Be warned as this review will be full of spoilers. I actually don’t want anyone to read it so I’ll spoil a fair bit of it to explain why.
If you’re already familiar with the setup of the story then skip ahead to the next segment.
One day a mysterious girl (Kurumi Sahana) transfers in the same class as our protagonist (Hideo Aiba), and he immediately falls in love with her. Luckily she is seated right next to him and they move their desks together to share a textbook. That alone makes him hard as a diamond. Unfortunately Kurumi drops her eraser and it lands right between his legs, next to a raging boner. She reaches down and picks it up while accidentally touching his penis yet she doesn’t seem to notice for now.
Later we are introduced to a roman club, it doesn’t have anything to do with the ancient empire or language. Roman alludes to romanticism of young boys and their desire to uncovered mysteries and chase after their dreams. The rumour has it that if you graduate without losing virginity or getting a girlfriend, the alumni of the roman club will fund your dreams. With high reward comes high risk in form of tests from the alums and assassins, women who are sent after the club members to rid them of their virginity. In this club there are 4 members: Hideo, who joined on a whim cause he didn’t think he’d ever date anyone while in school anyway; Ex-president, he has an anal fetish and mostly exists to make asshole jokes; Katsu Toshitsuku, a pervert with a peeping fetish who wants to become a lawyer and lastly; Tatsuya Yatsu, a cowardly otaku with a leg fetish who wants to becomes a politician.
Suddenly Kurumi comes to the club to check it out and joins them. When she’s left alone with Aiba she tells him to masturbate to which he replies that this is something people do in private but fearing to lose interest of a girl he likes he eagerly agrees and puts a nail inside his penis. After the attempt at masturbation with a nail failed Kurumi tells him that she will never have sex with him, she might do it casually with someone else but not with him, even if they were last two people on Earth, even he begged. Aiba doesn’t mind though, to him as long as she’s in close proximity of him. From there on the story is a slow trickle of what hardly qualifies of plot and character progression with and a lot of repetitive and forced comedy as well as very embarrassing ecchi.
What Sundome tries to be?
Now on to what this manga attempts to do, according to the writing and the presentation. The way story’s handled, I believe Sundome tries to be a tragedy centred around Kurumi. She seems to have some fatal disease and what little time she has left in the world she spends trying to make a better man out of Hideo in the most nonsensical and roundabout way possible. This all seems to be a part of the plan for alums or OBs as manga occasionally calls them, but it’s never made clear cause the whole thing about wish granting and evil assassins is nothing more than a plot device to explain some random coincidences. Most of Kurumi’s actions revolve around either setting up challenges for Hideo, for which he gets various erotic rewards or simply using him for her own enjoyment. Most of that ends up with Hideo being rewarded in way or the other, sometimes it’s the ability to touch or lick Kurumi, other times he gets a permission to masturbate or get pissed on. Kurumi’s challenges meanwhile can vary from something simple like fetching water or dragging furniture around to something life/health threatening like having to interact with a violent thug or enduring 20 second in an arm lock with a risk of his arms getting broken.
In the process of all this it becomes clear that Hideo will do absolutely anything, be it dangerous or humiliating, just for the opportunity to be close to Kurumi, let alone do anything more involved. For example there is a moment when he briefly gets an opportunity to live with Kurumi as her pet as long as he never touches his penis. Aiba eagerly agrees and comes to her house with a cardboard box to live inside of and as Kurumi leaves the house he promises to not set foot outside his box. Keeping his promise, he doesn’t even leave for a toilet break and pisses himself. Kurumi’s not mad though, she’s happy cause he’s such a good boy and Aiba is delighted by the result of his obedience.
To be ready for more dangerous or demanding tasks he starts to train and gets a bit stronger. He finds a job to get money he’d spend on Kurumi. His jealousy also makes him a bit more confrontational as he wants to have Kurumi all to himself. Generally all of his improvements centre around being able to make Kurumi happy and service her. In the end that leads to a weird development as author tries to show the payoff in a rather creepy way. The three instances of Hideo actually initiating something is when he forcibly steals a kiss from Kurumi, holds her down to suck mucus out of her nose and one time when lifts her slightly by the shorts to somehow make going uphill easier. That’s supposed to be his big character development and all it just comes off as his lust taking over.
Manga ends with Kurumi suddenly being hospitalized and Hideo breaking her out of it to make her see some special place which ends up being some boring beach. She gets inside a sleeping back and so does Hideo. Her final moments are spent looking at Hideo jerking himself off on top of her. Time goes by, Hideo becomes a doctor and is happily married while keeping Kurumi around as a happy memory.
What it actually is and why it fails?
