Story-8
It's difficult resume Madoka's plot, especially without spoiling it. What I can say is that the story was very well-told in only 12 episodes and is full of interesting concepts. When you finish an episode, you'll certainly want to watch the next one.
Art-8
The art of Madoka is one of the main qualities of the show. The animation was fluid and I loved the psychodelic and purposely grotesque witches. The character designs, on the other hand, are somewhat unatractive, but you soon get used to them.
Sound-9
The sound of the anime was totally awesome! The voice acting really fitted the characters and the songs are catchy and memorable.
Character-8
Madoka is definitely a plot-driven show, but that doesn't mean that the characters can't be good, because they are! Despite being somewhat clichéd and stereotypical, each of the characters have their own flaws, insecurities and motivations for their actions(even Kyuubei!)
Enjoyment-8
While the show is generally overrated (no, I don't think it's the best anime of the 21st Century) and VERY angsty, it's worth watching for all the reasons I've already cited.
