| Inb4 Aku no Hana Rosario Vampire came straight to mind. |
| *list list list list* Gedo Senki (The movie obliterated the entire book series) School Days (they picked the worst route) Ao no Exorcist (so much for a sequel) Paul said: Aku no HanaInb4 Aku no Hana |
| Yosuga no Sora was horrible in my opinion. I didn't read the eroge yet and dropped the anime after a few episodes, but what just pissed me majorly off is how they apparently would finish up each girls arc within a few episodes - something I can't stand at all. It's probably not the worst adaption ever, but it's the worst I know off. Oh, and inbefore people saying ZnT without even knowing why. |
MellowJello said: Ao no Exorcist (so much for a sequel) Ao no Exorcist BROTHERHOOD. |
bNq said: Yosuga no Sora was horrible in my opinion. I didn't read the eroge yet and dropped the anime after a few episodes, but what just pissed me majorly off is how they apparently would finish up each girls arc within a few episodes - something I can't stand at all. It's probably not the worst adaption ever, but it's the worst I know off. Oh, and inbefore people saying ZnT without even knowing why. i would say this, then i remembered roasrio + vampire |
   |
| Hey alright! I can dig this. |
| Rosario + Vampire always need to be reminded that the manga is 100x more better than anime counterpart. |
 Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| Rosario+Vampire And some people say that Chaos; Head visual novel is infinite better that the anime adaption. |
| http://myanimelist.net/anime/10213/Maji_de_Watashi_ni_Koi_Shinasai! Edit: damn links not working Wow... The entire first half of the visual novel consisted of two new female members of Yamato's group of friends. That could have easily been the first half of the anime, followed by whatever route they chose as the "main" route. Instead, the first half consisted of sex jokes and filler. Those two new members (along with the other girls, not counting the purple-haired one) were already established as hopeless harem losers craving for Yamato's dick. Then there's that damn ending... And THEN there's its English dub... Sentai, really. You squandered good voice actors on this piece of crap. |
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
gamer2710 said: Majikoi VN was more into friendship. Only Miyako was actualy in love with Yamato and no other girl in love with him outside their route.http://myanimelist.net/anime/10213/Maji_de_Watashi_ni_Koi_Shinasai! Edit: damn links not working Wow... The entire first half of the visual novel consisted of two new female members of Yamato's group of friends. That could have easily been the first half of the anime, followed by whatever route they chose as the "main" route. Instead, the first half consisted of sex jokes and filler. Those two new members (along with the other girls, not counting the purple-haired one) were already established as hopeless harem losers craving for Yamato's dick. Then there's that damn ending... And THEN there's its English dub... Sentai, really. You squandered good voice actors on this piece of crap. |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
NeoAnkara said: I meant that they were sluts in the anime. You get the point, though. That's what the show should have been about: friendship.gamer2710 said: Majikoi VN was more into friendship. Only Miyako was actualy in love with Yamato and no other girl in love with him outside their route.http://myanimelist.net/anime/10213/Maji_de_Watashi_ni_Koi_Shinasai! Edit: damn links not working Wow... The entire first half of the visual novel consisted of two new female members of Yamato's group of friends. That could have easily been the first half of the anime, followed by whatever route they chose as the "main" route. Instead, the first half consisted of sex jokes and filler. Those two new members (along with the other girls, not counting the purple-haired one) were already established as hopeless harem losers craving for Yamato's dick. Then there's that damn ending... And THEN there's its English dub... Sentai, really. You squandered good voice actors on this piece of crap. |
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
