necessary?

Jan 23, 9:27 PM

Offline

Jun 2021

127

Do you guys think a one piece remake is this necessary given the anime hasn’t even finished and a lot of the early episodes were already reanimated to fit the modern art style and pacing of the series

i’ll watch it to see how its gonna be adapted but interesting choice to re adapt it

what do y’all

Jan 23, 9:43 PM

Piromysl

Offline

Jul 2015

11375

When you see free money you don't ask if it is necessary.

Jan 23, 9:45 PM

onespankman

Offline

May 2020

197

It absolutely is necessary. As it stands, it’s almost impossible for newbies to get into One Piece through the anime. You need to be a binge watching god with at least two months to spare to do it.

The weekly anime may well continue into the next decade, there’s really no reason to wait to remake it. This will hopefully provide an accessible entry point to the series.

Jan 23, 10:47 PM

Kreshre

Offline

Mar 2019

128

it is cause the animation is outdated and is in box format so a lot of people won't watch it cause it looks old and not high quality. they are probably gonna stop at when the show went to wide screen tv format and probably fix pacing issues.

Jan 24, 12:13 AM

MishMashMoshi

Offline

Apr 2021

veryveryveryveryveryveryveryveryveryvery necessary

Jan 24, 12:16 AM

mokkocchi

Offline

Apr 2016

669

I mean it they have a lot of budget for it and considering that this a popular anime, fans will def watch it.

Jan 24, 1:15 AM

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

3825

It's necessary for those who are interested in One Piece but don't want to go through 1000+ episodes.

This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.

Jan 24, 1:17 AM

deg

Offline

Jan 2009

93200

netflix sees demand for it im sure after the success of the live action

Jan 24, 1:38 AM

ANIk_003

Offline

Sep 2022

427

omana said:
Do you guys think a one piece remake is this necessary given the anime hasn’t even finished and a lot of the early episodes were already reanimated to fit the modern art style and pacing of the series

i’ll watch it to see how its gonna be adapted but interesting choice to re adapt it

what do y’all

It is WIT Studio, so I know they will do a good job with art style and pacing, so yeah it was necessary to remove the stain of 'Bad Pacing' from One Piece, and I hope WIT will see it through the end.

Jan 24, 1:42 AM

#10

ToG25thBaam

Offline

Jun 2011

13808

I think it is. The One Piece Live Action garnered a lot of attention towards One Piece, but there are so many people who couldn't get into the old Toei version. A modern version of One Piece is for the new fans who got into One Piece through the live action and wanted to get into the source material. (anime/manga)

A lot of long time One Piece fans like myself are also interested in how it would look with modern adaptation, and a lot of people who were afraid of getting into One Piece due to the length can now watch along the others with the new adaptation. It's a win-win situation.

Honobono Log - best slice of life short
--------------------------------------------
most kawaii loli overlord
----------------------------
Donquixote Doflamingo AMV - Control

Jan 24, 1:49 AM

#11

Oskaroo

Offline

Feb 2022

246

As someone who’s never watched one piece i gotta say that if not for this remake i’d never even attempt to get into the series

Jan 24, 4:53 AM

#12

ButterworthBoys

Offline

Jul 2023

I'm actually interested in watching this, and I had zero interest in starting the already-existing anime. So I'd say it's definitely necessary to attract people like myself.

Jan 24, 8:29 AM

#13

omana

Offline

Jun 2021

127

onespankman said:
It absolutely is necessary. As it stands, it’s almost impossible for newbies to get into One Piece through the anime. You need to be a binge watching god with at least two months to spare to do it.

The weekly anime may well continue into the next decade, there’s really no reason to wait to remake it. This will hopefully provide an accessible entry point to the series.

yeha i’m so pissed cuz i’m still kind of new to one piece too and just after i watched 300+ episodes they decide to release a faithful adaptation 😭😭

Jan 24, 1:36 PM

#14

Sxlemm_

Offline

Feb 2022

No, but I don't think anyone will be bothered by this. Those of us who have fallen in love with One Piece from the beginning will be able to see the first steps of this work in good quality.
it is necessary? No. Will the fans be happy? Yeah.

Jan 24, 1:36 PM

#15

Sxlemm_

Offline

Feb 2022

Jan 24, 4:06 PM

#16

Chopper0610

Offline

Dec 2020

I think it’s necessary since there’s tons of people that want to watch the anime but don’t like the huge art style changes and filler. So the remake should be made while the series is still in heat. Especially since no one can spoil what the one piece is still.

