Although Fairy Tail haven't finished airing, the 1st Season was so far so good... It's a typical shounen, action, adventure anime that has a quite good character development, interesting Magic-Fighting style (Although a lot of anime have it), good story and a lot more...
Story:9/10
I've only seen the Season 1 which is 48 episodes... At first, I thought it would be just like your typical shounen, action, adventure anime but for some unknown reason, I was "sucked into it"... The story was really going on very well!!
Art:10/10
Good Artwork...
Sound:10/10
I loved most of the opening and ending themes of the anime and the BGM was quite good as well... No complains about any character voice! Just great.
Character: 9/10
Good character development, almost all character get a chance to "shine" and still not dragging down the anime... The characters are quite acceptable!
Enjoyment:9/10
Don't know bout' ya' but I definitely enjoyed it!!
Overall:9/10