gamer2710 said: Yeah. They were downgrading many character personality.NeoAnkara said: I meant that they were sluts in the anime. You get the point, though. That's what the show should have been about: friendship.gamer2710 said: Majikoi VN was more into friendship. Only Miyako was actualy in love with Yamato and no other girl in love with him outside their route.http://myanimelist.net/anime/10213/Maji_de_Watashi_ni_Koi_Shinasai! Edit: damn links not working Wow... The entire first half of the visual novel consisted of two new female members of Yamato's group of friends. That could have easily been the first half of the anime, followed by whatever route they chose as the "main" route. Instead, the first half consisted of sex jokes and filler. Those two new members (along with the other girls, not counting the purple-haired one) were already established as hopeless harem losers craving for Yamato's dick. Then there's that damn ending... And THEN there's its English dub... Sentai, really. You squandered good voice actors on this piece of crap. |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
Forgetfulness said: Isn't there no Tsukihime anime?And I hear Tsukihime is a really bad adaptation, though I haven't seen it myself (btw, How was this not mentioned yet?) |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
Forgetfulness said: It wasn't that bad. All they had to do was stick to one route entirely instead of trying to shoehorn bits and pieces of other routes (and filler, of all things) into it.NeoAnkara said: Forgetfulness said: Isn't there no Tsukihime anime?And I hear Tsukihime is a really bad adaptation, though I haven't seen it myself (btw, How was this not mentioned yet?) Ah yes, I was confusing it with a different adaptation. My bad |
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
Forgetfulness said: Yeah. Damn, Type-Moon's early works are notorious for this.Oh, so it's kinda like Fate/Stay Night? At least Fate/Stay Night had its length (24 episodes) as an excuse. Tsukihime had only 12 episodes, I mean come on. |
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
Xlypher said: oh god, this. R+V went from dark and amazing to lively fantasy world and over-the-top fanservice.bNq said: Yosuga no Sora was horrible in my opinion. I didn't read the eroge yet and dropped the anime after a few episodes, but what just pissed me majorly off is how they apparently would finish up each girls arc within a few episodes - something I can't stand at all. It's probably not the worst adaption ever, but it's the worst I know off. Oh, and inbefore people saying ZnT without even knowing why. i would say this, then i remembered roasrio + vampire |
 |
| General consensus say that R+V was bad adaptation and I'm 1000% agree with this. |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| Damn, it's hard to find something for people of MAL to pretty much agree unanimously on. I, too, think the R+V anime should be tossed in the trash. At first, I thought it was just mediocre, not any better or worse than other harems--but then I picked up where the manga started getting serious. I'm at the edge of my seat waiting for Tsukune to kick the Big Bad's ass. Damn. |
gamer2710Apr 10, 2013 9:21 PM
This topic has not been locked and is still available for discussion. |
Holybaptiser said: really? i think the manga is great (R+V II)Must... resist... expressing hatred... for R + V manga. |
|
| Samurai Deeper was pretty shitty ... Berserk wasn't shitty but managed to miss the entire plot in the adaptation (let's just say the part they covered is a plot device that most ppl usually bitch about) Tenjou Tenge was pretty full of fail too although ... the manga wasn't the best piece of work either so... |
 |
| I will always bring R+V into a discussion on the topic like this. |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| This non-existent anime comes into my mind. |
 |
Tennouji_ said: This non-existent anime comes into my mind. XD I'm reading the manga right now ... just finished chapter 71 ... pretty coold I suppose, but yeah heard the anime was amazingly bad by so many people As for Vampire Knight I would say that the adaptations was horrible but it was adapted from a horrible manga so ... I guess that would be unfair to blame the production company since it was mostly the plot itself that was shit. |
|
