Reviews

Jun 4, 2019
Mixed Feelings
The issue with Yakusoku no Neverland is that it tries to be too clever, and fails spectacularly. Having genius protagonists isn't a problem. What is a problem is when the protagonists are so intelligent that it ruins the plot entirely because after the first few episodes, you are left with little doubt that they will be able to overcome anything that is ever thrown at them. The question isn't whether the protagonist will be able to overcome the problem or not, the only question is whether an antagonist will come up with a deus-ex-machina of their own to delay the plot slightly. The viewer is kept guessing as to whether a number of characters are good or evil, except you're not, because you know that the protagonists have worked it out already.

What makes this worse is that overcoming the mysteries the plot throws at the main characters doesn't even involve any inspiring solutions that the viewer could have worked out themselves, it just involves an endless number of backstabbers, backstabber-backstabbers, backstabber-backstabber-backstabbers, and so on.

This to-and-froing between a group of ridiculously intelligent people at times reminded me a bit of Death Note, except at least in Death Note (1) the plot was generally interesting and (2) the main characters were somewhat believable. The latter point is absolutely not the case in Yakusoku no Neverland because everybody involved is under the age of 11. This is taken to the extreme by one of the characters who [SPOILERS], at the tender age of 4, has no problems comprehending that his entire life is a lie, that he has been betrayed by his mother, and without a second thought agrees to commit himself and the other young children to extreme danger to give the older children a chance at survival. And even that is topped when it is revealed that one of the protagonists has such an extraordinary memory that he even remembers being in his mother's womb. The biggest joke is that this doesn't even serve any particularly important role in the plot, it's just a lazy, deus-ex-machina explanation for this character knowing more than he should do.

Yakusoku no Neverland isn't a bad anime, but it isn't good either. There are some nice characters, some good cinematography, and good audiovisuals. It's just a shame that it's let down by lazy, unbelievable story-writing.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login