A Review of the First Arc of the Umineko Manga
I’ve given a lot of thought to how I should write this review. First, I want to clarify that I read the manga after finishing the visual novel, which I absolutely adore.
The visual novel Umineko: When They Cry is one of the best pieces of media I’ve ever experienced, so it’s impossible for me to be completely objective. My impressions are inevitably shaped by my love for the source material.
The Beginning: Disappointment and Contrast
When I finished the visual novel, I immediately decided to check out the manga. I believed Umineko was one of those stories that benefits from multiple readings to fully appreciate its depth, and I was curious to see how the story would feel now that I knew all its secrets. Unfortunately, my initial experience with the manga was disappointing.
The first chapter rushes through the introduction, giving only a surface-level presentation of the characters. Many cringe-worthy jokes, reminiscent of subpar anime humor, detract from the story. For instance, Battler—a deeply nuanced and likable character in the visual novel—is reduced to someone whose personality seems dominated by shallow jokes about breasts. In the visual novel, Battler’s relationships with others, his wit, and his charm are established so effectively that he becomes instantly relatable. The manga’s portrayal of him, however, feels flat and unappealing, especially for readers unfamiliar with the original work.
The same can be said for other characters, who are introduced hastily and lack the depth that makes them memorable. A prime example is the scene between Rosa and Maria, where Rosa’s anger builds into an emotionally charged confrontation with her daughter. In the visual novel, this moment is deeply affecting, layered with raw emotions that resonate with the reader. The manga, however, barely scratches the surface of these feelings, making it far less impactful.
Additionally, there’s a noticeable presence of fan service in the manga, which feels out of place in a story as atmospheric and serious as Umineko.
Improvements After the First Vol
After finishing the first vol, I was hesitant to continue, but I’m glad I did. Once the story reaches the first night, it becomes much more engaging. While it still lacks the depth and atmosphere of the visual novel, I found myself experiencing faint echoes of the emotions I felt when reading the original (helped by listening to the Umineko soundtrack while reading).
I’ve read that some fans dislike certain twists or how some mysteries are revealed in the manga. Personally, I didn’t notice these issues, possibly because I was already familiar with the source material. However, I believe that even if I had started with the manga, I would still have been drawn into the world and fascinated by the mysteries and narrative.
The Art Style
The art style is a mixed bag for me. While it’s not bad, it doesn’t capture the unique tone and atmosphere of Umineko. At times, I found it distracting or even jarring compared to the story’s themes.
Final Thoughts
Focusing solely on the manga, it’s undeniable that the story is deeply engaging. Even with a weak start, once you finish the first vol, you won’t be able to put it down. It’s an intricate, atmospheric, and thought-provoking tale that challenges your perspective and invites deep reflection. Umineko: When They Cry is one of the most complex stories I’ve encountered, and it absolutely deserves attention.
The first arc, is one of my favorites. The emotions, the atmosphere, and the intrigue of encountering everything for the first time are priceless to me. Many might disagree, but I firmly believe that the first arc of Umineko is one of the best. For me, it’s a solid 9/10. Yes, the manga falters in many areas, but the core story shines through, even in its abbreviated form. And my love for the first arc of the visual novel, which I rate 10/10, certainly influences my view.
P.S.
If you haven’t read Umineko yet and are wondering whether to start with the manga or the visual novel, I urge you to pick the visual novel. You won’t regret it—it will be one of the most captivating and enriching stories of your life. Trust me, you’ll thank me later.
First arc - Legend of the Golden Witch, final rating 9/10 (Manga Verion)