Reviews

Dec 2, 2023
Mixed Feelings
A sometimes tedious exercise in slow drama, Shinkai's only defense is him still exploring the themes of alienation and separation in the early stages of his career. Kumo no Mukou, Yakusoku no Basho happened to be his first feature-length production, and likely the substantial foundation for a lot of the romantic metaphors he currently gravitates toward. The film is simple, everything about it is relatively muted, and content in lingering around alternate-history war politics and monologue-driven intimacy with a yearning for a hopeful future. Shinkai's writing isn't as technically sound as some of his later features, and that's apparent in the deliberate assortment of character interaction and science jargon. It frankly suffers a great deal from inadequately contextualizing seemingly important plot devices that may decide the fate of Japan, although the plot does ultimately suggest we ignore the minor details, and shift our focus to the three protagonists at large. The three middle school friends are pulled apart by circumstance, and the raw ideas of loneliness are combined with his go-to allusions using character versus society literary devices.

Shinkai once mentioned in an interview that the beauty of scenery had saved him during his adolescent struggles, and what that may have entailed is of course foreign to others, but there's truth to natural landscapes acting as a deterrent to negative emotion. He constantly emphasizes shot selection, wide settings, and trains, establishing one of his recurring directing traits in applying visual spectacle. Sure it's not his most breathtakingly detailed effort, but the layouts are indeed expansive, as picturesque as rural areas can be. A lot of these shots tend to use a person as the center of symmetry to give depth as the camera leans into aerial tilts, which was utilized well in the closing sequences. Kumo no Mukou, Yakusoku no Basho as a collective production undeniably feels amateurish, more so the storytelling not being able to dictate itself enough, and on occasion, it can also be heavyhanded without necessary exposition. Shinkai experiments with the usual loss and plays with time, yet makes little progress in crucial moments. I'm willing to commend the role of the opening sequence though, setting up a clever implication for what would become the prologue to that scene. At times streaky, an ambitious take on melancholic human connection with the universe as a whole.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login