| For those of you who don't know, the brother hood treatment, named after FMAB, is when you take an old a show and remake it with better production, and a better story that usually just follows the source more tightly with less bullshit and filler As an example, you can take fruits basket which got a total remake that basically throws away any reason you had to watch the original one I've seen a lot of people saying how they want certain shows to be remade like this so why not make a post about it My choice would probably be one piece, even tho the anime is already 900 episodes deep, its full of filler with bad pacing, poor and rushed animation, and because it's so long and not divided into seasons, and with all that its doing a terrible job attracting newcomers to it, which sucks cause the pacing and filler of the show don't do the story justice, so it would naturally be better as a seasonal anime divided into 26 episode long seasons that come out every year or so, kinda like my hero academia, even 15 seasons would be far less intimidating than 900 episodes While one piece itself isn't as filler littered as, say bleach, I think its story is so much better that it deserves a much better adaptation more similar to new seasonal shounens |
yotiFeb 8, 2020 3:55 PM
 |
| Probably.... Berserk.... and berserk.... and also berserk... In short, i need berserk to get a remake. And i hope it won't be a 3DCG. |
  Wandering Witch is the best light novel ever! |
| Pandora Hearts Tokyo Ghoul Claymore Rosario+Vampire All these series need it very, very badly. The current adaptations don't do them anywhere near enough justice, it's depressing. |
 |
| literally every anime ever created particularly long forgotten shounenshit |
 |
| In that case, I want to see Violet Evergarden have that treatment. I really love the anime but still, the original story was what I prefer. |
 |
| Konjiki no Gash Bell, the source material is so much better than the series. |
| Akame Ga Kill Berserk Hokuto no Ken Trigun |
 |
| Kingdom - that CGI mess we got is a slap in the face for everyone who actually read the manga. |
NamikazeHime said: it was such a slap in the face that most kingdom fans ive seen just ignore its existenceKingdom - that CGI mess we got is a slap in the face for everyone who actually read the manga. |
|
| Yuu Yuu Hakusho and Great Teacher Onizuka are the first ones that come to mind Also Berserk. Definitely Berserk. |
| If you're reading this and you haven't watched Mob Psycho 100, go watch it and then continue with what you were doing. Also, for the record, JoJo is great, it's fans are not. |
| Tokyo Ghoul A Certain Magical Index Arifureta Corpse Party |
 |
yotamdin said: For those of you who don't know, the brother hood treatment, named after FMAB, is when you take an old a show and remake it with better production, and a better story that usually just follows the source more tightly with less bullshit and filler Actually it just means rebooting it for a full adaption of the source because when the first anime version came out the source was still incomplete. Whether it's 'better' or 'less bullshit' is subjective, whether it has better production value is incidental. My choice would probably be one piece, even tho the anime is already 900 episodes deep, its full of filler with bad pacing, poor and rushed animation, and because it's so long and not divided into seasons, and with all that its doing a terrible job attracting newcomers to it, which sucks cause the pacing and filler of the show don't do the story justice, so it would naturally be better as a seasonal anime divided into 26 episode long seasons that come out every year or so, kinda like my hero academia except OP already has one of the lowest filler percentages among long-runners. The pacing issues are really the only valid argument, and those don't even start until hundreds of episodes into the anime. I don't see much point in remaking all of it. Especially in the form of a bunch of 26 episode seasons with long waiting times in between, like Hero Academia. With so much source material already available, if there is a remake it should be a long-runner again. Kinda like DB Kai was for DBZ. You can improve the pacing without taking 20 years to animate a million small seasons. That's the only kind of remake that might make sense for OP, but also only after the manga is complete. And technically there are already shorter remakes for most arcs, in the form of movies that trim down the story and condense each arc into ~2 hours. Also the main reason new viewers shy away from it is simply the length. It would be the same if it had 20+ seasons with 26 episodes each. If you ask me the Brotherhood treatment should be reserved for shows that are not full adaptions and/or deviate strongly from the source so the remake is actually different and not just differently-paced with less non-canon material (the latter would be more accurately described as the DB Kai treatment). And it only really makes sense once the source is complete (like it was with FMA) because otherwise you just get another incomplete version of the same story, requiring another remake once it is finished. E.g. I read that Juuni Kokuki recently started publishing again, so if that goes anywhere it would be cool to have a reboot of the anime as well that actually concludes the story. Or Ao no Exorcist, although they already decided to ignore the deviation from the source when they continued it years later. |
| I probably regret this post by now. |
| I wish I could watch an anime that depicts the story of Tokyo Ghoul rather than that bullshit Pierrot gave us. |
| SAO PROGRESSIVE ANIME HYPE |
| I heard a lot of bad things about Berserk's adaptations(other than 1997 Berserk). Maybe Dragon Ball?(at least change Goku's VA) |
| I hate everyone equally |
| Berserk, Tokyo Ghoul, Toaru Majutsu no Index, Kingdom, Nanatsu no taizai 3 |
 |
| I think Bleach deserves a remake beside that I would love to see Noblesse gets a good anime adaptation. |
  |
