honest when i rated TTGL. Hope now you can sleep at night and watch your language, those words are a bit too big for a 12 year old. ;) But dont mark KnK unless you see it. If you do your just as bad as the trolls who marked it 1. But after all why not watch KnK? i mean isnt the nature of the top list to show what is good and what you would probably enjoy? if so then isnt it natural to watch something that shoots up to #1? Its on my watching list for days now, but didnt have time watch it, in case thats your only concern. The top mostly lists some of the excessively overrated animes. I would probably try to dodge KnK 5 aswell and only watch it when i have no idea what else to watch, but i seen already and liked (more or less) the first 4 movies. You could check the list next time, before telling someone what to do. :/ Right. The funny thing is you actually think I'm 12. 2 episodes is not enough to judge something. Only morons do that. You are immature for even thinking about rating it a 10 just to make it have a higher score than something you don't like. |
| First off... where in that quote did i say you didn't watch the previous 4? dude, im not telling you what to do, i just made a statement about the nature of the top list. and why must i check you list if im making a statement that's not implying that you've never seen the previous 4 or not? But on another note, you're post made it sound very much like you're just trolling hate for TTGL with no comment of the quality of KnK. Its only natural to think that you came into this thread just talk about TTGL vs KnK on the top list without having seen one. with all the people who actually went out of there way to try to troll KnK with 1s it doesn't help you when you come into a thread saying your going to give something a 10 because you hate the other. I never implied that you've never seen KnK 1-4... but your post certainly made it sound like you haven't. with that said im out, im tired of arguing with people who are so defensive that they take everything as an insult. it happens way to much for me to care anymore. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
The funny thing is you actually think I'm 12. Your attitude, language and behavior are those of a 12 year old. I never implied that you've never seen KnK 1-4... but your post certainly made it sound like you haven't. Then dont take it so personaly and do like i said. Check the list to make sure you didnt missunderstand it. Thats all i wanted you to do. You took it a bit too serious and also missunderstood the post. Keep it up and you can be proud owner of grey->white hair, while you are still young, whitout dying it. :P |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| I gave both a 9/10 thread fixed? D: |
Peralisc said: <div style="text-align: center; font-size: 12px; font-family: Verdana, Arial;"><img src="http://cdn.myanimelist.net/images/maintenance.png"> <br /> 10:10am: Bringing the server back online shortly. Still not entirely sure what happened to kill the mysql service. <br /><br /> 9:45am: Looks like the MySQL service crashed. Impending doom? Hmm, making backups just incase. <br /><br /> 9:35am: Trying to figure out what the hell just happened. Will keep everyone updated as I find out things too. -Xinil/Garrett </div> Your attitude of giving something a 10 just because you don't like something proves you are most likely the 12 year old. Language doesn't make somebody 12. |
| Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? |
Medeasenpai said: Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? Apparently yes. :P Well of course you aren't the only one; two posts above you there's another person who enjoyed both. And I enjoyed watching both KnK and TTGL as well. |
 Felli disapproves of this thread. |
Medeasenpai said: Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? I did too :O ... just one to a much greater extent then the other =3 |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Medeasenpai said: Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? Well, I gave both 10/10 :P I did enjoy KnK 5 more than TTGL, but as a "series," I think TTGL averages as slightly more enjoyable. TTGL was just fun to watch because it was so ridiculous. I didn't have to think about reality when I watched it. |
Medeasenpai said: I liked them both a LOT. Gave them both 10/10. Although TTGL is still a lot better in my opinion and probably deserves like a 12/10 or something if that would be possible.Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? |
|
Medeasenpai said: Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? Nope Kyora said: ...eh, I gave both TTGL and KnK5 10's. |
There is nothing in this world more ugly than imperfection |