Pirating_Ninja said: Regardless of what they chose to adapt, it would still have an open ending, you know, considering Berserk is never going to end. I think choosing to do the Golden Age arc was a sound choice, because it's the only conclusive part of the manga, was over 100 chapters long and had some very good character development. Yeah, there is over 200 chapters to read past that point, but it still hasn't really gone anywhere other than Guts building a group of followers and becoming more of a nice guy.Berserk wasn't shitty but managed to miss the entire plot in the adaptation (let's just say the part they covered is a plot device that most ppl usually bitch about) Only if they gave the Golden Age arc an anime original ending, so that the anime didn't have a troll ending. I still don't see the point for the new Berserk movies. |
I'm also filled with pure-hearted ulterior motives. |
| I never watched it, but i heard the anime of Nana to Kaoru was horrid. As for my own choices, Rosario+Vampire was awful and Fate/Stay Night was pretty bad too |
| Top 5 Anime - 1. Clannad After Story, 2. Higurashi Kai, 3. Steins;Gate, 4. Katanagatari, 5. The Wolf Children Ame and Yuki Top 5 Manga - 1. Great Teacher Onizuka, 2. Onani Master Kurosawa, 3. Tsukihime, 4. Naruto, 5. Dengeki Daisy |
| Gantz is the worst I've seen.... so awful oh and Soul Eater pissed me off too |
ZenickaApr 11, 2013 12:05 AM
robtheanimeguy said: Oh, fuck. Absolute train wreck. The OVA completely and utterly fucked up the characterizations and motives behind the characters and why they did what they did. The BDSM scenes were cool and well done, but the characters were completely ruined. It was nonsensical. The manga is infinitely better.I never watched it, but i heard the anime of Nana to Kaoru was horrid. |
| I'm also filled with pure-hearted ulterior motives. |
| Funny. A few weeks a go and this thread would've been creamed with SAO haters. And well, SAO. The pacing and the side-stories could've been done and placed better than they were. Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. |
 |
yhunata said: Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. I'm no Naruto fanboy by any means but, I honestly think the original Naruto could be considered really good if it wasn't for about, oh, 100 episode of STRAIGHT FUCKIN FILLER!!! |
| Top 5 Anime - 1. Clannad After Story, 2. Higurashi Kai, 3. Steins;Gate, 4. Katanagatari, 5. The Wolf Children Ame and Yuki Top 5 Manga - 1. Great Teacher Onizuka, 2. Onani Master Kurosawa, 3. Tsukihime, 4. Naruto, 5. Dengeki Daisy |
robtheanimeguy said: yhunata said: Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. I'm no Naruto fanboy by any means but, I honestly think the original Naruto could be considered really good if it wasn't for about, oh, 100 episode of STRAIGHT FUCKIN FILLER!!! That might count however ... that's just more milking a popular series for all it's worth, and avoiding catching up to the manga. |
|
Pirating_Ninja said: robtheanimeguy said: yhunata said: Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. I'm no Naruto fanboy by any means but, I honestly think the original Naruto could be considered really good if it wasn't for about, oh, 100 episode of STRAIGHT FUCKIN FILLER!!! That might count however ... that's just more milking a popular series for all it's worth, and avoiding catching up to the manga. Yeah, they did a good job of avoiding catching up and it was understandable. Some of the fillers were also very enjoyable. Now they're putting in shitty fillers for no reason whatsoever. |
|
yhunata said: Pirating_Ninja said: robtheanimeguy said: yhunata said: Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. I'm no Naruto fanboy by any means but, I honestly think the original Naruto could be considered really good if it wasn't for about, oh, 100 episode of STRAIGHT FUCKIN FILLER!!! That might count however ... that's just more milking a popular series for all it's worth, and avoiding catching up to the manga. Yeah, they did a good job of avoiding catching up and it was understandable. Some of the fillers were also very enjoyable. Now they're putting in shitty fillers for no reason whatsoever. Then that is undoubtedly just to milk it for all its worth, Naruto/Fairy Tale/One Piece/Bleach/etc. (most long running shounen anime) are kind of like cash cows at this point, gotta expect fillers whenever possible. |
|