joshua10red said: index is actually a great example honestly, the original index anime came out at a time when trashy harem shows have yet to oversaturate the industry, and looking at it back it really hasn't aged well, with the whole first season of index being full of trashy harem and power fantasy vibes that people already got tired of, I could recommend it to someone who hasn't seen a lot of sol harem anime but other than that it just makes it really hard to get into the franchiseBerserk, Tokyo Ghoul, Toaru Majutsu no Index, Kingdom, Nanatsu no taizai 3 |
|
| The usual answers. My vote would go towards Berserk (like many have already stated). You could throw Claymore, Soul Eater, & Deadman Wonderland into the mix as well. |
| definitely trigun, the original is just fine but it was made in the middle of the manga, so like soul eater (which also deserves this treatment badly, it could be perfect) it just has a really weird abrupt ending. It’d be cool to see more of the story adapted. Also berserk, poor berserk. |
 |
yotamdin said: For those of you who don't know, the brother hood treatment, named after FMAB, is when you take an old a show and remake it with better production, and a better story that usually just follows the source more tightly with less bullshit and filler Implying the production values of FMA were worse than FMAB's. There was nothing wrong with them. They were only different. People need to stop thinking that something newer necessarily means better. Newer =/= better. Also FMA wasn't loaded with "bullshit" and fillers... it was an adaptation that took its own route, which is something vastly different too. |
| - Umineko - Angel Beats (make it 4 cours like it was supposed to be) - The DEEN adaptation of Fate/SN - ReLIFE Kanketsu-hen (make it a S2 instead of 4 specials) - Berserk (obviously) - Eyeshield 21 |
| Hunter x Hunter is a 1/10 |
| I'd like full adaptation of Shigurui, not that 12-episode long trailer |
 |
| Not exactly the brotherhood method but I would love to see Zatch Bell get a proper ending and have the last arc they aired follow the manga a bit more closely for continuity sake. |
| -Fate/stay night 2006 remake would be cool... -Higurashi no Naku Koro ni, its animation wasn't enough at all for feed this masterpiece... |
 |
| Berserk and Tokyo Ghoul. A Fate/Stay Night remake would be good after Ufotable finishes adapting the Heaven's Feel route. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| No anime deserves such horrible treatment. |
 |
| I think the anime that deserves the Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood treatment is Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, for absolutely reason other than it'd be hilarious. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood: Brotherhood. |
 |
Seiya said: No anime deserves such horrible treatment. No anime deserves to get good production with a faithful and complete story that follows the source more tightly and therefore does it justice? Unless you were just trying to say you don't like Fmab and if so, how brave of you |
|
yotamdin said: Seiya said: No anime deserves such horrible treatment. No anime deserves to get good production with a faithful and complete story that follows the source more tightly and therefore does it justice? Unless you were just trying to say you don't like Fmab and if so, how brave of you Well, let's just say that I'm not an FMAB fan. |
|
| Lol, idk if FMA 2003 wasn't successful there were any full adaptation of manga but let's ignore that and just answer the question. Full adaptation (and even continuing were the manga ends) of Tsurezure Children would be really good. I haven't seen Aku no Hana anime but for being an incomplete adaptation, I think it would be good to make a remake of it and this time for those guys who can't stand roto scope make it idk more "generic" |
| Bearserk FUCK DA WORD LIMIT, FUCK EM |
| FMAB isn´t my fave, but I get what you´re saying. Something that feels more like the original source with improvements, huh? In this case, the first one to me should be D.Gray-Man. This only might happen when the manga series end, in one more decade or something, lol. But I´d really like to watch everything with better animation and without fillers, for sure. Unpopular one, but I also choose Sankarea. Very little was adaptated back in 2012, there is much more to see. There are more nice characters and awesome twists. |
| "Could you not talk with me? I'm busy breathing." |
| Ranma 1/2 would be pretty dank. People will realize they laugh on stuff like KonoSuba a bit too much because they have not seen this gold. |
| Stay Home and Wash Your Hands. Protect Yourself. Protect Your Loved Ones. Protect Your Community and Help Defeat Coronavirus. |
| 4 animes: 1- Claymore 2- Claymore 3- Claymore 4- Claymore |
 |
| I'm only counting series that have completed source material. Since Berserk is not complete, I am not counting it. - Full Metal Panic. The first season was good. Once KyoAni got their hands on it, the show began going downhill. S4 was... rather mediocre. - Magi. The first season was tolerable, but the second season was an absolute slog. |
| Two animes immediately come to mind when speaking of a Brotherhood treatment: 1) Yu Yu Hakusho getting the Madhouse treatment would be a fantastic way to introduce the series to a new generation. 2) Fate Stay Night route. It's a crime Ufotable has yet to get their hands on the very thing that started it all. Might be tough for them to pull it off being as focused as they are on Demon Slayer now, but who knows? Maybe after the smoke blows over with Heaven"s Feel, they may surprise us. |
 |
| Sailor Moon but with a better adaptation than what Sailor Moon Crystal gave us. I'd like to keep the same art style of the original and just make it closer to the manga. |
 |
More topics from this board
» Anime songs that give you goosebumps. ( 1 2 )TsutanaiFuun - May 23 |
57 |
by Kenzolo-folk
»»
14 minutes ago |
|
» Would you watch AI anime? ( 1 2 )removed-user - Yesterday |
77 |
by dreamingneon
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » Would/Do you go to Anime Conventions?Dragevard - Oct 15, 2021 |
44 |
by EpicO4
»»
24 minutes ago |
|
» Did you know people who have only 200 completed anime but more than 100 days are--LenRea - 10 hours ago |
38 |
by NubFix
»»
25 minutes ago |
|
» The Impact of Anime on Global Pop CultureLenRea - 11 hours ago |
5 |
by dreamingneon
»»
28 minutes ago |