I had written this review just before the last episode, so it got removed like other reviews written before a series ends. So I still feel the same way about it and have nothing significant to change :)
Overview:
Let me first say that not everyone will enjoy this anime. Which is perfectly fine. The start of the series is slowly paced, which I believe turned many off. It is somewhat understandable considering in this genre would have you to expect OP main characters, fast pacing, etc. In other words your basic seasonal SAO clone. Yet I believe this anime has the best storytelling I have ever come across so far. The art is original and new and the soundtrack is absolutely wonderful. This anime is more character development focused, so some might find that to be boring. But for me personally, this work is absolutely gorgeous and enjoyable, but you have to stick with it.
Story 9/10
I have thoroughly enjoyed this anime's story. The beginning started slow, and continued to creep along. Then all of sudden, BAM! An unexpected twist that just comes out of the blue. It was like someone slamming the accelerator down in a car, but then just as fast hitting the brakes. The writers skillfully had you relax and watch without expectation. Then proceeded to delivered a sucker punch and I don't think anyone saw it coming. Some people would argue that the character was unimportant and lame etc. But, his....fate helped to develop the other characters substantially.
The story then takes a slowish/medium pacing whilest a new character is introduced. Again, this anime is very much so focused on character development, which can take time. It continues this pace until the last episodes where they face their biggest fears and obstacles. I, once again, believe that the finale, and build up to it, were executed in a thrilling and exciting way.
The story can be slow. Some might consider it to drag at points. However I believe it to be enjoyable, always looking forward for the next episode.
Characters 9/10
Character development is the center of this anime. That being said, in the beginning they are all weak and somewhat fickle. Many people thought some of the characters were uninteresting, bland, and illogical at the start. However, at the end, the characters had grown strong and dependable. They somehow made you want to root for them. One of the coolest things is how the characters behave in a way that is somehow more human than other anime. They mourn when they should mourn. They're scared when it's appropriate to be scared. They are happy when times are good, but still have that gloominess that is comparable to when you have something you must do but you keep pushing it off. Most anime characters seem to be based off ideals rather than reality. I believe the characters here have a human like quality that many anime lack.
Art 10/10
This anime is freaking gorgeous imo. It looks like it was colored with Copic markers and colored pencils. The backgrounds have a sketchy quality to them which gives it a more human feel. You would usually expect perfect straight lines which seem more computer generated than normal. The characters clothes change many times which is unusual for anime or animation in general. I found that once again, gives it that more personal feeling. The great animation is combined with great camera angles during fighting scenes makes it a joy to watch. tl;dr It looks awesome.
Sound 9/10
The soundtrack along with the voice is just amazing. The voices are again, more human-like than other anime. No ultra high pitched voices or over masculine sounding ones. They sound just..normal. The music is amazing as well. I like the calm guitar parts during dialog and whatnot which are contrasted by the fast paced rock pieces during the fight scenes. The opening and ending songs are awesome too. I especially enjoy the opening with the cool violin (probably more appropriate to call fiddle in the case) in the intro of the opening. I don't have much more to say than that I can't wait till the OST comes out :3
Conclusion:
I have very much so enjoyed the ride. The story pacing was just right for the job. The characters slowly build themselves into strong ones. The art is amazing and the music is to die for. Some might find the slowness to be annoying and boring. But, you know, if everyone had the same tastes, likes or interests, it be a boring world.
I gave this anime a 10 because I enjoyed it so much and it really struck a chord with me and I hope it can do the same for you.