The concept of their relationship by itself is good. I could be down with a romance story where the goal is to lure protagonist into improving himself as a person, but the way Sundome goes about it doesn’t make sense and is outright disgusting. How can anyone claim Hideo ever truly becomes a better person when up until the very end he is driven forward by nothing but lust? He loves Kurumi unconditionally with slavish devotion. He’s fine with whatever she might do to him even if it kills him, that’s literally one of the things that gets established at a point. Kurumi stops chocking him cause if it was up to him he’d never want her to let go. He didn’t even have a dream to asks OBs about until he met her and decided to be a doctor “so that even if they are last two people on Earth she wouldn’t be in trouble”. So, main theme of their relationship is a complete flop.
The way it’s achieved thought is by far the worst. I have no idea who thought that a flat out abusive relationship can be painted as something good yet Sundome tries real hard. Whenever Hideo gets his reward after being hurt or humiliated is shown as some moment of romantic privacy and unity between the two main characters while in reality it can be Hideo drinking piss as thanks for servicing Kurumi. It’s almost as far from being a healthy relationship as it can be cause Hideo is such an unreasonable person. He shows doubt about his relationship multiple times but it all comes down to him living for the sake of Kurumi and her happiness without ever considering himself. There is even a subplot about Kurumi sleeping with some older man, he’s later revealed to be her doctor and even though it’s not actually said that he didn’t sleep with her it’s what reader will most likely assume. Either way Hideo never actually does anything to change the situation, he never asks Kurumi about him and two times he actually talks to the guy he tells him that Kurumi pisses on him and only him and allows him to drink her piss. So we have this protagonist who’s a massive pushover and constantly gets used in his uneven relationship. He will risk everything to gain very little yet this process is framed as him growing into a better person? That makes about as much sense as clobbering some nerd into a mental breakdown and then saying “well I only wanted to help him become stronger and more confident”. It’s ridiculous but in Sundome it works for no damn reason other than the writer trying to assign some depth to a shitty fan service manga.
And it’s not even good at that either. None of the fetishes in the manga really intersect with mine, so it’s not surprising I didn’t find the erotic part of it all that arousing. But at least I was willing to give it credit for variety. At first it seemed like the author put effort into creating a wide variety of different situations that are both interesting and capitalize on some of the taboos Sundome flaunts, but after a while the scenarios and actions start repeating. Aiba keeps trying to lick some part of Kurumi, he keeps trying to touch a different place or licking her wide variety of body fluids. It all starts to wear off and blend together rather quirk.
With all of this I didn’t expect Kazuto Okada to try and cram in a separate gag manga in all of this. The comedy largely revolves around roman club activities and character interactions that usually awkwardly flow into Aiba and Kurumi doing something perverted before everything is reset back to normal. Personally there were maybe 2 or 3 times Sundome made me laugh across the whole thing. Too many of the jokes just rely on terrible running gags that usually coincides with single defining feature of each character. Kyouko is a gyaru who asks money from people for anything she can, that’s hilarious cause instead of reacting normally she tries to extort money. Ex-president is fascinated with anuses, that’s funny cause haha anus. Aiba is excited about any opportunity to get pissed on by Kurumi and that’s funny cause haha ain’t that weird.
Worth mentioning that there’s also a completely pointless romance subplot between Kyouko and Katsu. Kyouko who used to be an easy lay starts hanging out with nerds at the roman club and eventually starts dating Katsu instead of asshole jocks cause Katsu is just such a nice guy. Their entire relationship could’ve been torn out of the manga and it wouldn’t impact the narrative in any way. If anything it would improve it cause the faster it ends the lighter the torture.
Lastly, the art.
The style is an inconsistent mishmash of SD and stylized but more or less realistic designs that are usually switched up depending on the tone of the scene. Except for ex-president, Katsu and Tatsuya, who are permanently stuck in joke mode even when they’re involved in serious scene, which is jarring as hell.
The general quality of drawing is way below average. At times the proportions are so out of whack that it made me think that any half-decent looking panels in the manga were heavily references and I still think that the author wouldn’t be capable of drawing them without that. There’s also a ridiculous amount of reused expressions and perspectives, it’s pretty obvious that Okada is not a very versatile artist and it really shows when all his emotional scenes usually just feature two or three same faces over and over. It doesn’t help the dramatic impact of those scenes and it looks terrible. There’s also a weird reluctance to draw one of the eyes in many of the shots, sometimes it’s common enough to think that the characters are actual cyclops.
When it comes to ecchi shows the art can make or break it and Sundome breaks fast. Despite all the feedback about this manga talking about how perverted and ecchi heavy this manga is, it’s gonna be one of the tamest I’ve seen. Okada rarely draws characters fully unclothed and when he does I start to understand why. He’s anatomy is not bad enough to be laughable but it’s nowhere near good enough to be titillating either. Erotic drawings are usually about realistic anatomy meeting halfway with exaggerated style and proportions to make the erotic parts stand out more than figuratively and neither is present here.
In conclusion you get Sundome, a terrible romance manga with not a single fleshed out character and a tragic story that makes about as much sense as cutting off your legs to run faster. As if it wasn’t bad enough it’s a comedy without wit and a manga without art worth looking at. I sincerely hope nobody reads this trash.
