Story 7/10
This anime has SO much potential, but the major hindrance for that potential to reach its maximum, is how the story unfolds. For the first half of the anime, you feel so lost. I even considered dropping it a few times. However, I persevered because this anime is very recommended and I wanted to at least be able to understand or deny what people were raving about. The anime does get better and the story is actually really deep and touching, yet, by the end it all feels so rushed that you are left feeling dissatisfied. How did the rest of the cast join this place? what were their final wishes? why even bother creating such a big group of friends if you are mainly going to focus on 4 characters? why wasn't Otonashi able to go like the rest? how come Kanade was there first if it seems that Otonashi died first? who was that guy in the library basement with all the computers explaining about love getting in this place? if Kanade was a human being, why did she have software features? so many unanswered questions. I read that this anime was supposed to be 26 episodes and during production was suddenly cut to half. If that's the case, it shows and it ended up hurting the anime. I really liked that this anime makes you think and wonder, conversation worthy. However, I wished than rather to have to look up theories, the anime had been clearer since the beginning. Also, isn't this one of saddest endings of all times? yes, per the after credit you can assume Kanade and Otonashi end up finding each other, but what about Hinata and Yui? Does Noda ever get a chance to profess his love to Yuri? Again, so much potential that the anime could have actually been a couple of seasons, not just one. Such beautiful premises of being allowed a last chance to leave all regrets behind.
It does have some moments that squeeze you heart such as Iwasawa and Yui passing and Otonashi's background.
Art 8/10
This anime has beautiful drawings and color combinations, specially the eyes. This is highly enjoyable.
Sound 9/10
I don't really care much about the endings themes, however, that opening is another story. I really liked it. And, am I the only one who gets goosebumps over "my song" from Iwasawa? This song easily redeems the anime a bit.
Characters 6/10
To be fair, all characters are likable and interesting, however, we only got to see a glimpse of the main character's background and actual interests and wishes. Relationships feel so rushed that you can't be a 100% invested in anything or anyone.
Enjoyment 6/10
If you are able to get passed the 3-4th episodes, you will be in for an emotional ride.
