Story 9/10
Although centered around a very down to earth topic. Through a unique setting the story takes on an appeal that rivals the universes we've seen come out of shonen jump in the past. Using all the tricks both an ecchi and shonen reader can expect. It's funny and intense, and comes with an edge bordering on survival territory. Yet I feel that this manga will be very limited in its appeal if you want to laugh and jump around in excitement this is perfect. If you want a depth of emotion like sadness and rage then maybe this isn't the one for you (but don't outright ignore it). Just try to remember "Shokugeki no Souma is a cooking manga"
Art 9/10
There is only so much you can do with black and white. Especially when you're writing about something that requires a certain degree of detail. Yet with an array of colour chapters to indulge in and the amazing detail throughout it becomes very hard to mark it down for it. The writer uses a style that truly captures the intensity of the work and that's all I can ask for. Plus it gets bonus points for including both male and female fan-service.
Character 10/10
This is where the manga truly is in a league of its own. There are so many amazing characters with their own: origins, personalities and desires. It is very difficult to find someone that is universally hated in this series because they all have strengths and weaknesses that anyone can relate to. From the awesome MC to his entourage of enemies and friends; the development of each is superbly thought out and though exaggerated feel incredibly realistic. One final note of perfection is how well each style of cooking reflects the personality of the character. from Nikumi's aggression as a meat chef to the Aldini brothers' speed and precision as Italian cooks.
Enjoyment 10/10
With all these superb elements it is very difficult not to enjoy this manga. I for one love it. It is an amazing epic that still has a few years worth of story left in it to keep me interested. (it's been 2 years and we're only half way through 1st year). With the anime adaption now well under way there is a lot to keep you going. It started out as a casual interest and turned into the highlight of my week in just a few chapters.
Overall 10/10
to quote one of the chapters. "I give you an A only because I don't have the authority to give you something higher". This manga has filled every possible desire I could have, so all it can do now is continue to impress and exceed my already bloated appetite for the series.
