Plunderer
LemonadeSamurai said: The whole concept was interesting at first, every human has a count and that count goes up or down depending on their lives and what they do And when it reaches 0 they're dragged into a mysterious place called the abyss. Then they start going the Fairy Tail route.. With This had SO much potential but it was ruined when they started that nonsense. The I lost all interest when a GODDAMN I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a The main character was really cool and the humor was top notch! But the Madoka Box/Fairy Tail type plot twist just ruined it all. How is your opinion relevant? The creators told the story they wanted to tell. If you disliked it, fine, that’s your choice. But expecting creators to tell your own story is just being spoiled and unrealistic. |
Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.  |
| Shame on you, Fairy Tail is far better than this trash. |
 |
Reply to ejleon
LemonadeSamurai said:
The whole concept was interesting at first, every human has a count and that count goes up or down depending on their lives and what they do
And when it reaches 0 they're dragged into a mysterious place called the abyss.
Then they start going the Fairy Tail route..
With
This had SO much potential but it was ruined when they started that nonsense. The
I lost all interest when a GODDAMN
I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a
The main character was really cool and the humor was top notch! But the Madoka Box/Fairy Tail type plot twist just ruined it all.
The whole concept was interesting at first, every human has a count and that count goes up or down depending on their lives and what they do
And when it reaches 0 they're dragged into a mysterious place called the abyss.
Then they start going the Fairy Tail route..
With
This had SO much potential but it was ruined when they started that nonsense. The
I lost all interest when a GODDAMN
I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a
The main character was really cool and the humor was top notch! But the Madoka Box/Fairy Tail type plot twist just ruined it all.
How is your opinion relevant?
The creators told the story they wanted to tell.
If you disliked it, fine, that’s your choice.
But expecting creators to tell your own story is just being spoiled and unrealistic.
| @ejleon Bro wtf is tis reply? He gave his opinion and thoughts on what he though was a garbage show. He didn't what the author to tell the story how he wanted, he just wanted it to be good. |
|
Reply to Akuya
@ejleon
Bro wtf is tis reply?
He gave his opinion and thoughts on what he though was a garbage show. He didn't what the author to tell the story how he wanted, he just wanted it to be good.
Bro wtf is tis reply?
He gave his opinion and thoughts on what he though was a garbage show. He didn't what the author to tell the story how he wanted, he just wanted it to be good.
| @Akuyatsun Re-read the first comment, you obvious didn’t follow the words. LemonadeSamurai said: I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a realistic war isekai? How in the world are the creators to know what someone else wants for their own story? They can’t know and don’t know, they are telling the story they want to write, there is nothing wrong with that. I already stated, if the OP didn’t like it, fine, that’s their choice, and they can list reasons why they didn’t like the anime. But saying they don’t like it because it’s not how they would have written it, this is not a valid complaint. Therefore, their complaint is illogical and irrelevant. |
| Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
| An author can absolutely know what other people would want in a story. That’s called being a good writer. Nobody would ever read or watch something that didn’t appeal to them, an no author would publish a book they didn’t think anyone would read. If you want to write a story for yourself that’s one thing. If it’s just for you than it doesn’t matter what other people think. But if your publishing it for the word to read, what good author wouldn’t think about their audience? Not saying that an author has to meet every single need of some random guy on the mal forums of course not. But any good author should know who their target audience is, and how to appeal to them. |
|
Reply to Yeshaiah2015yesh
ejleon said:
@Akuyatsun
Re-read the first comment, you obvious didn’t follow the words.
How in the world are the creators to know what someone else wants for their own story?
They can’t know and don’t know, they are telling the story they want to write, there is nothing wrong with that.
I already stated, if the OP didn’t like it, fine, that’s their choice, and they can list reasons why they didn’t like the anime.
But saying they don’t like it because it’s not how they would have written it, this is not a valid complaint.
Therefore, their complaint is illogical and irrelevant.
@Akuyatsun
Re-read the first comment, you obvious didn’t follow the words.
LemonadeSamurai said:
I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a realistic war isekai?
I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a realistic war isekai?
