Kaicho wa Maid-Sama follows Misaki Ayuzawa, the student body president of Seika High, a school that was once an all boy school. She's sexist (although most people just put it nicely to "boy-hater") but due to her family's circumstances was enrolled there.
Story- 7
It's pretty good. Kaicho wa Maid-Sama has its moments that occur in almost every single shoujo anime, but it's enjoyable. Can't say that Kaicho wa Maid-Sama has the greatest story, it's about a boy-hater who works at a maid cafe, that's it. Yet I found myself enjoying it although this isn't the kind of anime I'd usually watch.
Art- 7
Kaicho has the kind of art style you'd see in anime for little girls. Giant eyes, cute clothing, males that look like adults occasionally. I didn't expect it to be in a romance comedy, a magical girl one was where my head was. It's not the worst, shading is not over-exaggerated or not shaded at all. It just has that "girly-girl" feel to it that makes guys laugh.
Sound- 6
The voice actors fit real well. Even though I haven't read the manga yet, (but I plan to) the voices work. The fact that the voice actors actually say what is written in the background (example- giiiiiiiiii) is kind of annoying. I don't like hearing "tsuku-tsuku" a hundred times during comedic parts. Unlike some people, I found the opening and ending kind of annoying. The "douka, please can you keep my secret" in the beginning is just no. I really love the chorus of that song but everything was meh. As for the ending, it's too rock for a shoujo.
Character- 8
I loved, loved, loved the characters in this. They're more... Realistic? Well, sort of. The characters in Kaicho aren't the super girly or hard-core characters I despise. Misaki has some stereo-typical anime girl traits, like being better than a guy, but not enough to make me hate her. As for Usui, Misaki has got to be a masochist to hang around him. He's got stereo-typical anime-boy-heart-breaker-type-traits but without him, we couldn't see the best of Misaki.
Enjoyment- 10
I really loved this anime even though I wouldn't usually watch it. It's hilarious, it has the official pairings I usually want to see. Kaicho wa Maid Sama is definitely enjoyable.
Overall- 8
This is enjoyable, I can't wait for the next episode. It's not the best but definitely in my top-ten favorite anime list.