5layer said: Medeasenpai said: I liked them both a LOT. Gave them both 10/10. Although TTGL is still a lot better in my opinion and probably deserves like a 12/10 or something if that would be possible.Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? That just means you rate too high. If you give 10s out like free candy, of course you're gonna run out of high ratings to give to better shows. 12/10? lawl no. You should try using some 1s, 2s, 3s or (more) 4s before suggesting that |
|
| I also liked both KnK (#5, anyway) and TTGL, but there's a 4 point gap between the two. |
dxthegreat said: 5layer said: Medeasenpai said: I liked them both a LOT. Gave them both 10/10. Although TTGL is still a lot better in my opinion and probably deserves like a 12/10 or something if that would be possible.Am I the only one who enjoyed both KnK and TTGL? That just means you rate too high. If you give 10s out like free candy, of course you're gonna run out of high ratings to give to better shows. 12/10? lawl no. You should try using some 1s, 2s, 3s or (more) 4s before suggesting that If my TTGL moves from 12/10 to 10/10, that would cause ALL my other 10s to drop to an 8 which I wouldn't do. It's an outlier obviously. |
|
| Imo, Gurren-Lagann is overrated. I gave it an 8/10 because I thought it was very good, but nothing more. KnK:5, on the otherhand, was pretty darn mind blowing. It actually made me think in a way that only reallly good series allow me to do. I gave it a 9~ |
 |
Drengot said: Its been almost 2 months and KnK is still #1. I guess its going to stay #1 for the rest of the year unless some anime this summer or fall beats it. sup, FMA remake and Haruhi 2 |
naikou said: Drengot said: Its been almost 2 months and KnK is still #1. I guess its going to stay #1 for the rest of the year unless some anime this summer or fall beats it. sup, FMA remake and Haruhi 2 Not sure if these can make #1. FMA is a remake, so it'll take a while for watchers of the previous one to like it (that is, once it gets to the new scenes). Haruhi may have a huge fanbase, but KyoAni trolling combined with Haruhi haters makes it difficult to score over a 9. Also remember that one of the reasons why KnK 5 is way up there is because most of the people who got this far like KnK in general for one reason or another. Haruhi2/FMA2 are sure to have more universal viewership and more overall "low" scores. |
5layer said: It's an outlier obviously. 10's are supposed to be outliers. That's why 10 is called "Masterpiece," 9 is called "Great," and 8 is called "Very Good." 8 is not a bad score. There should only be a few things you can call a masterpiece, but there are a lot you can call great or very good. |
meonlyme775 said: naikou said: Drengot said: Its been almost 2 months and KnK is still #1. I guess its going to stay #1 for the rest of the year unless some anime this summer or fall beats it. sup, FMA remake and Haruhi 2 Not sure if these can make #1. FMA is a remake, so it'll take a while for watchers of the previous one to like it (that is, once it gets to the new scenes). Haruhi may have a huge fanbase, but KyoAni trolling combined with Haruhi haters makes it difficult to score over a 9. Also remember that one of the reasons why KnK 5 is way up there is because most of the people who got this far like KnK in general for one reason or another. Haruhi2/FMA2 are sure to have more universal viewership and more overall "low" scores. True, it's not a guarantee that they'll hit the top, but I'd bet money that they'll both be in the top 10. Haruhi may be the target of a lot of hate, but the amount of love it gets is far more overwhelming (it's just that the haters are very vocal about their hatred). It's still rated number 33, and sequels are almost always significantly higher than their predecessors, regardless of actual quality (see Code Geass R2, and Higurashi Kai). Also, the material which the second series is going based on (The Disappearance of Haruhi Suzumiya) is better than the original source material - at least, that's what fans of the series say. In other words, if Kyoani doesn't go completely crazy and totally fuck things up, Haruhi 2 is going to make some big waves. FMA has even more potential. Everyone, save for a select few like myself, loved FMA. A few people gave it decent ratings instead of 10/10 because it didn't follow the manga. Well, the remake is going to follow the manga. With the first season of FMA sitting pretty at #18, the remake will almost certainly hit the top slot - again, as long as the producers don't totally fuck it up. It's just a question of how long it will stay there. |
