Reviews

Mar 8, 2022
Mixed Feelings
One would think that Mario characters and fairy tales would be a combination that works, but “Amada Anime Series: Super Mario Brothers” is just silly. I can tolerate a lot of the liberties taken in the three stories in this short OVA. A mustachioed baby Mario? Sure. Queen Bowser? Okay. Princess Peach being the granddaughter of two Koopas? It’s a stretch, but an understandable decision. The issue is that the stories don’t make logical sense. Stuff just happens without rhyme or reason, and characters do things that seem incredibly unrealistic, even by fairy tale standards. Given the fact that the stories are short and based on existing material, the writing here is inexcusably sloppy.

The animation is also quite bad. It’s somewhere between full animation and storybook-style limited animation, almost as if they couldn’t commit to one or the other and compromised with a half-baked approach that looks subpar. “Critical” action scenes are played three times; perhaps for emphasis, but it gets old fast. What little animation there is tends to get reused. Characters’ facial expressions are often static, and the colors are washed out and even incorrect some of the time. The music is generic synthesized stuff. Even the voice acting isn’t that great.

This OVA is poorly done at every level. So why did I give it a rating of 5/10? I would rate each episode individually as a 4, but the fact that this OVA got made in the first place is interesting. The world of Super Mario does seem like it would mesh well together with fairy tales, so watching this left me thinking of what might have been if it had had better writing and higher production values. Also, due to its short length, it’s not painful to watch; it’s just silly. Not “laugh-out-loud” silly, or “so-bad-it’s-good” silly, but more like “what the heck am I watching” silly. It’s a spectacle; an anime oddity, if you will.

Overall, this OVA is not good, but it is unusual, easy to watch, and has little objectionable content beyond some cartoonish violence. Recommended for anyone who wants to see something different.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login