Story (10/10)
I personally found the story to be absolutely excellent. For about the first half, the anime feels like it is going to be a typical adventure anime following the two main characters on their trial. However, other events occur in the background surrounding a much more ominous enemy. This all begins to wind together, involving the students, and before I knew it there was this insane plot device. It all leads up to a really awesome ending that is climactic and satisfying.
Art(8/10)
The art is quirky and strange. It is all set to this halloweeny feel with the characters, theme, and environment. The animation is smooth, and the battles are really bad ass.
Sound(8/10)
From the amazing intros down the the sounds of the scythe, the audio is really good. The sound effects are spot on and the voice acting is really well done.
Character(8/10)
As expected from a shounen, there is really good character development for all of the characters as they grow to become more mature and overcome their struggles. I also just really enjoyed the cast. Aside from Black Star, I liked all of the characters, and I was always hoping for the best for them.
Enjoyment(8/10)
With a good blend of comedy, intense action, and deep story, I found this anime to be really fun to watch. I never felt overwhelmed, but at the same time the anime never lost its focus on the story. There was also very limited filler, which is always nice to see.
In the end, I am giving Soul Eater a 9/10 because it is great. The show is entertaining, well directed, and well written. I recommend this to anyone looking for something a little unique with an interesting story and characters. However, if you are looking for something that will change your soul, this isn't for you, this is still just a typical shounen.
