I feel like there is a good portion of intrigue here, with how deep the rabbithole goes for the story, but the main problem is its presentation. Characters will just describe the entire tension point of the story before it even happens and I'm supposed to act like i didn't see it coming. And the way they present it too is substantially more annoying. explaining every segment of the story and what's happening as if I'm not even watching the show and I'm having them give me a full plot synopsis every time. the handholding completely ruins the fun of trying to understand what you are watching, making your own sense of the story and the characters. rather than having them explain every single thing every single time.
most of the characters are pretty bad too. all of them are a single cliché and completely adhere to said cliché for the duration of their character's screen time. rinse and repeat this with every scene. they have little depth or character beyond this cliche. but that cant be said for EVERY character, like joker, whos actually interesting. but this can be said for most. because even if they undergo some sort of "awakening" and "realize their purpose" (or something along those lines) their character remains the same. they just fight better than they did before.
plus, the concept of subtilty is near non existent. with characters cracking jokes at the worst times, (literally the whole last arc of this season, where people are dying left and right but half of the characters act like nothing is happening) or just holding them for too long.
despite my negative gripes with the show, I still thoroughly enjoyed it. maybe I'm just a sucker for good animation and sound design. And the dialogue isn't ALWAYS bad, it can be good sometimes (for example, the arc with joker and beni, the shortest of them all. which had perfect pacing, dialogue and character development. actually felt like I was watching a competent show until we went to the next arc.) but it usually is pretty mediocre. And, obviously, the comedy isn't my thing. the fanservice isn't something I have a huge issue with because after a while it just becomes white noise and I block it out, despite it being completely stupid never the less. But that can be said about half of the characters in the show.
my final consensus is "definition MID Shonen material." (low 6, high 5)