dio_brando86 said: There's more than 1 masterpiece anime in this world so I ain't gonna be giving other masterpiece anime low scores just cause an outlier beyond that exists.5layer said: It's an outlier obviously. 10's are supposed to be outliers. That's why 10 is called "Masterpiece," 9 is called "Great," and 8 is called "Very Good." 8 is not a bad score. There should only be a few things you can call a masterpiece, but there are a lot you can call great or very good. |
|
5layer said: dio_brando86 said: There's more than 1 masterpiece anime in this world so I ain't gonna be giving other masterpiece anime low scores just cause an outlier beyond that exists.5layer said: It's an outlier obviously. 10's are supposed to be outliers. That's why 10 is called "Masterpiece," 9 is called "Great," and 8 is called "Very Good." 8 is not a bad score. There should only be a few things you can call a masterpiece, but there are a lot you can call great or very good. sure, if you insist then there ain't only 1 masterpiece in the world (though i don't think anything deserves the title "perfection" yet). But u rated 35 of the 120 or so titles u've seen 10s... tbh, i would give someone who says there is only 1 masterpiece in the world more credit than someone who gives 25% of all anime he sees a 10. if you give gurren lagaan 10.. u have to downrate everything else? so what? whats most important in appreciating an anime is differentiating it from the rest, not give a 10 which more than one quarter of the anime you've seen already has. |
|
| ^ Its a matter of choice really. I prefer to rate according to my style and yeah, I pretty much agree with you that one should only have a few 10s in a list. My list that have a 6-7 are consider good series and 8-9 are consider great while others might see 6-7 as 'bad'. I guess its just depends on the individuals. For me, its not a good way to rate with straight rating like - GOOD -> 10, BAD ->1 etc PS: oh btw just checked your list, you are stricter in term of rating than me, lol |
   |
| I've only given 10/10 to shows that I liked so much that I just cannot get tired of them no matter no many times I rewatch them. I dont give them often either...I only have given four 10/10 ever :P Oh and I expect Haruhi S2 to be better because as previously said...novel 4 which is the base of the second season is probably the best novel of all the series, much like this movie was imo the best of the KnK movies |
| I don't think I'll ever watch an anime that I would call a masterpiece. |
dxthegreat said: I rate by enjoyment which means I'm not gonna be an ass and downrate anime I super enjoyed just because it may be worse than TTGL hence why I have many 10s. The 10s are my enjoyment of the anime at the time I watched it and they aren't gonna get moderated by me just cause something amazing comes along.5layer said: dio_brando86 said: There's more than 1 masterpiece anime in this world so I ain't gonna be giving other masterpiece anime low scores just cause an outlier beyond that exists.5layer said: It's an outlier obviously. 10's are supposed to be outliers. That's why 10 is called "Masterpiece," 9 is called "Great," and 8 is called "Very Good." 8 is not a bad score. There should only be a few things you can call a masterpiece, but there are a lot you can call great or very good. sure, if you insist then there ain't only 1 masterpiece in the world (though i don't think anything deserves the title "perfection" yet). But u rated 35 of the 120 or so titles u've seen 10s... tbh, i would give someone who says there is only 1 masterpiece in the world more credit than someone who gives 25% of all anime he sees a 10. if you give gurren lagaan 10.. u have to downrate everything else? so what? whats most important in appreciating an anime is differentiating it from the rest, not give a 10 which more than one quarter of the anime you've seen already has. |
|
M_A said: How one rates shows is their own business, really. I rate by enjoyment too. If i had to rate shows for a publication or something, and had to give scores based on artistic merit and directing (which is how i judge actual films), i'm sure i would half most of my scores. Same here. And that would make my average rating for anime a 2 or 3... Although I don't rate purely by enjoyment, it does play a big role in my rating system. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Kara no Kyoukai 5: Mujun Rasen Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )dtshyk - Aug 22, 2008 |
511 |
by Stormen
»»
Sep 28, 8:48 PM |
|
» Which city inspires Mifune CITY?RyogiSHIKI7 - Jul 1 |
5 |
by RyogiSHIKI7
»»
Jul 1, 12:45 PM |
|
» best plot twist in anime history?sabervergarden - Feb 12, 2021 |
11 |
by sudhanshu_hbk
»»
May 11, 8:27 AM |
|
» why peaple gave this episode low rate to be lower than it deserve? this episode is masterpieceRCvvvv - Sep 17, 2022 |
17 |
by Phloup
»»
Sep 17, 2022 4:03 PM |
|
Poll: » which is the best ost from ufotabledixoncider8142 - Feb 4, 2022 |
6 |
by JJxy
»»
Mar 29, 2022 5:58 AM |