Romcoms, and just romance anime in general, is a genre that is very near and dear to my heart. I’ve seen almost all of the big ones and probably enjoy them more than most of the anime community. So naturally I was interested in what some call the grandfather of anime romcoms, Maison Ikkoku. I gave it a shot, and oh boy did I come to regret that decision.
The premise is pretty simple. A beautiful widow, Kyoko, moves into, and starts working as the “manager”, in the apartment complex the main character, Godai, and some colorful characters, are living in. It’s more or less love at first sight for Godai, and well, you can probably see where this is going; it’s a typical romcom set-up, with some more serious aspects thrown in. But one of the first things you might wonder is how are they going to handle a 96 episode romcom. Surely you can’t stretch out something that usually takes place over a 12-24 episode show to 96 episodes right? Right? Wrong. It’s like they took everything I dislike about the genre, amplified it to insane levels, and shoved it in my face for almost 100 episodes.
Maison Ikkoku is basically “Misunderstandings: The Anime”, and almost all of them could have been quickly resolved with decent communication, or any communication at all. How many times can the main character be caught in a compromising position, have a perfectly valid explanation, only for him to inexplicably fail to properly explain himself at all? If his neighbor ever gets murdered and he is on the other side of the world, he’s going to jail for it, because he will somehow find a way not to tell them he was 2000 miles away when it happened. Or he’ll get interrupted while trying to tell them. Because if I took a shot every time someone got interrupted just as they were about to say something really important, I would be dead after a couple episodes. The amount of times these misunderstandings lead to excessive pouting, or even running away and hiding for days, is laughable. It might be excusable if these were middle school kids, but these are adults in their early-to-mid-20s we’re talking about here.
Look, I have a pretty high tolerance for slower love stories, but this is borderline writing malpractice. It’s as if the author knew people lose interest when it goes from the “will they/won’t they phase” to the “couple phase” and wanted to keep making the story, so we were just stuck in that first stage indefinitely. And to make it happen, the main character’s, and to a certain extent the main love interest’s, characters were nearly ruined. Dense would be an understatement. How either of them dress themselves or brush their teeth without adult supervision is a mystery to me. Keep in mind, they are supposed to play the “straight men” to the rest of the apartment complex’s loonies. I’m not going to spend much time on the rest of the residents. They’re a bunch of selfish, drunken idiots that screw up everything they put their grimy hands on and their act wears thin because it’s repeated ad nauseum. Got it? Good. As for the others, Mitaka, Godai’s romantic rival, is probably the only one worth mentioning. He’s pretty much the only main cast member that acts like an actual adult and is able to communicate his feelings semi-effectively. IMO, Mitaka , was the best character in the show, but given he was not the main character, you knew his chances of “winning” Kyoko’s heart were slim-to-none.
As far as the animation, it’s an 80s show, so don’t expect to be wowed. This is just a personal preference, but I can’t say I’m a fan of the character design. Many of the adults looked too much like giant children. This problem was not as severe as it is in, say, Key shows, but still, maybe differentiate adults and children by more than just height.
Onto sound. None of the OST, OPs, or EDs were even slightly memorable to me. The voice acting, outside of Shigeru Chiba’s performance as the bizarre Yotsuya, was at best average. Kyoko's dog in particular hurt my ears anytime it made any sound whatsoever.
I can’t say I hated the show from the beginning; but like an unhappy marriage, it was more of a slow burn to Hatred Town. Even the most interesting aspect of the show, the fact Kyoko was a widow, was mostly mishandled. There were long stretches where I legitimately forgot she was a widow, and then suddenly there would be an episode focusing only on that, only for it to mostly be forgotten by the next episode. And, the thing is, I desperately wanted to love this series, but by the time I got to the end, it had nearly broken me. I would say I cannot believe so many people like Maison Ikkoku, but a lot of people also like getting whipped and beaten. I’m guessing there’s some crossover in that Venn Diagram, because you have to have a little bit of masochist in you to sit through nearly 40 hours of this hellish romcom purgatory.