How in the world are the creators to know what someone else wants for their own story?
They can’t know and don’t know, they are telling the story they want to write, there is nothing wrong with that.
I already stated, if the OP didn’t like it, fine, that’s their choice, and they can list reasons why they didn’t like the anime.
But saying they don’t like it because it’s not how they would have written it, this is not a valid complaint.
Therefore, their complaint is illogical and irrelevant.
bro your over thinking, I've read the comments, he never said he wanted the author to write the way he wanted. he was just expressing his discontent of the way the author chose write the show.
bro seriously you should stop over thinking and speculating things on impulse
| @Yeshaiah2015yesh Pathetically Lame attempt to discredit my words. I read his actual words, which does not take much thinking. I already said they could express dissatisfaction with the show. But complaining that the writer should have made the story how they thought it should go, is illogical and irrelevant. I’m done with this weak defense for the OP, go bother some else, I have yard work to do. |
| Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
Reply to Yeshaiah2015yesh
@ejleon
see bro you gotta take it easy with those impulse their cool down bro cool down. you gotta understand know buddy is attempting any thing on you. Why are you being so agrivess. when all i said
read it again if you want
He just said he didn't like it turned out like one piece type of show rather than a war isekai (because that who the anime presented it self in the start). And asked who did the author think that people who watched it from episode 1 wanted this.
That's all
And i was trying to tell you that. But your just lashing out on me, saying pathetic this and that. Your just being mean to me for nothing.
And speaking of work i have to get up in the morning and go running my self. I came to my Village for this holiday. And i also help out my grandfather in the farmers. Iam not free my self expect in the noons, and night's
see bro you gotta take it easy with those impulse their cool down bro cool down. you gotta understand know buddy is attempting any thing on you. Why are you being so agrivess. when all i said
Yeshaiah2015yesh said:
bro your over thinking, I've read the comments, he never said he wanted the author to write the way he wanted. he was just expressing his discontent of the way the author chose write the show.
bro your over thinking, I've read the comments, he never said he wanted the author to write the way he wanted. he was just expressing his discontent of the way the author chose write the show.
read it again if you want
LemonadeSamurai said:
I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a
realistic war isekai?
I get it. You wanted a plot twist. But did you ever think that people reading your manga or watching your anime from the first episode wanted a one piece type show with characters having different abilities and powers and NOT a
realistic war isekai?
He just said he didn't like it turned out like one piece type of show rather than a war isekai (because that who the anime presented it self in the start). And asked who did the author think that people who watched it from episode 1 wanted this.
That's all
And i was trying to tell you that. But your just lashing out on me, saying pathetic this and that. Your just being mean to me for nothing.
And speaking of work i have to get up in the morning and go running my self. I came to my Village for this holiday. And i also help out my grandfather in the farmers. Iam not free my self expect in the noons, and night's
| @Yeshaiah2015yesh I was on a break… First I’m “overthinking” now I’m “not calm and aggressive”, why attack me personally? You are even stating the exact problem, but still claims to not understand. The author wrote the story how he wanted, nothing wrong with that. You disliked it, nothing wrong with that. But claiming that the author should have made a different story to satisfy the audience or just 1 person is a step too far. Hope your work goes well and you are safe. |
ejleonMar 7, 1:06 PM
| Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
Reply to Yeshaiah2015yesh
@ejleon
Calling someone pathetic and telling they are attempting some thing on you, is nothing less from beginning agrivess. especially when all they ware trying doing was tell something to you
What am I a terrorist, that's why I said don't over think, because i don't what made you think i was attacking you, all i did was being polite, while you're accusing me doing this and that to you
That's exactly you, and what your overthinking, because he never said the author should have changed this part or that part, all he said was did the author think people who are watching will like this.
I absolutely agree with you. And he is only expressing his dislikes of the anime. He never stated anything like the author should have changed this for me. I hope you understand. Or if i missed something he said quote me those lines
I don't know why said it, but tanks
ejleon said:
First I’m “overthinking” now I’m “not calm and aggressive”
First I’m “overthinking” now I’m “not calm and aggressive”
Calling someone pathetic and telling they are attempting some thing on you, is nothing less from beginning agrivess. especially when all they ware trying doing was tell something to you
ejleon said:
why attack me personally?
why attack me personally?
