I recently finished a rewatch of one of my all time favorite animes (Toradora) and was looking for a new Anime to dive into. After looking through my collection and recognizing the name I started Golden Time (I was pleasantly surprised after a few episodes when I did a precursory search that it was made by the same creator.)
The anime was completely captivating. From the get go I was interested in the characters and drawn into the animation as a whole. And as the episodes carried on I kept saying to myself "one more episode" or "I need to know what's going on." Which is something I look for when watching an anime.
As a fan of Romantic Comedy/Dramas, this one hit the nail on the head for me and I enjoyed it immensely. Without spoiling anything, if you're looking for an anime with an enjoyable cast that will tug at your heartstrings then this is the one for you.