The storyline is simple, episodic SOL with heavy emphasis on comedy. The romance is mild: it’s alluded to, but nothing concrete develops. For anyone who wants heavier romance, I suggest you read the manga - they directly address romance in the final few volumes. Back to the anime, there are certain character dynamics and interactions that may feel uncomfortable, but at the end of the day, they’re left intentionally vague and are mostly for comedic effect. As this anime is a SOL, there is no real plot. Each episode is basically the same format - Host Club does outrageous things because they’re so filthy rich. It doesn’t get boring, though, and that’s all I’m looking for.
The writing makes an attempt to flesh out the main characters (they start off as tropes), and while it isn’t the best characterization I’ve seen, it’s an honest effort to introduce some seriousness. In Haruhi and her dad, there’s a fair bit of representation offered, even if it’s used as a gag (commendable for its time period). You have the other characters, and they also get some history and drama, and from there you can draw out their motivations. You end up with a likable cast, with a measure of substance to them, which is, honestly, all you need.
The only real criticism I have is that the ending felt a little too “happily-ever-after”. It was too easily resolved and even arguably fantastical. However, that’s because the writing team for the anime had to accelerate the pacing, knowing there was no intention for a season 2.
More than anything, Ouran High School Host Club maintains its lighthearted, goofy tone. I had a lot of fun watching this, and while I can’t promise you that, know that if anything, you’ll be entertained. Maybe in a couple of years, people will finally start remembering this show exists, and we’ll get a reboot. I don’t know if it’ll be the same without Miyano Mamoru as Tamaki, but still, a polished version would be very welcome.
Final Rating: 7
