This show might seems mediocre to regular people, but for us, loners it's something we can find ourselves in. Not another show where two girls fight about one random guy, but story about lost fish that found soulmate in the eternal ocean of plain people.
Apart from the first season, this seems much more serious, but it didn't really reveal much, thus i rate with 8 points for story.
Art was very good indeed, but this is one of the elements that first season was better at. 8 points
Sound was great, brought nice or sad atmosphere just where it was required. Also the opening was one of the few i could not skip. 9 points.
Characters were what made this anime so good. God i would have rated them at least with 12 points, but i sadly i cannot. Hachiman is loner and one young philosopher. Others are long dead to him.
Raised in the world where fakes are not accepted he adapted, hardened and build walls where only his little sister was allowed enter. He is genius in his own way, he knows how people behave, what do they think because everybody is so simple, yet even there are exeptions and he finds himself lost when trying to read certain girl.
Yukinoshita is very beatiful girl, everyone admires her, yet she finds herself hated, bullied in the past just because of jealousy and her unability to fit between the fakes.
There is it, the beauty and the beast, both excluded from society for many different reasons, but the one main reason remains the same - they weren't able to fit in to the society
10 points for totally outstanding characters (Still at least 12 in my head tho ^^)
Enjoyment - well not much to say about this what already haven't been said. I enjoyed this show very much, every episode kept me entertained. 10 points.
Overall - Characters are keeping this anime high above most of the shows i've watched, this anime deserves spot in my top anime list with it's 10 points.
Now there's nothing left but to wait for another season (well maybe if i get impatient i could read the VN, but i think that i'll wait for anime).
