Story: begins with cliches like "Killing number of monsters = reward", "protagonist(s) is the only one who can kill the monsters", and "Characters who questions and/or resolves in-order to become stronger".
Though these cliches can be found in almost any action anime Soul Eater stands out by putting the original intention of "Killing number of monsters = reward" out of the story (or at least short sighting it) and extends into the cliche of "Stop the bad guys from obtaining certain things in-order to rule the world". The story shines unlike any other anime when character contradictions, in depth character thought, and secrets come into play.
Art: The art uses a combination of "post-gothic" and "hip-hop" styles. Initially the art doesn't draw attention due to the "ghetto-ness" of the art that most anime viewers are used to. The art is only acceptable once the other categories of the anime come in. Action scenes are superb but the length of the scenes leaves the viewers wanting more. Certain action scenes lead more to character development verses action itself leading to a "Naurto-like/Bleach-like feeling", in other words a big disappointment. The anime features "post-gothic-ness" at certain points leaving a darkened tainted feeling (which is great for catching the viewers mood). When both arts are used in comedy it does the viewer(s) well because of the freshness (like someone hasn't made this joke even though they kinda have and its still funny feeling) it presents.
Sound: Soul Eater features music that gives off the feeling of "i want more so im going to buy that damn soundtrack". the voice actors aren't very renown (though you figure Bones and Square Enix would hire someone like "oh i know this guy!" kind of guy) but they fill their roles just fine (though some people think Maka/Black Star are annoying). The sound effects are fine and the intro is fine just as well. The only thing that stands out is the in anime music.
Character: Soul Eater doesn't shy off when it comes to character development. The story goes in dept with what the characters think and makes use of its time. The characters become stronger when they find a resolve which leads to a O_O holy sh!t O_O moment. Characters also contradict themselves which leads to a very human feeling (because we all contradict ourselves at some point).
Enjoyment: It's great very great just watch the first three and i promise its greatness.
