I thought throughout my first watch last Summer 2021 that the show continued to improve as it went along. I felt every 10-20 episodes there was a jump in quality of the characters and story telling. I felt the story really picked up around episode 60-70, and then was consistently getting better and better through to it’s final episode. Now, I know 60-70 episodes is a lot, and I definitely wish the show was better, but I still gave it an 8.
I will admit, I watched the show with some preconceived notions, both positive and negative. I had heard that Asta yells a lot and people could not stand it, that the plot was filled with typical tropes and that the animation was hit or miss. But I had also heard that the show improved with time, and the clichés it started with grew into something more.
After having watched it, I agreed more with the positive take. The show did seem very by the book, and it’s animation is inconsistent (it’s like a bell curve lol for some reason the animation quality seems to get worse towards the end) but the story, characters, world building and lore were intriguing enough to keep me watching and eager to see where the story would go. Still, I thought it took a while to get to that point, and had I stopped prior to episode 50 I would give it maybe a 7. By episode 100 or so the show is very enjoyable and the characters have had enough growth and the plot progressed enough to make the action and story developments worthwhile enough to be a 8-10 depending on the particular “sub arc”.
I left my score at 8 because 60-70 episodes to hit that high was a little annoying since the series is under 200 episodes at the moment. I can’t wait for new episodes to come out, and I completely understand the hype around it! It successfully takes a generic fantasy magic powers story setting, and develops it enough to make the world and it’s characters feel fresh and unique, even while having some cliches stick around. It could be better, and while I don’t want to ruin the story I do wish it had progressed more than it did. However, how the story has progressed I think is going great, and I have my own hopes for where the story can go and how it can flow better. |