Reviews

Jul 18, 2015
Mixed Feelings
I don't know what's with KyoAni lately, but they keep undershooting my expectations. KnK had shitty writing, Free2 was riddled with melodrama and both it and Chuuni overstayed their welcome, Amagi Brilliant Park was the fanservicey kind of nonsense I'd expect JC Staff to pick up, and Hibike Euphonium was kinda boring, despite not having bad writing and production. It was really great at first, but then it never picked up the pace. I know I said I wished K-On had more actual music, but applying this to orchestral music here didn't really do anything for me. Each time show dealt with actual music and practice I just wanted it to skip to the character development, conflict and drama instead, or even random comedy gags. Didn't think I'd see the day when I'd call the music in KyoAni show mediocre. I don't hate orchestral, nor do I particularly like it, but I do love modern orchestral. And this wasn't modern at all, and I feel it would have benefited from it.

As far as the actual story goes, there's nothing to talk about, as it's LN based and suffers from being underdeveloped and unfinished. We met some characters, learned about their relationships, there was some ship tease, some drama, half of which was okay, half of it meh, then there was a lot of practicing and a concert finale and... that's it really, nothing touching, nothing memorable, nothing engaging or compelling, at least to me. There wasn't enough conflict, and what conflict there was most often felt petty. I suppose it was a story about trying really hard, but that theme has been so overdone by shounens that I'm kinda tired of it, and Euphonium doesn't really make a compelling case for it. It's just okay regardless of how I look at it.

The highlight of the show is that it had some characters that were really really great, namely Kumiko, Reina and Asuka, which pretty much carried the show. I also loved the way Noboru was portrayed, but I can't help feeling his character wasn't explored enough to realize its potential. Kumiko-Reina relationship was by far my favorite part of Euphonium, so not having any of that really resolved by the end felt rather disheartening. Overall, an okay show is not what I would expect from KyoAni.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice Nice0
Love it Love it0
Funny Funny0
Show all
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login