White Album is much much more realistic. The scenarios that play out are, while not relatable, unless you have any experience of being in the idol industry or something similar, can be empathized with to an extent and understood. And the main character is also definitely not the shameless wimp that White Album 2's MC is.
And the women in this show, have problems. But they are not made up or trivial or over-dramatized. They all make sense. They were all forcefully tied into the MC, but still that's the way you make an anime - put someone at the center.
I'm sure this anime will be a 10/10 on a number of people's list - people who like tragedies. But it was just plain depressing. And so that completely took out the enjoyment factor for me.
While all that is said and done, this anime is definitely a must watch for any non-casual anime fan.
Skip White Album 2. Stick to this much more believable one.
