Reviews

Oct 31, 2023
Mixed Feelings
Preliminary (57/? chp)
An incredulously edgy, blatantly misogynistic, story masquerading as a meaningful dark fantasy tale. The truth is, this isn't really Berserk. The protagonist does many 'edgy' things claiming that he is happy being in the background, giving his other family members the platform to bask in the light. But the way the manga develops and tells its story constantly puts the protagonist front and centre in every single one of its conflicts makes it hard to take what he says seriously. Also, what is with the gratuitous sexual violence and activity in this manga? Why is sex the only way to 'conquer' and get a female character on the protagonist's side? Why are all the characters so blatantly horny, with rape being the no.1 activity in the manga to signal to viewers that a character is antagonistic? Hell, sometimes the use of sexual violence and seduction of women isn't at all necessary to the progression of the story, or the development of the characters.

But aside from the edgy elements, I think one of the worst things in this manga is its poor characters. The characters aside from the main protagonist and his family are barely fleshed out at all (Though honestly, the female family members are also not very well characterised and often play out as cliches). The female characters especially, making them sometimes feel like meat puppets made to parade around the protagonist. The most egregious thing is how the manga constantly flips antagonists into his companions. It is forced and a little nonsensical when you bring in the context of their actions before they became an 'ally'. These antagonistic characters don't have a strong motivation to change their allegiance at all! But it's forced in there anyway to serve the fantastical narrative that the protagonist is some alpha that bathes in the darkness, converting all morally grey-black characters into allies to do his bidding.

Still, I think there are some interesting ideas in this manga. For one, the manga does fulfil the promise of a 'ruthless' and intelligent protagonist who uses his glib tongue and scheming to his advantage. In fact, some of the schemes that the protagonist pulls are interesting and kind of well thought out. It's just a shame that most of the conflict just falls down to pure firepower, making much of the scheming feel rather unnecessary. Still, while the manga explores its themes in the most juvenile and thoughtless way, the art is quite nice, and some action sequences are really good.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login