I just finished watching and I'm giving the story an 8 because it was very good but not as good as some other stories I've seen. Soul Eater is not a typical shonen so it was very unique in that.
Art: 7
Soul Eater has a somewhat simplistic art style but it's very clean, however not very detailed. I didn't like the art at first but I grew use to it. It's actually pretty cool after a while
Sound: 9
I love the Soul Eater openings and endings. I have them downloaded on my ipod and I listen to them every day. Great soundtrack. Great voices. Yahoo.
Character: 10
Soul Eater is known for its characters. (So if you ever see a low character rating on this anime, they hated it). Maka, Soul, Black Star, Tsubaki, Kid, etc. are all amazing characters. I loved them all. However there are some annoying ones...... "FOOLS!"
Enjoyment: 8
It was a great anime and I enjoyed it. However, at first, two episodes in and I was bored. I put the anime on pause. Now, about a year later, I'm back watching it and after the first few episodes I really got into it. So I'm giving it an 8.
Overall: 8
I think it's a great anime. Very popular and you should definitely watch!
Give it a try at least!