Jan 24, 9:02 PM

#17

a0t3a

Offline

Apr 2020

536

yes. one piece just the animation is dated💀 it's boring it's stale🤷 revolutionary girl utena came out around the same time and that even has better animation and more style (also in need of updated animation). one piece has always struggled from having a bad director and toei just being very cheap while also milking one piece for all it's got. not saying Netflix isn't doing the same thing but at least Netflix shows are pretty sometimes.

Jan 25, 9:13 AM

#18

GoCrayzee

Offline

Oct 2022

207

Exactly, I’d love to watch some of my favorite arcs in anime form, but I quit watching at Dressrosa and read the manga because of the pacing and animation being so horrendous. Hopefully this adaptation means I can see a well animated and well paced version of one of my favorite manga.

Jan 26, 3:02 AM

#19

GoatPieceLuffy

I love femboys.

Offline

Sep 2022

844

Reply to omana

yeha i’m so pissed cuz i’m still kind of new to one piece too and just after i watched 300+ episodes they decide to release a faithful adaptation 😭😭

@omana

Just keep watching!

Toei's One Piece is special!

𝙊𝙣𝙚 𝙋𝙞𝙚𝙘𝙚 𝙥𝙖𝙘𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙞𝙨 𝙥𝙚𝙧𝙛𝙚𝙘𝙩𝙡𝙮 𝙛𝙞𝙣𝙚. - 𝙕𝙖𝙘𝙝

Jan 26, 6:06 PM

#20

Pirate

Offline

Apr 2013

207

the anime started over 20 years ago and the pacing in the anime has been awful for most of that. it Is definitely necessary in order to get new fans

Jan 26, 6:10 PM

#21

Early_Morning

Offline

Aug 2019

2489

Money talks I guess. I don't see the remake as necessary, especially since it might potentially overshadow the original series.

Jan 26, 11:39 PM

#22

district_marvel

Offline

Mar 2021

I genuinely think it is quite necessary.As it will drastically reduce the episode count which will help with the bad pacing and fillers

Jan 27, 12:20 AM

#23

HasnatVhai

Offline

Dec 2023

Absolutely necessary...

Jan 29, 9:21 AM

#24

Animeboy153

Offline

Dec 2022

I wanted to watch one piece but I heard pacing is shit.
so I see this as a absolute must

Jan 29, 9:26 AM

#25

spacecobra5

Offline

Jan 2024

Nobody cares in Japan if it's necessary or not, the industry people simply saw it as a good way to make more money and made it happen, the rest is irrelevant. You people should really learn anime is an industry focused on making money, not some artistic medium that is decided based on what is necessary or relevant. It was less money making oriented back in the 80s and the 90s and early 2000s though.

spacecobra5Jan 29, 9:46 AM

Feb 1, 12:09 PM

#26

Asoockie

Offline

Nov 2019

spacecobra5 said:
Nobody cares in Japan if it's necessary or not, the industry people simply saw it as a good way to make more money and made it happen, the rest is irrelevant. You people should really learn anime is an industry focused on making money, not some artistic medium that is decided based on what is necessary or relevant. It was less money making oriented back in the 80s and the 90s and early 2000s though.

But still it depends on the consumer demands too.

Feb 3, 4:57 AM

#27

akazawafate

Offline

Mar 2021

Reply to Sxlemm_

@Sxlemm_ OP deserve it.

Feb 4, 3:30 PM

#28

Storm-Sage

Offline

Nov 2014

264

yes, the anime is full of filler embedded into the dialogue, a 30 sec scene ends up being 3 minutes, multiply that by a thousand episodes and any manga reader will tell u its mostly just time wasting filler. Also lots of side stories and small (important) details get completely skipped. One piece NEEDS the FMA: Brotherhood treatment.

「俺を誰だと思っていやがる！」

嵐仙人

Signature | Transience

Feb 4, 3:34 PM

#29

phantom346

Offline

Jun 2015

2616

Of course it's necessary. Have you seen what a shitshow the One Piece anime is? If it wasn't for the amazing story it wouldn't even be worth watching. It has all the same pacing issues and animation issues as Naruto and Bleach.

Read Toriko!

Feb 24, 1:06 PM

#30

zombie_pegasus

Offline

Oct 2014

15269

Considering how watered down One Piece is compared to the manga, a remake makes total sense. It'll be more approachable for newcomers, it'll be more compact, easier to digest. Most people don't have time to get into regular One Piece.