What am I a terrorist, that's why I said don't over think, because i don't what made you think i was attacking you, all i did was being polite, while you're accusing me doing this and that to you
ejleon said:
You are even stating the exact problem, but still claims to not understand.
You are even stating the exact problem, but still claims to not understand.
ejleon said:
But claiming that the author should have made a different story to satisfy the audience or just 1 person is a step too far.
But claiming that the author should have made a different story to satisfy the audience or just 1 person is a step too far.
That's exactly you, and what your overthinking, because he never said the author should have changed this part or that part, all he said was did the author think people who are watching will like this.
ejleon said:
You disliked it, nothing wrong with that.
You disliked it, nothing wrong with that.
I absolutely agree with you. And he is only expressing his dislikes of the anime. He never stated anything like the author should have changed this for me. I hope you understand. Or if i missed something he said quote me those lines
ejleon said:
Hope your work goes well and you are safe.
Hope your work goes well and you are safe.
I don't know why said it, but tanks
| @Yeshaiah2015yesh I didn’t call you or anyone pathetic, “pathetic attempt to discredit my words”, there is a difference, and the reason I said this is how you were phrasing things. If you are not trying to insult me or attack me, then please rephrase your words, because it seems like you’re insulting me, when you say certain things, not sounding polite, but rude. (I don’t think it is just me being too sensitive, emotional, or overthinking) I will also rephrase my comments and be more patient to not sound rude or aggressive. I apologize and thank you for telling me. Yeshaiah2015yesh said: did the author think people who are watching will like this. Of course the author thought his story was good, he would have changed it if he didn’t, and others, the editors (etc), would have told him too, but it became publisher written material and an anime. Hence why I was saying that it made no sense to claim it should have been written differently. I understand that you don’t agree that he is claiming the other should have written a different story, thank you for explaining. Yeshaiah2015yesh said: I don't know why said it, but tanks Because I do want to get along with people and be kind. |
| Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating. |
Otakupervert890 said: with plunderer being the worst by how long the manga drag. Lol for me Judas and that one golf manga he drawn is 10x worse with the amount of silliness and nonsense he pulled out there (And cringe ass fanservices that made Plunderer anime looks genius by comparison for the latter). Plunderer manga despite all it's flaws is still far from being the worst lol. The anime adaptation is 100% trash I agreed tho lol. |
MahiaErebeaNegiMar 26, 6:46 PM
| When I first saw this anime, I gave it a 5/10. Re-watching it and I can't make it past Episode 9, changing my rating to 3/10. This show is just beyond stupid. I just don't give a flying fuck about any of the characters. What's more hilarious is that when the show starts, the mother hands over the "ballot" to the girl, and made it look like the girl was suppose to find the legendary Ace to seek help. But nah, apparently the mother just wanted her daughter to find a serious molestor for lulz, cause the daughter never mentions saving her mother again to this Ace. Instead she's attached to the guy like a leach for no reason whatsoever. Then there's the moron with "conviction" nonsense. Dumbest fucking character till the girl with the fun shows up after the helicopter. Actually, you know what? I changed my mind. Rating it 1/10 cause it's too stupid, just like that "Hundred" show. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Plunderer Episode 13 DiscussionStark700 - Apr 8, 2020 |
38 |
by Narity_
»»
Sep 18, 5:40 AM |
|
Poll: » Plunderer Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Dec 8, 2019 |
197 |
by Tsukasa_Rio
»»
Jul 25, 3:46 AM |
|
Poll: » Plunderer Episode 22 DiscussionStark700 - Jun 10, 2020 |
41 |
by Meinis
»»
Jul 21, 10:16 AM |
|
Poll: » Plunderer Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jan 22, 2020 |
84 |
by -ODA-
»»
Jul 10, 8:08 AM |
|
Poll: » Plunderer Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jun 24, 2020 |
88 |
by AnchientProphet2
»»
Jun 27, 10:34 AM |