yhunata said: You know Naruto filler was good. Up until Pain arc many Naruto filler are good. But past that many filler is questionable on it's quality.Pirating_Ninja said: robtheanimeguy said: yhunata said: Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. I'm no Naruto fanboy by any means but, I honestly think the original Naruto could be considered really good if it wasn't for about, oh, 100 episode of STRAIGHT FUCKIN FILLER!!! That might count however ... that's just more milking a popular series for all it's worth, and avoiding catching up to the manga. Yeah, they did a good job of avoiding catching up and it was understandable. Some of the fillers were also very enjoyable. Now they're putting in shitty fillers for no reason whatsoever. |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| OH FUCK! I just remembered DBZ existed. OH GAD, SO MUCH FILLER!!! |
| Top 5 Anime - 1. Clannad After Story, 2. Higurashi Kai, 3. Steins;Gate, 4. Katanagatari, 5. The Wolf Children Ame and Yuki Top 5 Manga - 1. Great Teacher Onizuka, 2. Onani Master Kurosawa, 3. Tsukihime, 4. Naruto, 5. Dengeki Daisy |
| Deen really butchered Umineko. I'm sure there are worse anime adaptations out there, but that's the worst one I've seen, and perhaps my least favorite anime of all time. As a side note, I'm in the vast minority of people who actually like the anime adaptation of Higurashi more than the VN. Fate/Stay Night's adaptations were pretty bad too. The Unlimited Blade Works movie literally makes no sense unless you've read the VN. Absolutely disgraceful. |
| As a HUGE R+V fan, I will go ahead and add to the consensus... However, R+V anime was a failure not for the ecchi but because they didn't even bother to animate the actual fucking story. The manga is IMO a perfect example of how you can combine a harem + battle shounen in a positive way. I will say that another terrible anime adaptation is Negima....then again the Manga ended so horribly, I don't even care. |
| Negima OVA Shirokishi Tsubasa Ala Alba was decent though. |
| Kickstarter for Rokujouma is fully funded. Good work everyone. Lets wait for the result of our hard work together. |
| I want to say Ao no Exorcist, which was actually pretty good until half way through. Then it became a filler. Sure people enjoyed it, but I was too disappointed with it that I couldn't watch. |
robtheanimeguy said: yhunata said: Naruto Shippuden is also up there because of the load of fillers. I'm no Naruto fanboy by any means but, I honestly think the original Naruto could be considered really good if it wasn't for about, oh, 100 episode of STRAIGHT FUCKIN FILLER!!! Agreed. I never read the manga, but I liked the pre filler Naruto far better than Shippuden. I still think it's slightly above average overall, and certainly better than the haters suggest, but it could have been a top standalone anime if it didn't milk the the shit out of it with fillers. Well, I only took one point off it, but the sheer number of fillers probably deserves more. One of the the prime cases of $$$ over artistic integrity, reminds me of DBGT. Shippuden I just hate the canon as well as the fillers. As for the topic, I don't have have any to add. FSN/Tsukihime are my votes. Both could do with remakes. And I haven't read Umineko, but I refuse to believe the VN is as stupid as the anime, so I'm gonna throw that in there too. |
DateYutaka said: Berserk TV It's good for atleast introducing the manga. Really it's just the production values that are lacking the story and characters are still fully intact IMO. Zetman on the other hand is a terrible adaption. |
 "The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself." -Friedrich Nietzsche |
DateYutaka said: Berserk TV That was for me the best adaptation ever. Funny. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Which is your favourite Anime in this list?PushedCaraway - 9 hours ago |
32 |
by Ex-Aid
»»
1 minute ago |
|
» What's an anime that didn't meet your expectations, and what's an anime that exceeded them? ( 1 2 )JKKH - Jul 18, 2022 |
67 |
by Spunkert
»»
8 minutes ago |
|
Poll: » do you consider hate on your favorites an attack on you personally?deg - Apr 23 |
33 |
by deg
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
» ❄️ Anime Winter 2024 Male Characters Tournament ( 1 2 3 4 5 )ISeeLifePeople - Apr 14 |
223 |
by iftsistrnn
»»
33 minutes ago |
|
» Do you consider the opening(s) and ending(s) when rating an anime? ( 1 2 )Hacker075 - Mar 15 |
62 |
by _ATG_
»»
34 minutes ago |