Feb 25, 2:51 PM

#31

BilboBaggins365

Offline

Oct 2017

4060

If it adapts everything and is paced properly yeah. OP post timeskip is unwatchable, and they could cover other things better. Despite it being one of the biggest battle shonen out there and one close to my heart, it's hard to honestly recommend to any fan who didn't just grow up with it like me. A re-adaption would still be a long trek but actually watchable for the vast majority of anime fans who aren't into it already.

Feb 25, 3:11 PM

#32

wildhood

Offline

Dec 2013

5533

They might as well remake Detective Conan too at this point.

Feb 28, 5:35 AM

#33

Icy64

Offline

Aug 2020

I think it is, though i think its a bit early maybe wait until the manga is done.

I watched up to the end of wano act 2 of the anime before switching to manga, and while i love one piece and prefer watching anime to reading manga, the one piece adaptation kinda stinks, its nothing you havent heard before, theres no reason why an animated episode should cover less than a chapter of manga, dressrosa was awful, long op, long recap, super padded episode with flashbacks, long ep, long next time clips, adding up to like 10 minutes of new content

This remake can fix the awful padding issues since they wont have to worry about catching up to the manga, genuinely believe a redo could be the best way to watch the series and makes it so much more approachable

Mar 12, 9:22 PM

#34

Bhanu_LAW_196K1A

Offline

Nov 2022

Yess it's necessary because it will have better pacing,better direction,better SFX and most post time skip original series has animation issues until wano but it has direction and pacing issues

Mar 17, 1:19 AM

#35

argy97

Offline

Aug 2022

i think it is neccecary, the animation of one piece is relatively old at this point its been 25 years after all and it will allow new fans to enter the franchise (also it will have less episodes and the new anime watchers will not get scared away the moment they see the episode count)

Mar 19, 11:28 AM

#36

tudos4

Offline

Aug 2019

So, its probably a remake with One Pace style pacing + new Animation. I want to check it out.

Apr 6, 4:20 AM

#37

Baya128

Offline

Mar 2022

Absolutely necessary, I tried watching one piece, stopped somewhere in the 100s. The only way I got that far was by watching it on x2 speed.

Apr 10, 3:59 AM

#38

Icebreaker93

Offline

Mar 2011

1138

Reply to argy97

@argy97
The old animation is gold, but the pacing is the problem with the anime.
Too many padding and dragging the scenes and recaps.

Apr 17, 1:34 PM

#39

Vsegda7

Offline

Apr 2015

351

Reply to wildhood

They might as well remake Detective Conan too at this point.

@wildhood Detective Conan is 95% case of the week one-offs and 5% main plot. There's no skewed pacing for a remake to fix

Apr 25, 6:06 PM

#40

Rhae

Online

Aug 2018

17234

Personally, I find it unnecessary since One Pace and the manga exist.

But colour me surprised, maybe it's going to be the next best thing for One Piece.

May 9, 6:51 PM

#41

Zerity

Offline

Jul 2017

1845

yes, the anime of OP is fucking garbage so this is needed

May 16, 5:20 AM

#42

024

Offline

Nov 2017

1683

Yes, now that I've caught up, I need at least double the weekly One Piece dose.

plz @ me

May 24, 10:52 AM

#43

YahiyaX777L

Offline

Aug 2020

364

Not really necessary but it will definitely be something to keep an eye for

May 25, 9:14 AM

#44

praisethevillain

Offline

Feb 2018

158

Obvious cash grab is obvious.

See All Discussions

» There's a chance Wit Studio could adapt all of One Piece in 6 years. GoatPieceLuffy - Yesterday	20	by xay_sama »» 2 hours ago
» Remember people, this anime won't tarnish Toei's One Piece! GoatPieceLuffy - May 22	20	by PPL_CaLL_Me_DUDE »» May 26, 10:58 AM
Poll: » For people who've already watched/read through One Piece, will you be watching this? JKKH - Dec 18, 2023	44	by Elfezen »» May 17, 7:01 AM
» Hype! But, what about the VAs theaznkid360 - Dec 17, 2023	25	by APolygons2 »» Apr 25, 12:57 PM
» Is this completely unprecedented? ( 1 2 ) Caciulacdlac - Dec 17, 2023	55	by Baya128 »» Apr 10, 11:52 AM

necessary?

More topics from this board

» There's a chance Wit Studio could adapt all of One Piece in 6 years.

» Remember people, this anime won't tarnish Toei's One Piece!

Poll: » For people who've already watched/read through One Piece, will you be watching this?

» Hype! But, what about the VAs

» Is this completely unprecedented? ( 1 2 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters