So Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood...
I remember my cousin and i, big fans of the original fma, watching a couple episodes in english and him saying "It's cute but yeah no thanks..."
So i watched the whole season in Japanese, and coincidentally so did his older brother. So when we were all together again (because they are both in the Marines) we we're talking about how f-ing awesome it is.
So the story ends about 30 hours and $200 later with us having bought all the seasons and watched it that week.
Incredible story. Great voice acting dub (Funimation delivers almost 100% of the time) . If you haven't watched it you're seriously missing out.